Ducking the choices
Socialist Organiser1980 1980-09-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
and revolution to a gross cracy. need to bind the class strug- frills. UNG argues that Peter Hain leaves out a crucial element: organising militant left wing According to the 'Hackney People's Press' , it has taken someone over 18 months to join a local Labour Party. Rumour has it that one North London Labour Party branch tightly controlled by the right wing told a keen applicant for membership: "Sorry, we're full up"
An inquiry into the affairs of Roy Jenkins' constituency revealed it to be little more than a 'rotten borough' run by a tiny committee.
Peter Hain, in his recent pamphlet, On Reviving the Labour Party — refreshing the parts that others cannot reach, makes a diagnosis:
"Far too much of what passes for political activity is geared to 'declaratory politics' rather than 'activist politics'. Typically, discussion at CLP (Constituency Labour Party) level is followed by the passing of a motion which is sent elsewhere, thereby neatly passing the buck and avoiding the pressing problem of implementation or campaigning for such a policy at CLP level.
"The National Executive Committee, despite its left composition in recent years and its important stands, appears not to conceive its role outside electons in campaigning terms.
'In the case of a national strike, the Party's function nationally ought to be to mobilise maximum support for picketing and so forth, not just by issuing appeal circulars, but by practical intervention"' makes the Labour Party dead and unattractive: 'The new member's first real contact with the Labour Party is usually at a ward meeting and that can be enough to put you off for life"
But why doesn't the Labour Party turn outwards? According to Peter Hain, 'The dominant perspective has been that socialism could be achieved through the ballot box alone"
Instead of this pure "Parliamentary road to socialism", , Hain sugests a parliamentary road to socialism backed up by mass action: "Party activists have neglected the vital task of creating a mass movement outside (Parliament), capable of exerting sufficient power to make feasible socialist changes through Parliament or the local Council"
And he adds: "It is necessary to dispel the myth that parliamentary and extraParliamentary strategies are necessarily in conflict, that there is a straight choice to be made between reform and revolution"
Is this right? Consider first Peter Hain's argument ón roads to socialism.
The police, the armed forces, the civil service hierarchy, and the -secret services are not controlled by Parliament at all. Shuffling through Parliamentary lobbies, even with back-up "mass movements' outside, will not deal with these heavily-armed, hard-bitten, solidly-Tory bodyguards of capitalism. Chile proved that.
The power of capitalism can be overthrown only by the fully-mobilised power of the working class, acting through its own workers councils, and willing to meet violence with violence. 'Mass movements' as a theatre chorus for Parliament are not enough.
Revolutionaries do not reject the fight for reforms. We do not reject Parliamentary activity. But Peter Hain, by searching for some mystical 'third road' between reformism and revolution, does reject revolution.
The 'Alternative Economic Strategy' which he supports sees mass action only as a back-up to a gradual transformation of capitalism by action from Westminster.
Peter Hain goes on from his argument about reform underestimation of the struggle needed to reorientate the Labour Party. His argument is: "The mistake made by the Labour Party has been to assume that socialism could be grafted on from above through governmental action in a hostile capitalist environment"
So the 'mistake' can be corected just by getting more mass involvement and campaigning activity at grassroots : level, to back up a worthy but one-sided effort to get socialism through Parliament.
No ruthless fight to replace the Party's present leaders and transform its structures is necessary. There is no gle left together into a solid fighting force. Peter Hain does not map out any militant role at all for an organised left wing, not even for the Labour Co-ordinating Committee, to which he belongs.
Is the emphasis on Parliament which Hain criticises really just a 'mistake'? No. Callaghan and Wilson were not courting socialism by some long drawn out and unsuccessful method. They were alreadv wedded to can itarsal and snugly in bed with the City.
Their opposition to mass action was and is not because of some philosophical preference for the ballot box, but because of their close commitment to capitalism. So we need more than a fight against inertia, routinism, lack of imagination or wrong ideas. We need a bitter struggle against those in the Party who want to keep capitalism pretty much as it is.
Peter Hain backs up his argument by accusing revolutionaries who follow the Bolshevik model of "seeking to impose or introduce socialism from the top down". 'Unless people have been actively involved in the process of themselves building socialism the result will not be socialism at all...
This might be reasonable as a criticism of the Communist Party. But it is not a valid criticism of the Bolshevism of Lenin and Trotsky.
Lenin and Trotsky fought for a democracy far more real and extensive than parliamentary democracy - the rule of workers' councils, directly based on the workers in the factories, with regular re-election of delegates and right of recall.
They also fought for a militant, disciplined organisation of revolutionaries — as the only way to win the bitter fight for real workers' demoIn the same way, an organised class struggle left wing is really needed to 'revive the Labour Party' • Peter Hain has many good ideas:
"CLPs should help to set up or become closely involved in tenants' associations... local Labour Parties (should) support and relate to local women's movements... we need to mount specific drives amongst black people, especially black youth... the party should be involved in single issue campaigns such as the Anti-Nazi League and the Anti-nuclear campaign"
But without a militantly organised left wing these proposals will just be good intentions - or irrelevant
Scan page 9
SOCIALIST ORGANISER 9