BALLOTS IMPLOYMENT Outlawing solidarity
Socialist Organiser1980 1980-08-30Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
The aks of the Act
A major prong of Tory the cost of secret ballots on policy has been the attempt the calling or ending of a to mobilise the backward strike, or other industrial workers' against the class action, electing members conscious activists and a to positions in the union, major tactic here has been changing the union rules, the push for secret postal amalgamation or any other balloting, cutting back on purpose which the Minister union democracy as active may specify by order. The However, regulations will cover, the picketing was therefore Constable of Leicester) breach of contract, and illegal. and intimidate workers Although in many cases so that they will limit legal orders or damages restricts their activitie could be awarded against to 'explaining' thei It would be fatal for trade unionists to see the Employ. ment Act as simply motivated by the Torles' dislike of trade union activities. It is an essential part of the government's economic strategy. The Tories believe that by limiting the money supply, by cutting public expenditure and consumer spending, by . allowing interest rates to rise and withdrawing from intervention in industry, they will force the bosses to face 'reality'. Millions will be thrown out of work, organised workers' bargaining power and therefore wages will be cut, inflation will fall, profitability will increase, reinvestment in dynamic new industries will take place and the ordinary worker having once again solved capitalism's problems will get pie in the sky!
The monetarists acknowledge that artificial conPickets who turn away workers at picket lines are legally said to be inducing those workers to break their contracts of employment and in the case, say, of a lorry driver, directly inducing a breach of the commereial contract between the lorry driver's employer and the pickets' employer.
If there were no specific statutory protection, almost all union action would be illegal. Since 1906, pickets have been protected against civil actions for breach of contract - where there is a trade dispute in certain limited circumstances, what the Tories call a 'privilege' is simply an "immunity' essential if trade unions are to operate. However, pickets have always been open to criminal prosecution for obstruction of the highway, obstructing a policeman in the course of his duty, assault or intimidation.
The Tories' view of the Act's progress is clear. The police will take a stronger line with pickets; several will be successfully sued; this will make other workers limit their picketing. A shop steward will be successfully done for compensation for defending the closed shop. This will make other stewards more reluctant to do so. Whilst there is an obvious gap between this aim and its achievements, many of the left take an equally complacent view, quote the Pentonville dockers or
traints interfere with the erfect working of the narket. Strong union organration and aggressive action an limit these effects
articularly as strong monooly capital too is insulated. Reasonable' levels of nemployment pay mean vorkers are not forced to ompete as vigorously as hey should for jobs, thus xercising a downward pressure on the wages of he unemployed. This is here legislation comes in.
The central objective of the Employment Act is to limit the use of trade union organisation to interfere with the operation of the Tories' strategy. The aim of the new act is to make trade unions less successful in the fight against mass sackings, in the fight against wage cuts, in the fight against cuts in the social services.
In a series of legal judgements in the '60s and "70s, the courts held that if pickets stopped workers or vehicles against their will, even for a short time, they were guilty of obstructing the highway. You could only picket legally if, say, a lorry driver was willing to stop, and then only for as long as he wished to talk to you. All effective picketing was therefore illegal.
Although in many cases the police did not enforce the police did not enforce the law. where crucial the law, where crucial interests were at stake, as at Grunwick, or Adwest or during the steel strike, they acted on the correct legal assumption that there was no right to picket. The new Act is the AUEW in 1972, and believe that spontaneous rank and file action will magically cripple the Act.
Yet the position is far different today, with recession and 2 million unemployed. This legislation can work. The fight inside Parliament has been unbelievably feeble. Nor has any leadership come from the TUC. The Congress agenda contains no strong policy resolution, while Murray has stated that "there is little or no support for a repeat of
PICKETS LIMITED to two at each entrance; police violence; scores arrested. The recent attack on this picketing at Brixton Social Security office in defence of two victimised branch officials is the rehearsal for coming confrontations this winter between trade unionists, the police and
the law courts. Without disturbing the slumbers of Labour's front bench, the Employment Act has hit the statute book and its provisions will be gradually phased in in the next few months.
* If you work in a closed shop situation and pressintended to stiffen the police: "We have got to live with these people once the strike is over': Alan Goodson, Chief Constable of Leicester) and intimidate workers so that they will limit their use of this vital them. tactic.
The Act limits the already negligible right to picket your own workplace. Workers picketing another plant of their employer or their head office; workers picketing stonec the Day of Action", and vetoed Regional TUCs holding • demonstrations. The leaders of the ETU and the AUEW, given the mild reception to the blacklegging they have organised at the Isle of Grain, are unlikely to fear expulsion for breach of any vague or minimal policy which may be agreed.
The way forward for socialists, however, is clear. Firstly, we should fight at all levels of the union for a clear, formal policy — no closed shop ballots: dismissurise the employer to sack non-members; * if you attend a picket line in solidarity with workers fighting for recognition or against virtimicatinn• * if you black goods to a company which is being used to break a strike at a third company; You would be in breach of the Employment Act and subject to injunctions and damages. These and many other ordinary union activites are now illegal. What is the thinking behind the new act? What does it say? How does it work in practice and how can we fight it? another company to support a victimisation or recognition dispute: all would be open to civil actions for inducing breach contract, and legal could them.
To take the steel strike as an example, it is clear that to make the strike halfway effective, workers needed to picket stockholders, the private sector, the docks and companies using alternative to br al of non-unionists; no money for ballots, and no change in picketing or blacking — whatever the dispute requires, should be done. No penalties imposed under the Act should be met and solidarity action at the level of the unions and the TUC should be organised.
Secondly, we must fight within the Labour Party so that both nationally and locally, support is given in practical terms to those fighting the Act. The example of Reg Race and Stuart Holland on the Brixton picket line involvement.
the lories have learned from the experience of the Industrial Relations Act that compulsory ballots can produce hostility and a closing of the ranks, as they are often seen as an invasion of union democracy.
The Act is therefore just another prod in the direction of secret ballots. It authorises the Minister to make regulations which would authorise payments towards steel. All of this picketing would be illegal under the new Act. All steel workers could do would be to picket their own workplaces... and even here they could be arrested if they halted lorries or office workers.
Again there will be a Code of Practice to be used by the courts and, judging by Brixton, by the police. This Code the police. This Cod limits pickets to six limits pickets to six, restricts their activities to 'explaining' their case, states that each case, states that eac picket line should be supervised by a union official and attempts to stop unions taking disciplinary action against If you ask workers at another company to black zak las (condemned irrationally by Murray) should be hammered home to all MPs, and union delegates to GMCs should press for motions on the above lines, plus practical support to any local disputes.
Thirdly, apart from ensuring the repeal of the legislation by the next Labour government, we have to consider what should replace it. Our experience with the legal system has been so appalling that we must start asking questions about the election of circumstances in which, and the conditions subject to which payments may be made.
As the TUC points out, "public funds cannot be handed over to the unions without the acceptance of some degree of public accountability... unions which accept public money could well find their independence and autonomy under goods which are undermining your • stoppage, you are again legally inducing a breach of contract, and again, the law since 1906 has protected this if you were involved in a trade dispute. In a series of Court of Appeal judgements in the last few years, the judges have attempted to undermine this right. The judgements were reversed by the judges in the House of Lords, who said quite blatantly that the Court of Appeal was bending the law too obviously and too much, and allowing workers to see clearly that they were politically biased. Instead, these independent, impartial Law Lords recommended that the government should remove the protection given to unions and the new law basically re-enacts the Court of Appeal's decisions.
continued on p.11 judges and tribunal members, and the extension of the jury system, otherwise our experience with new laws will be as disillusioning as in the past. The next Labour government should not merely abolish the House of Lords, it should start taking steps to make the legal system itself accountable to the workers of this country.
----- pull-quotes -----
by John McIlroy