Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[on this matter needed to be said. That…]

Socialist Organiser no. 25, 13 September 1980 · scan pp. 3–4 · about 1,605 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

on this matter needed to be said. That it was said most vehemently by the one figure in the British labour movement most odious to socialists and militant trade unionists is a terrible verdict on the state of that movement's official leadership.

Every thinking worker in Britain, everyone who has ever known what it is to give or receive basic class solidarity in a strike, every worker who would revolt against a police tyranny over the British working class, ardently sympathised with and wanted to help the workers of Poland. He or she felt betrayed and dirtied by the bumbling and spineless bureaucrats of the TUC who were so eager to be the guests of those who run Poland's 'company unions' for the Polish and Russian Stalinists Shame They are people without honour and without principle who shamed the labour movement and themselves by their fawning on the anti working class Polish Stalinists. Just like they do by their docility before the Tory offensive against the British working class.

But who are you, Mr Chapple? You are a professional anti-socialist and anticommunist, eager to pretend that the police state in Poland is socialism and that socialism is thereby discredited. You are a man initially installed as a leader of his own union by a High Court judge, instead of by election, a man widely denounced as a scab by his own union's members - and with good cause.

CHAPPL BALI DIl NUW TU ALL FORDIOUR MONEY FRANKIE BOI * NO WAY You run the nearest thing to a 'union police state' in Britain. You have more than once played the role for the capitalists of Britain that those that the TUC was going to visit in Poland always do for the bureaucrats there.

Of course, Britain is not a police state, and despite your own tin-pot despotism in the EETPU, despite your readiness to call in the state and its courts to arbitrate in the affairs of the labour movement, the EETPU is a genuine workers' organisation, qualitatively different from the police state "trade unions' of Poland. Even you, Chapple, sometimes have to represent the interests of your members, and even to fight for them.

In the last analysis it is this that determines that you, despite what you are, came out on the right side in this question. You are part — a malignant part, but still a part - of a real working class movement, whereas the Polish 'trade unions' are designed to prevent a real Polish workers' movement from emerging.

The problem, Chapple, is that your support taints the cause you say you support.

Militants in Britain who know you for what you are in the British labour movement and in the fight against the bosses here may thereby become confused about who is who and what is what in Poland right now.

The TUC discredits only itself; you, by your championing of them, threaten to discredit the Polish strikers in the eyes of a lot of good working class militants, especially those who mistakenly believe that the system in Poland is some sort of "socialism' The Morning Star. the newspaper of the Communist Party of Great Britain. which tried to whitewash Gierek and the other Polish tyrants, eagerly seized the chance to tell those working class militants who read it just how many of the enemies of socialism and of working class militancy in this country were 'supporters' of the workers' struggle in Poland, ranging, as they did, from yourself to the Sun and Daily Mail newspapers.

In fact, Chapple; you don't really support the Polish workers at all. No doubt you do rejoice at the troubles of the Polish Stalinists. But you are a liar if you say you support what the Polish workers were fighting for. Or in any case you oppose in Britain most of the demands the workers in Poland fought for Let us look at their demands.

• Do you support free trade unions, independent of the state and the managers? The Polish workers do.

But you run autocratically the least democratic union in this to the intervention only thanks to the of the state within the workers' movement that you, Chapple, are where you are today. Rather than independence from the state, you have slavishly sought interference by the courts to maintain your erip. You accept the Employment Act (with the state financ.

ing of postal ballots which would tie the unions closer to the state) and want to work it for the Tories.

• Do you support the right to strike, the safety of strikers and all those who support them? The Polish workers do.

You support the legal right to strike, of course.

But you have publicly scabbed on many strikes. In the 1968 grading dispute in Scotland, your members, when they demonstrated, had to wear masks to protect themselves from expulsion from the union.

Trade unionists wearing masks to protect themselves from victimisation: that's one of the most striking images of the recent struggles for democratic trade unions in Britain. They wore the masks to protect themselves from you and your machine, Mr Chapple. • Do you support the right of strike committees get access to the media to publicise their demands? The Polish workers do.

But your case, Chapple, it would be more appropriate to ask first, do you support strike committees? 'Such committees would be the death-knell of your own stranglehold on the EETPU.

As for access of workers to television and radio to put forward their demands honestly, this would cut firectly across your own pri vileged access to the bosses media, with which you Isually collaborate to slander and vilify the militants of our class.

• Do you support open democratic debate, the ending of state secrecy, and the access by workers to all the facts and figures of economic and social life? The Polish workers do.

• Do you support the sliding scale of wages — wage increases to compensate for the rise in the cost of living? The Polish workers do.

Chapple, your record of strike breaking, your sabotage of even the most minimal struggles of workers who are determined not to bear the brunt of the bosses' crazy system, is answer enough to that question.

• Do you support the Polish workers' demand that the privileges of the police, and the secret police, should be abolished? That special shops tor the bureaucrats should be eliminated?

But, Chapple, you are one of the most vociferous advocates of 'law and order' and security, almost always on the wrong side when cops smash up picket lines. You do not criticise the multitude of anti working class special police and espionage organisations which the capitalists find essential to maintain their class rule in this country and to frame up militants, revolutionaries, and those fighting for the freedom of the Irish people.

As for the special shops - have you ever denounced the exclusive shops of London, whose prices are so astronomical that no working class family could ever afford even to contemplate shopping there? No doubt on your salary such ice in search of illegal immigrants', nor have we heard you protest against speed-ups, undermanning, and the capricious and petty foremen who have sold out their class and do the bosses' bidding on the shopfloor.

• Do you support increases in nursery provisions to meet the needs of working mothers, and the extension of maternity leave for women to three years on full pay? The Polish workers do.

Since when has your union made a stand on the rights of working class women, let alone the right of women to work, and not be sacked first as a matter of course, when profits are bad for the bosses?

Finally, Chapple, the Polish workers are not fighting for the return of industry to private ownership. All reports tell us that socialised industry is accepted as the basis of a democratic alternative to Stalinism, that is, inescapably, as the basis of a democratic working class system. In other words, the Polish workers are in agreement with the programme of the socialisation of industry under workers' control, which socialists fight for in this country and you fight bitterly against.

These, Chapple, are the demands that the Gdansk workers fought for. The 21 demands of the Inter-Factory Committee of Gdansk are firmly on the terrain of our class's age-long fight against the capitalists and of the decades-long struggle to overthrow the ruling Stalinist bureaucracies.

Your support of the Polish workers, Chapple, is only so much hot air and bluff. A mass movement for the same programme in this country would sound the deathknell of your rule in the EETPU. In British working class politics you fight against those who stand tor the programme the Polish workers fought for - and you use all the arts and tricks of the turned-around, insideout 'Stalinist' that you are.

The programme of the Polish workers and the victory (as yet not consolidated) they have won, should inspire the British labour movement to move into action against the Tories, to fight for what the Poles demanded. The day we do move, Mr Chapple, will see you lined up squarely with the Giereks and Brezhnevs of Britain — against us and against the programme of the Polish workers.

Jim Denham, Angus McDougall, George Makin, Frank McGuirk (T& GWU shop stewards, BL Longbridge), Steve Griffiths (AUEW shop steward, Ro Solihull), Frank Henderso (NUSMW deputy senior steward, BL Longbridge).

Scan page 4

SOCIALIST-ORGANISER 4

----- pull-quotes -----

FORD EETPU DEMAND OURI HAD OUR LOOT THE DISPUTE NOWITS TIME TOMI GOT THE BOOT

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 25

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →