Organise for May 14
Socialist Organiser1980 1980-05-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
the trade union leaders much less energetically than the Tory press campaign against it.
TUC leaders say they want jas many workers as possible out... but not a general strike! Translate that bit of wriggling into plain language, and they want enough action to give them some bargaining strength with the Tories, but not so much as to pull them into an all-out class Add to that the bureaucrats' inbred reluctance to do more than pass resolutions and put out circulars, In an open letter to Lambeth council leader Ted Knight, John O'Mahony replies to Knight's recent attacks on S and our policy against cuts and rate rises.
DEAR COMRADE KNIGHT, I decided to write you this open letter when I read your article Build a wall of unityacross London in London Labour Briefing. It was perhaps due in any case.
From being chairman of the July 1978 conference which founded the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, and an early supporter of Socialist Organiser, you have adopted a more and more antagonistic, rancorous and splenetic attitude to us.
You long ago abandoned the position against rent and rate rises adopted without opposition at the July 1978 SCLV conference, and we
Express has been running a campaign against the TUC's May 14th Day of Action.
Stridently pretending to be
the voice of the common folk, the Express protests: "Lenin(!) Murray and all the Bully Boys are manipulating the people just for political aims.
*The Daily Express has the same message for Lenin Murray as it has for anyone who unfairly seeks to impose his will on the British people.. Get lost!"
*Millions of trade unionists have never been consulted by the TUC bigwigs" they say, failing to mention that the Day of Action was and you have picture of the problems mobilising for May 14th.
A few unions are instructing their members to come out: SOGAT, the Tobacco Workers' Union, the Fire Brigades Union. The NUR is calling on all members other than safety staff "to give maximum support by striking' on the 14th Other print unions will probably find their workplaces shut down by the SOGAT action, and are making slightly weaker calls. The
by EEPTU General Secretary Frank Chapple.
Unfortunately for both of them, this unholy alliance
gave the lie to the Express's protests about democracy, and to Chapple's protests about May 14th weakening the trade union movement.!
Chapple's article is headlined: "Make no mistake, this is the road to dictatorship". • He should know...
Chapple's union is about the most undemocratic in Britain. It has just suspended one of its largest branches in Cardiff, for the stated reason that it is controlled by left-wingers. is run like a mini police state. NGA 'asks members to lend full support. The NUt will 'encourage' its members to strike. NATSOPA does not expect its members to be available for work'. SLADE invites its members to take action' Some other unions are giving similar relatively strong support. The National Union of Seamen is 'strongly recommending' a work stoppage. The TGWU National Passenger Services Committee is calling a strike, and the Construction and Automotive groups 'expect their members to stay away. (The TGWU as a whole confines itself to 'support for the strain workers' loyalty to the TUC and thus weaken the movement... why does he have to go to the rightwing Tory Express to voice it? Why is it Margaret Thatcher who congratulates him the next day on an "excellent article"?
While the Express has provided the froth, Chapple provided the basic argument. 'Democracy cannot functior if Government policies are to be changed, not through the ballot box, but through the disruption of industry by political strikes"
So workers have no choice but to put up with hospital closures, school cutbacks, Day of Action'.)
NUPE 'calls on" its members (other than those on emergency services) to come out, and CoSE 'supports' strike action. So do UCATT, the Boilermakers, and the CPSA.
The GMWU is 'support ing' stoppages of the whole day or halt day, depending onl what is appropriate' The NUT will support half-day strikes.
Other unions have a weaker policy. The Bakers "invite their members activities, to support local • NALGO asks its members to coordinate with other local action. but authorises"
cil as a 'cutter "Both groups see the danger of acknowledging that an independent left wing coun cil can defy the Tory government and maintain a policy off refusing to cut any service, or job, or job opportunity....
