A Mass Party?
Socialist Organiser1980 1980-07-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
THE LABOUR Party was created to 'secure for the workers by hand or by brain the full fruits of their industry! • About 25 million people in Britain come into the category of 'workers by hand or by brain' - that is, they sell their labour in order to live.
But of those 25 million, only 7 million are affiliated members of the Labour Party through their trade unions. And fewer than 400,000 (at the most optimistic calculation) are individual members of the Party which was created to serve their interests.
So the Labour Party is hardly a 'mass party', in spite of the fact that about 12 million people vote Labour at each General Election. Each one of those 12 million is a potential Labour Party member. How can we go about recruiting this vast and virtually untapped reservoir of Labour support?
Much play is made (particularly in the media) of the 'disproportionate' power wielded by the trade unions in the Party, especially in the form of block votes at Party Conference. The old answers to this argument still hold good: the trade unions created the Party, and to a considerable extent finance it; furthermore, trade union members choose to pay the political levy, and have the right to a say in Party affairs, through their union, just as much as any individual Party member.
But (in spite of the persuasive voice of the media to the contrary) there is no real conflict between tradeunion affiliated members and CLP activists. After all, the CLP activists are trade unionists, too!
But there is a vast discrepancy between the number of affiliated members and the number of individual members, because the trade unions have made a much more successful job of recruitment than the CLPs have so far been able to do.
The answer is to draw as many as possible of the 12 million Labour voters into individual membership of the Labour Party - that is, to boost the voice of the constituencies, rather than diminish the legitimate voice of the trade unions. How can this be done?
The problem certainly cannot be solved by administrative changes alone, or even by changes in the Party Constitution. There is a need for mass participation by ordinary people. What do these 12 million people have in common? They work. So where better to draw them into the Party than in their places of work?
This is not a new idea. It has been tested on a small scale. And it was a success.
During the, 1939-45 war, the Party organisation collapsed in many areas, partly due to wartime collaboration between political parties. There was no organised collection of subscriptions, and very little official activity by the membership within the CLPs.
Such was the situation in Coventry, an engineering centre of the war effort.
I raised the question of creating a 'factory branch' of the Labour Party in the factory where I worked (Daimler Browns Lane). The Midland Regional Council of the Party agreed to approach the NEC with the proposition, and eventually a Factory Branch came into being on an experimental basis.
I found it easy, Shop against reform.
But even unions like the Haven droom ai have their TGWU ASTMS ( Steward, to make individual members of the Party in the factory, and I was able to collect their Party subscriptions at the same time as I collected their trade-union subs. Many of the new individual members were of course also contracted-in members of the Party, through paying the political levy to the Engineers' Union.
Within a few weeks, there were about 100 individual members in this one factory. We held meetings in one of the coaches which brought the workers to the factory, and this was parked in the firm's car park.
It held 36 seated and about 12 standing, which was adequate for an average lunchtime meeting. We met once a week, and held discussions on a wide variety of political and trade-union issues, including the kind of Britain we wanted after the War. We paid the membership subs into the Coventry Labour Party. We had no direct representation there, but we sometimes worked out resolutions and sent them te the local Party.
This factory branch continued for about a year, until I was sacked by Daimler as a Toolroom Shop Steward, and shortly afterwards the branch folded up.
In my opinion, this was a valuable experiment in the building of the Party, and I am convinced that the same idea could succeed again, although on a regularised basis, with more formal links between the workplace branch and the local Party.
Such branches would be successful for the same reason that an on-site trade union branch is often more successful than an off-site one - people are at work anyway, available for meetings say, lunch-time or at the end of a shift, and they are less likely to be seducer away from political activities by television, family commitments, etc. than if they first go home and then have to set out for a meeting.
The detailed arrangements would of course have to be a matter for wide discussion within the Party, but the following ideas could prove to a satisfactory basis for opening talks about workplace branches.
Officers of the workplace branch would be responsible for the collection of membership subscriptions, which would be paid into the CLP in which the workplace was situated. Such a branch would have the right to elect delegates to the CLP in the same way as wards or trade union branches, and they could forward resolutions to the CLP, MP or NEC in the same way as any other constituent body of the Party.
Some CLP members may object to the fact that a workplace branch would be sending delegates to the CLP who would be representing Labour Party members who in fact lived outside their constituency. But we have lived with such a procedure for many years with regard to trade union branches, whose membership may be drawn from a number of constituencies, and no harm appears to have come of that! (Providing their delegate lives within the constituency)
There is no reason, either, for triction between the CLP in whose area the workplace is situated (which would be receiving the subs) and the various CLPs in whose areas the workplace branch members actually lived (who would get no financial contribution).
The new member would be notified to his local CLP where he would be entitled to attend ward or branch meetings where he lived, receive Party literature, etc., in the same way as any other Party member.
And his 'free' membership of his CLP would be balanced by the benefit to the CLP of other workplace branches affiliating to them, whose members in fact lived in another constituency.
It would be a case of swings and roundabouts. Even if a few non-industrial CLPs found themselves marginally losing by this arrangement, they could take comfort from the fact that (a) those workplace members who pay their subs in another constituency would probably never have joined the Party in the traditional way, and (b) a new member is a member for the Party nationally, not a feather in the cap of a particular constituency.
At present a young woman engineer who joins the AUEW and pays the political levy can also join the LPYS, the women's section, her ward party or branch, the Co-op party, or the Fabians... so why not also a factory branch?
Such workplace branches would take the policies of the Party onto the shop floor. They would activate many more workers to take part in local and national politics. They would permit workers to decide where to engage in Labour Party activities, in thé workplace, in their CLP branch, or both if they were politically enthusiastic. Thus every workplace could be made into a socialist fortress, a socialist school.
The Party should not be afraid of members being too active, but rather encourage it. We could have thousands of workplace branches, with millions of active members, in factories, shops and offices, in schools and in hospitals. This would be real democracy in action within the Party, and nobody need then complain about trade union versus CLP votes in Conference!
With a mass membership actively participating in the Party, keeping Party leaders and the PLP accountable to the membership and firmly on Party policy lines as laid down by the Mass Party at Annual Conference, we would surely be on the road to a Socialist Britain, involving the maximum number of 'workers by hand or by brain' in the decision-making process of our Party.
Unity is strength!
factory."