Fight Now, or Wait for or Wait 'big Battalions?
Socialist Organiser1980 1980-05-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Wing us for two reasons. —In the first piace, SO cannot go on silently tolerating disloyal attacks such as yours. And in the second place, to define our differences and clear away misunderstandings (if such there be) will help perhaps to prepare unity in action against our common enemies where that is possible.
Most of what I have to say implies that you have much in common with SO - if that were not so, there would be no point in the letter.
Our root difference lies in being surcharged or disqualified) you pass on • the Tory cuts, translated into cuts in income by rent and rate rises. You refuse to stand and fight the Tories now, and cling to the power to decide from which area of working class income the siphoning-off should take place.
This is the essential truth, even if some redistribution of income to the working class of Lambeth may occur from the high proportion of Lambeth rates raised from business premises. And of course you know that rate rises are not a way of avoiding indefinitely the choice of cuts or taking on the Government.
In pursuit of your lopsided vision again, you have turned Lambeth Council into a major school of reformist class collaboration for Lambeth and the London labour movement. You teach responsibility, , confinement to the parameters and options laid down by the Tory government (until the "big battalions' of Labour kick the Tories out), to justify and explain the choices you make and advocate within those parameters.
To justify your rate-rise poliçies you refer to powers above you that you dare not take on or challenge at fundamental level. Isn't this capitalism, and therefore that only if the anti-capitalist movement spread to contries like France and Germany could there be the possibility of stabilising the workers' power.
Immediately after taking power, the British workers state. would face a very difficult period. It we apply your argument about Lambeth -supposedly under the control of the Left and those like you who present themselves as revolutionaries — to Britain, it is an argument not to take power until the big battalions of France and Germany' lead... It is an old, old argument of the more aware reformists and reactionaries in the labour movement, to justify their own passivity and accommodation.
In your interview with the Chartist magazine (MarchMay 1980) you say you hope to avoid cuts on top of the rate rises. You base this on the belief ('perspective") that the labour movement will fight the Tories and drive them from office. (You seem to have a maximum time scale of one year for this -it must happen 'before April 1981'). The clear implication is that if we don't fight, or if we fight and don't win, then you will probably have to cut.
But this is the perspective' you had in July 1979 ley in 1973 calling for a general strike - when he was trying to convince the miners they they alone should not take on the Tories?
In the second place, following from the above, it has nothing to do with a Marxist idea of 'perspective' - it is nothing but passive expectation and hope. STRUGGLE Your conception of the role and responsibilities of a militant is remarkably like that of the Militant tendency. What is to be the role of the leader of Lambeth council in the battle to dislodge the Tories? Of Lambeth Council itself? Is is to be a bastion of Left strength and working-class strength (which it could be perhaps, but is not now), or is it to be preserved at all costs from possible damage in the struggle?
Your vision of the struggle against the Tories is of a purely industrial struggle -to be initiated and waged by others. The industrial struggle will come to your rescue and meanwhile 'the Leader' administers • Lambeth (humanely). If the rescue does not come in time you will have to consider administering it (less humanely) by making cuts. I suspect that this syndilabour movement clash with the Tory government then you would be less timid in face of the Government (and feel less need to lash out at the Left). And if you were still a militant, you would not shirk the personal risks (surcharge, lisqualification as a councillor, gaol) of confrontation with the government, if that could give a lead to the movement.
Of course one understands the psychological Icgic of someone switching from the mindless voluntarism of the late-'60s SLL to Militant-style passive perspectives'. But the fact remains that either you no onger see any role for your self in the struggle, or that you do not believe in 'the perspective' you enunciate. Which?
Before you tried to identify sO with the Right, you should have remembered the proverb, 'One does not speak of the rope in the house of the hanged'. For though you need to present yourself as one who is hounded by the Right, in fact you seem to have much better relations with the Right (in Lambeth and in London) than you have with the revolutionary Left. For example, a few minutes of discussion between yourself, pocket calculator in hand, and the Right, sufficed to determine the size of rate increase in Lambeth.
Last July - and we have seen what perspectives you had then — when you decided to carry out cuts, you gave a much appreciated signal to every right wing council have seemed to everyone present to be your politics too.
At a conference on the cuts called by the SCLV in June 1979, you may have been decisive in persuading the majority to opt for rate rises aS the only alternative to cuts. A couple of weeks later you tried to cut as well as raising rates.
That you considered cuts an immediate option when made those 'militant' speeches seems more or less certain. Were you just saying the "popular thing' at conference bamboozle people that rate rises were an alternative to cuts - or don't you know from one day to the next what you will do?
Again. In the recent interview with Chartist magazine, you pronounce yourself against rent increases - about a week before you impose an average increase of about £1.50 a week on the working-class tenants of Lambeth Council.
How would you go about arguing that this is not the record of one who knowingly fakes?
Finally, one of the central things about the role and contradictions I have discussed above is, I think, that you necessarily have a purely personalist view of politics man alone in a very loose social democratic party, VOU must protect yourself from surcharge, jail, disqualification. What is 'the Leader of Lambeth' if he can no longer be even a councillor?
The Clay Cross councillors took on the Heath Government and when the first 11' were victimised, "second 11' came forward. They were art of a fighting community aen one could confidently say, "If I go down, there are others to come after me". . They behaved as great working class fighters, and dealt blows to the GovernBut you, comrade Knight, are an individual operating through loose alliances,
----- pull-quotes -----
ment out of all proportion to Clay Cross's size.