AMALGAM "Finally they declare Lambeth councillors to be traitors because they have put up council rents. After a three-year rent freeze, and a manifesto commitment limiting such a standstill to a period of wage restraint, Lambeth councillors were faced with a clear risk of surcharge if they refused to make an increase The technique you use here has long been a prize exhibit in the black museum of working-class history. It is the Stalinist technique dubbed 'the amalgam' by Trotsky in the 1930s when it was used to poison the labour move. ment against the Trotskyists by 'amalgamating' their politics and criticism of Stalinism with those of the kight, and pretending that Right and revolutionary Left were in some mysterious way identical.
Just what has the position of SO to do with the Right? They are unhappy with rate rises and prefer cuts instead; we oppose cuts and oppose rent and rate rises because we think they are a variety of cuts. What is there in common. Nothing whatsoever except that Ted Knight and resents and fears the Not to publicati now put
do not override the class struggle. When the bosses and bankers are dissatisfied, they apply pressure fast
enough. The IMF bankers giving their instructions to the Labour government in 1976 did not think of waiting until a general election. Neither can or should the working class.
The Express screams that May 14th 'is an attempt to bring down a government by, some kind of mob rule. They are exaggerating for the sake of sensation. But what if May 14th should be a step forward in organising for an all-out general strike which does bring down the strikes.
And a few big unions aré hardly supporting the Day of Action at all. The AUEW national committee resolution! supporting it had a specific mention of 'industrial action" deleted. The EETPU has attacked the Day of Action and left it up to individual members to decide what to do.
When I phoned the TUC press office they had no information on the NUM other than what they had read in the press. The NUM press office told me they were "supporting the TUC" •Will members who strike have the support of the Tnigit: SO united with tile right wing criticism of the Left. spent a considerable part of Comrade Knight, you your life in the Trotskyist movement. (It is no secret, and you have not declined to talk to the capitalist press about it). 23 years ago you were a business manager of Labour Review* which exposed and helped clear away the mountains of Stalinist lies and amalgams which had suffocated the Marxists between the '30s and '50s.
Many SO readers will find it hard even to imagine how effectively — for quarter of a century - the system of ideological terrorism based on lies and amalgams' was in poisoning the moral, political, and intellectual life of the labour movement, and in isolating the Trotskyists. You however must remember it. Like everyone who lived through even part of that period as a Marxist, you learned to hate the mendacity, the demagogy, and the be confused with the on of the same name out by the WRP. unid won the that
on the workers' organisations coming out of a great general strike, then that would mean more demo-.
cracy, more real controli by working people over how society is run!
That is what the Express means by "mob rule" Underneath the fake "voice of the people" act, the real hatred of the Express is directed not so much against Murray and the TUC leaders as against the active and militant sections of the working class.
And at root they would rather see the trade unions crushed. Speaking the language of war, the Express ht "No". "So they 't have the support of union?" "I didn't say either".
Beal
Some areas of the NUM are, however, expected to call their members out. -In the biggest unions, especially, the turn-out on May 14th will depend almost entirely on the effort put in by rank and tile activists. Let's make sure it's a bigger turnout than the bureaucrats want - one that really begins to beat the Tories back.
COLIN FOSTER lack of political scruple of your smear is modest enough compared with what the Stalinists did. And there is no Lambeth GPU. But in principle it is no different. Nor, 1 suspect, is it different in intent.
When spleen against your left critics leads you to use this foul and dishonourable technique, then perhaps it is time you took a cool look at where you have arrived politically now - and at where you are going.
Your smear on SO results, I suggest, from the fact that there is a major and increasing contradiction between your projection of yourself (and, perhaps, how you think of yourself, as a man of the revolutionary Left, and the actual political role you now play. You now occupy a position not too far from what we used to call a 'fake left' Your talk is a great deal more "left' than are your actions.
You feel any challenge to your credibility keenly because you know it to be vulnerable. When you say -on what basis? - that we call you a 'traitor', , one wonders. if the accusing voice you hear is not inside your ownhead. We have not callea you a traitor. You are seriously failing to be a revolutionary militant, but you are not yet a traitor.
continued on p.8
----- pull-quotes -----
ress May 14 is being organised by
wants to present himself as being hounded by the Right
those who used 'the amalg- amp course, the content of