I «FLOWMENT ACT The closed
Socialist Organiser1980 1980-08-30Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
3L by a Longbridge T&G steward IN THE 1960s and early '70s, BMC (later BL) carworkers were among the top paid manual workers in British industry - and many people seem to think we still are.
In fact, BL hourly paid workers are now among the lowest paid in engineering. A track worker at Longbridge, for instance, is lucky to take home more than £67 per week.
Last year (and the year before) most BL workers received only 5% pay rise.
This decline in BL workers' living standards has been brought about not only by the collapse of the car market and the increasingly hard-line stance of the bosses, but also by the cowardice and bureaucratism of the trade unions at every level.
Until this year, wage negotiations had been controlled by a body called the Leyland Combine Joint Negotiating Committee (JNC), the union side of which was made up of convenors, senior stewards, and national officials. In overall charge was the Confederation of Shipbuilding and Engineering Unions (Confed).
Although highly bureaucratised and largely unaccountable, the JNC was at least subject to some indirect pressure from the rank and file, via the convenors and senior stewards. Now the Confed (which is controlled by the right wing AUEW leadership) together with BL boss Michael Edwardes, have proposed a new JNC, to be totally dominated by full time officials.
This is being opposed by the T&G and by the unofficial combine committee - although what they are pushing for is a JNC much like the old one, but with a fairer balance between the various unions on it. Militants in BL (including the leadership of the Cowley Assembly Plant) have been arguing for a negotiating committee directly elected by and answerable to a conference of stewards trom ı every plant.
The question of the make up of the negotiating committee is of vital importance. The old JNC was bad enough. But the new Edwardes/ Confed JNC would be guaranteed to stitch up a rotten deal behind the membership's back every The combine committee met this month (for the first time since Derek Robinson was sacked last November) and put forward a 'single issue' wage claim (drawn up by Longbridge convenor Jack Adams, and other Communist _Party members) for £17.21 rise (before deductions) for all BL workers. The figure of £17.21 was worked out as 20% of the average of the five grade rates in BL.
This claim is not even enough to keep BL workers up with present rates of inflation, let alone start to claw back any of the last few years' lost ground.
Even so, the bosses seem unlikely even to negotiate seriously on the claim. At the moment, they are arguing that as the combine committee is an unofficial body, the claim has no legitimacy. Also, they have threatened disciplinary action against anyone attending 'unofficial' meetings (i.e. combine meetings on the claim).
In this situation, it is vital that the rank and file begin organising now around the combine claim (while arguing for the addition of such demands as a 35 hour week and inflation-proofing). The combine committee must be pressed to organise a truly representative conference of stewards to take control of negotiations and to organise action in support of the claim, if it has not been met by the November 1st settlement date.
"The compulsory enforce:
ment of the closed shop by parliamentary statute the greatest disaster which has befallen liberty in my lifetime" (Paul Johns on).
The Tory government would agree but they also know that a well-organised closed shop provides a potential increase in bargaining power for workers. Alarmed by the spread of closed shops in the last decade, they are determined to weaken existing closed shops and stop their extension.
Before the Act, the law did not compulsorily enforce the closed shop. The position was left to negotiation between union and employers. All the law said was that the employer was protected against an action for unfair dismissal if he dismissed a worker in a closed shop situation unless that worker could show that he objected to trade unionism on religious grounds. If the worker fell into this category he could get compensation at an industral tribunal against the employer, but not his job back. The Act changes this position in two ways. If you have an existing closed shop then the exception on religious grounds is extensubsidiary intertwined purpose of the Act is to free the allegedly dynamic small capitalist from the crippling tentacles of Employment Protection legislation, which allegedly stifles his expansion; to make workers dependent on this kind of law, to stand on their own two feet, and to push women out of work and into the home.
In fact, Britain's Employment Protection legislation is already the worst in Europe. The median compensation in unfair dismissal cases is £375; there is no right to reinstatement, and the number of awards favourable to workers fell from 40% in 1975 to 28% in 1978. In this country, a woman receives 44 weeks statutory maternity leave only, 6 paid at a reduced rate of wages. In Italy, women ded. Workers can now opt out if they can show that they object to the particular union on grounds of conscience or other deeply held personal objections. As a management magazine pointed out, "The phrasing 1s so broad that the more interesting question is likely to be: what grounds do not fall within the protection?"
If a Tory worker objects to his union contributing towards the Labour Party then presumably he can leave the union.
The position is worse if you are trying to negotiate a new closed shop. For the employer to be protected against legal action there must be a secret ballot of the workers involved. If 80% of those entitled to vote are in favour, you have an approved closed. shop...
except anybody who voted in the ballot is still entitled to opt out, full stop. Only new workers will have to join...
unless, of course, they can show. an objection grounds of conscience.:.
A vital point is that if an employer is taken to a tribunal he can ask for workers whopressurised himtodismiss the blackleg to be joined to the action. Compensation in thousands could therefore be awarded against a shop ng the v Moreover, the government's own reports show • that most small employers have not even heard of this legislation, let alone been crippled by it. In a 1979 survey, only 2% mentioned employment legislation as "a difficulty'.
The Act makes a number of small changes, which, taken together, eradicate most of the little value these rights possessed. The government has already increased the qualification all workers need in order to claim unfair dismissal, from 26 to 52 weeks' employment. Workers in firms employing less than twenty will now need two years' employment to qualify.
With growing unemployment among women, even the limited legal right to return to the job after pregnancy might be useful in keeping the weaklyorganised in a job. The Act's changes make the procedure more technical and bureaucratic, and thus make the right more difficult to exercise.
As well as the present hurdles in this obstacle steward.
Whereas until now, workers expelled or refused admission to a union have only been able to take action if they could show the union rules met some basic requirements — right to know the charges, right to a hearing etc-and were followed.
There was no opportunity to go to court and argue that the rules were unreasonable.
Those who wished to do this if they worked in a closed shop could only take the matter to a special TUC Disputes Committee after exhausting the individual union procedure.
Under the Act, workers who feel that they have been unreasonably refused admission or expelled from a union in a closed shop situation will be able to take the case to an Appeals Tribunal, where s/he can be awarded up to £16,000.
These provisions give the judges, with their anti-union attitudes, the power to decide whether union rules are reasonable. Moreover, all these legal changes are to be read in the context of a Code of Practice on the Closed Shop which suggests, for example, periodic ballots to see if the workers still support the arrangement.
leakest course, a woman must now write to her employer three weeks before she leaves, stating she will return; write to confirm within fourteen days that she will return if the employer requests confirmation after the birth, and write a third letter three weeks before. If these technical requirements are not met, tribunals rule out claims. Moreover, whereas a woman has been entitled to return to the same job, she can now be offered "suitable. alternative employment" which may well involve substantial changes in cash conditions and job content.
Finally, the Act abolishes the ill-fated Section 11 of the Employment Protection Act by which unions were given a procedure to attempt to achieve recognition -limited anyway, and crippled by the courts. It also scraps a clause which allowed workers' terms and conditions to be improved through comparison with those of other workers. It was widely used to get around the Labour government's incomes policy.