[thin lixsemare. hane Dostr that top laft's asked…]
Socialist Organiser1980 1980-08-30Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
thin lixsemare. hane Dostr that top laft's asked VLADIMIR DERER, secretary of the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy, for his views on the 'gang of 3' "IF THERE is one lesson, it is that there can be no compromise with those who share neither the values nor the philosophy of democratic socialism"
Thus saith Dr David Owen, William Rodgers, and Shirley Williams in their lengthy 'Open Letter' These prominent members of the Parliamentary Labour Party (with Shirley Williams temporary absentee) assume that . their views accurately reflect democratic socialist views and the philosophy of the Labour Party. Is their assumption justified?
The Labour Party's aim is to realise democratic socialist values and philosophy through the abolition of the capitalist system. This is shown in the Labour Party constitution, which clearly defines the Party's object: "to secure for the workers by hand and by brain the full fruit of their industry and the most equitable distribution thereof that may be possible upon the basis of the common ownership of the means of production, distribution, and exchange"
However, Owen, Rodgers and Williams place themselves outside this ground, traditionally occupied by the incy are proposilg lo rediise Labour's values and philosophy through their commitment to successful management of the mixed economy, i.e. of capitalism. The question they are raising is not a tactical one of how the transition from private to common ownership might best be brought about.
The great majority of Labour Party members may believe that this change cannot be effected overnight but only in a piecemeal manner. This means that it is believed that they may have to put up with the social inequalities generated by the existence of a considerable period of But Owen, Rodgers and Williams disagree not just about the method of achieving the Party's objectives. Their statement implies a commitment on their part to the indefinite existence of the 'mixed economy'.
They appear to regard a large private sector as something desirable in itself. How else is one to interpret their claim that 'the mixed economy is here to stay - and rightly so", or their advice that we should all work for its success, e.g. by pouring public money into the private sector. ("'Finance should be made available on easy terms to new firms starting up...")
To top it all, Owen, Rodgers and Williams, for some obscure reason, seem to link a commitment to the successful management of the mixed economy with a commitment to parliamentary democracy, ideals of freedom, equality and social justice.
Mixed economy thus turns out to be a good thing and not a system which generates class divisions and hampers economic growth.
It is not sufprising therefore that Owen, Rodgers and Williams take an extremely rosy view of the 1974-9 Labour Government: 'We were proud to be members of the last Labour Government... It made mistakes as all Governments do...
Nor is it surprising that they are unconcerned that the commitment "to bring about a fundamental and irreversible shift in the balance of wealth and power in favour of working people and their families" was not honoured, a commitment on which the Labour Government, as the present Parliamentary Labour Party, were elected.
They do not attribute the electoral defeat of 1979 to the performance of the Government, which presided over a ‹ cuucallun the living standards of Labour's traditional supporters, reducing many of them to unemployment. Instead they try to pin the blame for the last election onto those members of the Labour Party, including some MEC members, who were not prepared to be silent while the policies adopted by the Labour Cabinet were laying the ground for Labour's loss of credibility.
The rank and fite members of the Party have drawn very different conclusions from their experience of the last Labour Government. They are determined to see that future Labour Governments stick to Labour policies.
fhis is why they are pressing for a number of vital constitutional reforms. Needless to say, Owen, Rodgers and Williams do not find this at all to their liking.
They complain: "For decades, debates on policy and organisation have gone on within our party, and we have managed to find some way of working together, but this time the far left wants no compromise. It is seeking not only to dominate the Party, but to destroy representative democracy itself"
Owen, Rodgers and Williams should know better, for it is well known in the Lawul rally wal lal ICIL groups like Militant, IMG etc. had very little to do with either the launching of the campaign for constitutional reform or maintaining its momentum. The Campaign for Labour Party Democracy, which carries the brunt of the struggle for re-selection, was in fact repeatedly criticised and on occasion actively obstructed by some of these so-called far left groups. The attaching of false labels and silly insinuations about dangers to parliamentary democracy should deceive no-one.
What Owen, Rodgers and Williams really object to is that unlike in the past, the debate on this occasion may end with the majority decision in favour of the rank and file. Having lost the argùment, Owen, Rodgers and Williams are now resorting to threats.
They seem to be saying that unless the Party goes back on its traditional commitment to socialism and accepts their views instead, they will split it and thus deprive Labour of electoral victory:
All this is to be done, of course, in the name of democratic socialism. Labour Party members will not be misled by that kind of 'argument' '. Nor will, in due course, Labour voters. on the Employment Bill and the steelworkers' strike? The Labour Opposition could have made itself a lot more effective than it has been - if it had committed itself to the tactic of disrupting the Tories' work in Parliament.
'Even a minority of Labour left-wingers could make sure not a single Tory measure got through without big delays and a loud outcry - an outcry which would develop and encourage mass action against the Tories outside Parliament. Jo Richardson and others showed how it can be done over the Corrie Bill.
The 'gentlemanly' attitudes rife in the conduct of business in the hallowed chambers of the House of Commons are a bit sick when you're on the receiving end - homeless, on a one-day week, or on the dole queue. They are as useless as the TUC leaders' idea that they can get the Tories to 'change course' by having polite conversation with them.
The Labour Opposition must ditch their 'good manners' and continue the filibustering they started too late last session, into the next Parliamentary session.
Published by Socialist Organiser, 5 Stamford Hill, London N16, and printed by Morning Litho(TU). Signed articles do not necessarily represent the point of view of
Scan page 4
SOCIALIST ORGANISER 4 BRIANISULLIVIANi isshe INUPE branch secretawyi atıtherRoyalVictoria Hospital., Belfastsln Apri hisıyean herled ia sacäke *henentordemandithat Brütsh Anmy patrols be removed from the hospital.
During August Brian Sullivan visited Binitainıand ıspokeratısevera meetinps organised bıyı Workers -Act on and Baracade. He calledifonthe Brütlshl aboyr