[November 7 last year: Lambeth marches against the…]
Socialist Organiser1980 1980-08-30Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
November 7 last year: Lambeth marches against the cuts. .. IT HAS become apparent that the crisis in local government finance will be upon us in the next few months. Many Labour Party activists had anticipated that it would not come until Spring '81 - when the rates for the next financial year are being set.
Each November, the Government of the day makes what is called the rate support top-up grant - the second instalment of the central exchequer's share of the cost of local services. This would normally also cover the cost of local government annual salary awards, including the comparability payments won earlier this year, and also an allowance for the high level of interest rates.
Heseltine is breaking with this bi-partisan tradition and trying to force Councils to finance this additional expenditure by making more cuts. On top of this, Ted Knight explained how he sees the Conference. «The fight against the government has got to be made this financial year. It can't wait. If we wait, then the odds will be stacked well against the Labour Councils and the unions. Manchester has conceded, and other councils are in extreme difficulty. 's impossible, unless there's money, to continue paying out money - that's just not a practical proposition. Many councils will be in that position rapidly. We must move quickly; councils must maintained indefinitely."
He explained Lambeth's cash problem — the councils have got no extra money from central government to cover council workers' pay rises. Interest rates are still high, and prices are rising fast. He said that "the overall result is that we could be £6 million in the red this year", — and with Hesel. tine's plans to penalise 'overspending' councils, rate rises are no answer. "The rates will have to be raised so high, that it becomes not practical"
• What kind of response should be offered? •O TK We must argue for increased central government grant. Thatcher and Heseltine have rejected the arguments for this. So the objective now of the Labour movement must be to force a change in government policy — or, of course, if that isn't possible, to force the government out.
How?
OD TK We have to bring together the public sector trade unions and local councils, and the Labour movement generally, and say that unless a stand is made, and confrontation with the government in one form or another takes place, then what faces TUs and Labour councils is a reduction in jobs and services.
If the conference agrees on a strategy which members of the trade unions, labour councils and labour parties will go back to their organisations to right for. then that's what were looking for. Nobody's going to be able to take a decision at the conference to take strike actor on a paricular da: or something ake ine: Wra that se car _5% his Local Government and Land Bill contains provisions to further reduce the RSG top-up of those Councils which he would call overspenders'. • There is no limit to the size of these penalties contained in the Bill.
As a response to this attack on local services and jobs, the Labour Parties and Town Hall Trade Unions in Lambeth are calling for a National delegate Conference of their comrades throughout the couverber st, held, an the Camden Town Hall.
Alan Freeman from Socialist Challenge and myself, on behalf of Socialist Organiser, interviewed Ted Knight, Leader of Lambeth Council, together with Brian Martin, the representative from the Joint Shop Stewards' Committee [he is also Assistant Branch Secretary Lambeth NALGO].
in the present situation; there has got to be a confrontation. • • What would happen in a confrontation? What should a Labour council actually do?
OO TK I don't think a Labour council should do anything by itself. I think the Labour councils and the trade unions could force a situation whereby they make it possible to bring local government generally to a standstill in the major city areas, in my view. That's the sort of action which has got to be considered. In my view, it is possible to force government to negotiate in those circumstances. •• BM We feel we have no alternative, if we are really sincere about wanting to protect services and ZAGAINSI nolgo 10..
Above: Ted Knight jobs, but to see if there is any broad front we can attack the government on.
- What sort of support will you be looking to local councils for? •• BM We would want the Councils at least to stand firm until we are ready to take action.
You sule stand firm. What would this mean in the next financial veur? -- BM Well. I:ri : would meat siepere ene. een i : mes.: gE*: dr: : sm = CERCE ET: until the unions are in position to take some action..
DO TK Can I butt in here - what we are saying is that unless we move very quickly, that won't be possible. . Can you explain who is organising the conference, and what sort of response you have had? OO TK The organisation is in the hands of a joint organising committee of the Labour councillors, the joint steward committee of the council, and the constituency Labour Parties. •• If you're going to call for industrial action, it will obviously be better if you can get support from national unions, from trades councils and so on. Are you trying for this?
BM Yes. Trades Councils are being invited, certainly Lambeth and the Greater London Association of Trades Councils have expressed support. But essentially at the moment it naig is more a rank and file conference. We are sending out invitations to delegates. We are not doing it through our national executives or anything like that, although some of the unions might have to get their NEC's tacit approval beofre sending out the invitations 1 don't know. But it's unlikely that we, for example, could get national NALGO support for it.
Iris stess that when we policy of confrontation, we can't possibly : pre-empt any union's decisions on this. I can't even say whether my branch would be prepared to take industrial action, let alone NALGO nationally. We see this as a taking-off point. If we get a positive strategy, members can go back to their branches to win rank and file suppor for adopting that policy. •• So what are you hoping the conference will achieve? UO TK We're looking for a very full discussion at the conference, not on the indiv ¡dual perils we face, but on the forward to to break this impasse that is develop ing. I would hope that we can come to some agreement at the conference, working towards a united action against the government, either to force policy change, or to force them into a situation where they can no longer continue. •• A doubı has been expressed to me by members of the Labour Party. You rave said that if the conter ence is successful you will be able to avoid making cuts raising the rates Tenis. But. of. course, this doesn t raise a sufficient eve a super men or you obliged to go ahead and raise the rates, and possibly even make CULS People feel, perhaps a a little cynically, hat you would not be ur lappy y conference didn' rulse sufficient level of upport, and councils woul then use it as a justification for making cuts. arguing there hadn t been a sufficient level of support.
OO TK I think that anyone who raises cynical questions like that must be very cynical themselves. We are in a serious position. What we are talking about is Prophes jobs, and services.
Is playing with those, in Lambeth or anywhere else. If the government is not prepared to put more money nito Lambeth, then somehow the money has to be raised, or if it's not raised, then cuts have to take place. And that's the situation we're in. So it isn't a question of being cynical. It's not a situation of playing games. We're in a serious situation, and to argue that people will be seeking to use this as an excuse — well, it may be that some people will: but then, frankly, it will no longer just be an excuse, it will be a fact.
• But one of the factors that would stimulate a fight would be if councils said: "Look, we're not going to implement the cuts, and we're not going to raise the rates" - which would mean effectively going against the law - the auditors would be called in...
CC TK …well, it would not. it's not a question of going against the law; it's not illegal ... •• ...well, it means the government would step in... ..... TK ...no. I doubt it the government weuld step Faldeme thereen• • Don't you feel that this would be better than a Labour council being seen by its electors, to whom they have a responsibility...? DO TK ...well, that's really a political decision which I'm frankly not prepared to take at this point in time. Maybe yes, it may be nice for Labour councillors to say they wash their hands of the situation, and they leave the unions to NATIONAL ANTI-CUTS CONFERENCE called by the labour movement in Lambeth Date: Saturday Ist November.
Place: Camden Town Hall.
Delegates: 3 per contro ling local authority Lab. our group, 1 per minori Labour group, trade un. ion branch, shop stewards' committee, CLP or Trades Council.
Delegate fee: £1 (chequ es/POs payable to 'Lam beth Joint Conference') Write to: Organising Committee, Room 103, Lambeth Town Hall, Brixton Hill, London SW2 1RW.
wallow away under a mass of Tory cuts. But that's not my position. I think we would have to very seriously consider with the trade unions what we would do in that situation. •• Do you think, in the long run, that it's better for the Labour Party to make cuts than for the Tories to make cuts?
• TK I don't think it's best for anyone to make cuts, from the Labour movement. What the unions may say to us is that we need you in control in this situation, in which case we might have to accept that.
There are members of the Lambeth CLPs who view with doubt the intentions of Lambeth Council, fearing that they may well resort to cutting jobs and services.
It is important not to allow this conference in any. way to assist them, or any ather council, to this end. Already the rhetoric contains the threat of cuts to come.
Nonetheless, this conference gives the positive opportunity for rank and file activists in the trade unions to fight for a strategy which would preclude any cuts in their jobs or the services they provide. It is important for them to know that their action will be supported by Labour Councils, who themselves will refuse to implement cuts. It thus becomes meaningful for those trade unionists not in the Labour Party to work jointly with Labour councils.
It is, therefore, not acceptable for any council leadership to talk in terms of Labour cuts being preferable to cuts implemented by eo!
other sourit We can't walk away from it. Their jobs are going to be cut. They may decide that they prefer to do that with Labour in control, than with the Tories or the receivers or someone else. But that's a decision which will be taken later on, I think. It's not a decision we're preparing for now.
O• BM The point of view does exist about the council adopting a no rates rise and no cuts policy. It's quite strong in my branch - and it's even stronger, I think, in the Constituency Labour Parties. But I think the danger is, if you are entertaining : that posture, you're taking a chance if Lambeth did go to the wall — would the Labour movement come over the hill like the Seventh Cavalry to rescue us, or would we just be left to wallow around, trying to defend services against the receiver or whoever the Tory's commissioners put in to implement their cuts? If all the London boroughs should take that position, then I think it might be a possibility. But certainly I think Lambeth in isolation would be placing itself in a dangerous position.
But whether one takes the view that rates should be raised or not, the conclusion would be the same as regards this conference — it should be built as big possible.
UD TK Yes: you see, 1 don't think the issue before the conference is whether to raise rates or not to raise rates, or whether to go bankrupt or not to go bankrupt. The fact is that unless government policy is changed, there will be splits, divisions all over the place. Some Labour councils will stay, some will go. But jobs won't stay, services won't stay. We're saying that the crisis is so desperate that really: a decision has got to be taken to change that situation.
We must do all in our power to sell this strategy of industrial action to all Labour Councils and to all the Town Hall workers.
Should, by any chance, councils continue to be isolated, it will then be up to the activists on the left of the Party to ensure that our elected representatives do not participate in a sell-out.
Whilst it would be neglectful not to prepare for all eventualities, we must concentrate our efforts on making this conference an overwhelming success. We must convince delegates that industrial action acrOSS the country, which will co.
incide with next winter's pay battles, will have a real chance of forcing concessions out of the government, and hasten its departure.
This is the only way to ensure 'the continuation of local government services as we have known them, and to obtain the improvements and growth that we vant to see in the fatare.
ROSALND
----- pull-quotes -----
take a 'no cuts' stand, but there's no way it can be