Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Their electoral college and ours

Socialist Organiser no. 21, July 1980 · scan p. 3 · about 1,205 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

Why a broad electoral college? Vladimir Derer explains ONLY A SMALL minority in the Party, primarily MPs and the AUEW leadership, are still convinced that the present method of choosing the Party Leader should. be retained.

The majority of Labour Party members, including many conservatively-minded trade union leaders, now accept that it should be changed and that the Party Leader must be elected by a body more representative than the Parliamentary Labour Party. The debate has been going on in the Party for some five years and a number of options have emerged.

The election of the leader by Conference appears to many the obvious and most logical option. The great majority of the NEC members are elected by Conterence; why should the Leader be the exception? If it is desirable to increase the authority of Conference, why not make the Party Leader accountable to it?

Politics, however, seldom follows formal logic. To change political structures, more is needed than a Fabian blueprint. The immediate problem is not to devise the ideal constitution, but to gain support for proposals which would be acceptable to Conference in 1980 and come as near as possible to introducing direct accountability of the Leader to Conference.

At present the election of the Party Leader by Conference does not stand an outside chance. When this was proposed in 1978 it received less than 7% of the votes cast. (457,000 for, 6,084,000 against) Last year a substantial majority of the 26 Conference resolutions and amendments on the leadership favoured an electoral college. Only five opted for election by Conference. This proposal was not put to Conference.

The proposal for an electoral college, however, was. It was lost only because one of the AUEW delegates unexpectedly voted against it in his delegation's meeting, and thus produced a tie. This, in turn, enabled Terry Duffy to use his casting vote and prevent the resolution in favour of the college from being carried.

Furthermore, the submissions of all the major unions to the Commission of Inquiry show that they are opposed to the election of the Leader by Conference. But the union leaderships now accept that the election of the Leader by the PLP alone is not satisfactory, though they still believe that the PLP should have a considerabie say in who is chosen.

Above all, they seem anxious not to be put into a position where a deal between a few union leaders would make the result of the 'election' a foregone conclusion. This appears to be the reason why the union leaders serving on the Commission of Inquiry put forward the electoral college formula which gave the PLP 50% of all the votes.

Fortunately this proposal is proving unworkable: the Commission's drafting committee has been unable to agree about the detail of the provisions. This is not surprising. It takes more to devise a satisfactory constitutional compromise than it does to reach a satisfactory result in wage negotiations.

On the one hand the trade union leaders on the Commission agreed to take away from the PLP the exclusive power to elect the Party Leader. On the other hand, to make this palatable to the PLP - and to guarantee continued safety to the Labour establishment they also decided to diminish the power of the NEC and implicitly that of the rank and file.

If the new structure were to be able to perform independently of conference the two new functions assigned to it, i.e. to elect the Leader and act as final arbiter on the Manifesto, then it had to be small, both to deny direct representation to CLPs, all MPs and all affiliated organisation, as well as to enable it to be convened at short notice to endorse the Manifesto.

The requirement that the college be small (a figure around 100 members was suggested) immediately presented difficulties. How were the 50 MPs to represent the PLP, the 25 irade unionists to iepreser: == 50 affiliated constitueno **=.::

to represer: : - = = .:

bechaseIn practice, an electoral college cannot reflect the true preferences of MPs and CLPs unless they are all given a vote, nor can it reflect those of affiliated organisations unless each of them is given at least one vote. If elementary democratic principles are to be observed a small college is, therefore, a non-starter.

There are two other proposals for an electoral college - one prepared by CLPD, and the other floated originally by Neil Kinnock and now favoured by several members of the NEC.

Both are geared to a large and representative assembly i.e. Conference. The Kinnock proposal gives the TUs, the PLP and the CLPs 33% each of the voting strength, whereas the CLPD's gives 50% to trade unions and socialist societies, with the remaining 50% being shared between the PLP and CLPs.

Thus the Kinnock proposal is slightly more generous to the PLP and CLPs, and might appeal to those trade union leaders who do not wish to appear to be kingmakers.

The main drawback of Kinnock's "three-thirds" proposal is that, unlike that of the CLPD (which bas already been submitted by several constituencies i tre form of a ecstational ameriter: . as =o: been = is: = s. I #71 the NEC Conferions condemning the failure of those unions" loaders -Clive Jenkins, Bill Koys, Moss Evans -to stand up for union policy and for democratic reforms on the Inquiry. * Explain to trade unionists that this -fight for Labour democracy is not just an obscure internal affair of the Party, but the essential political back-up to the direct trade union struggle to kick out the Tories and defend workers' Interests. Draw industrial militants in to join the fight for socialist policios.

RFMC model resolution welcome the Commit bion oh Enquiry's recommendation that last year's conference decision on mandatory reselection be upheld. It urges the NEU to submit to conterence the necessary consequentia. amendment.

•'This CLP/Branch also welcomes the Commission's recognition of the need for expanding the electorate of the leader of the party. However, it deplores the proposed structure of the electoral college, which would make the PLP dominant and underrepresent the trade unions and constituency parties. It therefore calls on the NEC to submit to conterence pro• ›osals for an electoral college which would give an equal say to the political and industrial wings of the movement, give a vote to every MP or candidate, to every CLP and every affiliated organisation, and thereby ensure the accountability of the Leader to the Party.

"Further, this CLP/Trade Union branch condemns the aibiposal that the respon- the vested in the electoral college, thus further depriving conference of any effective influence on future government policies. It therefore urges the NEC to put down a constitutional amendment in line with the 1979 conference decision on the manifesto.

"Finally, this CLP/TU branch rejects the proposa. that the 3 year rule, abolished by conference last yeat, should be reintroduced, for constitutional issues. The current debate on the 3 main constitutional issues shows that the party may need longer than 1 year to decide what is desirable. This artificial distinction between constitutional and other issues would unnecessarily restrict debate and may land the Party with an undesired solution.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 21

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →