Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[calist' (for other people) view of the struggle…]

Socialist Organiser no. 19, May 1980 · scan p. 8 · about 608 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

calist' (for other people) view of the struggle is probably central to your present outlook. For it you conceived of the struggle as demandir g the mobilisation of working class communities, tenants, etc. then you could not blithely raise rents and rates.

In the third and final place, I suspect you do not believe in your own perspective' You do not at all act like a man who takes his own ideas seriously.

If decisive class battles are in the offing, then a serious militant would feel a strong need to find his own role in the struggle, to help develop it, perhaps to spark it (because there are no grounds for confidence in the leaders of the "big battalions' as leaders in the workingclass struggle against tue lories).

Your only conclusion from the 'perspective' is that is is a licence to hang on in Lambeth. It is no more than an alibi for time-serving now. (The parallel with Militant is quite striking here If you really believed in the likelihood of a decisive had given you a national standing as a foremost op ponent of the Tories and their cuts, and you had a solid base of support.

Two months (!) after the election, when the movement was still feeling its way on how to deal with the Tories, when many people looked to Lambeth's 'Red Knight' signa lead, You ave it tar signalled, and clear: 'Surrender', 'cut.

You said the 'big battalions' had not moved to bring down the Government, SO you had no choice but to surrender. And every right wing council in the country breathed a sigh of relief.

The revolt of the Lambeth Labour Parties soon forced you to rescind the cuts. (In my opinion you do not have a right to the lavish self-praise for 'democratic accountability which you now ussing this episode. A right winger or a Tribunite might have: not someone with your But it one wants the outstanding recent example of leftists helping the Right, and even momentarily politically amalgamating with them (under cover of "left' flak), then that was surely it, comrade Knight.

It is, I have suggested, this sort of contradiction between what you do and what you she left dangerous (and per- say that makes criticism from haps painful for you. unaware are you of the contradiction? The record without stable political base, and not one of a group of revolutionaries. You cannot think that you are replaceable not at rate with equanimity. You have only the weapons of manoeuvre and manipulation. You are increasingly driven by the contradictions in your position to resort to the arts of the 'fake left" and to the use of techniques like 'the amalgam'.

Without being part of a serious political organisation, you have advanced to high political office, to a key position in the London labour movement. Faced with the prospect of a fight you feel weak and isolated; faced with capitulation - with betraying your whole political life you vacillate and try manoeuvre, and lash out at the revolutionary Left.

The name the Marxist movement has given to the type of political course you have chosen is adventur ism. It is a process whereby the one-time professional revolutionary can sink into being a professional leader of a safe Labour council.

The point where you find yourself using Stalinist techniques against the revolutionary Left should be the point where you take stock. Events are likely to TOVe fast in the period ahead. You are probably much further along the road to being a professional councillor, and more distant from being a revolutionary, than you know vourself to be

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 19

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →