Crisis: Import Controls the Ansiyer?
Socialist Organiser1980 1980-07-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
redundancies announced every day, the demand for import controls is growing. In the motor and components industry in particular, both unions and bosses are now demanding protectionist policies from the Government.
Michael Edwardes started the ball rolling with the "Buy British" campaign and his calls for "a little healthy chauvinism". • Now BL is planning a full scale campaign amongst its employees to whip up feeling against European and Japanese imports, and to put pressure on the Government for controls.
Bill Hayden, senior executive with Ford Europe, has also come out publicly for import controls against Japanese cars,and, again, a campaign amongst the workforce is planned:
"Ford wants to alert its employees, not just to the immediate threat of Japanese imports, but also to the fact that the likes of Datsun and Toyota can make cars much cheaper by organising their factories more efficiently" (Sunday Times, June 22nd)
So the campaign also ties in neatly with the bosses' plans to persuade workers to accept speed-up, increased flexibility, new teohnology and reduced union rights (the Ford "Business Plan Shopping List" and the BL '92" Page Document) - all of which will cost more jobs, of course.
The bosses can expect support from their old friends like Terry Duffy in all of this. Already, Duffy is calling on "Sir Michael" to join him im a joint appeal to the Government to demand import controls. And the I&GWU is backing the bosses, too. Its paper, the Record, has devoted the bulk of its last three issues to the import controls demand. The I&GWU's ten point "Charter" includes the following:
"Joint Action: that trade union negotiators should join with employers in joint campaigns to exert maximum pressure on the government and the CBI to take action against specific import penetration problems, using tri-partite machinery such as NEDC Sector Working Parties and Economic Development Committees wherever possible"
It's no surprise that the self-same bureaucrats who sabotaged the fight against the Edwardes plan, and who're stood idly by while 40.000 jobs were slashed in BL, now want to join with the bosses in demanding import controls to "save British jobs" • The whole logic of the demand is to tie British workers to "their own" boss In America, the campaign has gone furthest with laidoff Detroit carworkers being encouraged (with some success) to smash up any Japanese car they see, and Doug Frazer of the United Auto Workers Union taking class collaboration to its ultimate by taking a seat on the board of the bankrupt Chrysler Corporation, and persuading his members to accept sackings, lay-offs and lower wages 'in return"
So what would happen if the Government were persuaded to introduce import controls?
For a start, the cost of living would go sky high and many goods (particularly electrical goods normally imported from Japan) would become too expensive for many workers to afford.
Talbot would almost certainly close down 1TC British operation (which depends upon imported components) and BL (which exports over 40% of its production) would come off the worst in any generalised trade war. Even it the controls were directed: only agairst Japanese products, the resulting flood of cheap Japanese cars into other markets would still clobber BL's exports.
But the real objection that socialists must raise to the demand for protectionism is not just that it wouldn't work. More important, to advocate import controls is to disarm the working class ideologically, to imply through import controls. making common cause with 'our own" capitalists, and to encourage nationalist and even racist illusions.
It can be no coincidence that the T&GWU, as it steps up its campaign for import controls, is also preparing to give up the last vestiges opposition to the Edwardes plan (using the fig leaf of the "Eurofinance report which the union commissioned in January, and which warns that BI cannot survive any further serious disruption). Import controls are not just ineffective as a means of combatting unemployment -the demand militates against the kind of independent working class strategy that can defend jobs, and begin the fight to overthrow the crazy, unplanned system whose over-production is causing the crisis!
Now, more than ever before, British workers need to be forging links with their brothers and sisters overseas in a common struggle for shorter hours and workers' control. In the motor industry, only Ford workers have any effective links with their foreign counterparts - and it was significant that at a recent meeting of the Ford European Combine Committee no-one felt able to raise the demand for import controls!
Talbot and Vauxhall (General Motors) workers have virtually no contact with their european opposite numbers. And as far as the unions in BL are concerned, that company's operations in Seneffe (Belgium), South Africa and elsewhere, might as well not exist. With the likelihood of a permanent link-up between BL and Honda being strongly rumoured, the unions cannot afford to continue with their insular, nationalist outlook.
Genuine, rank and filecontrolled international combines have to be built as a matter of urgency: Car workers of the world unite against the common enemy!