Women 'last in, fırst out'? inst out'
Socialist Organiser1980 1980-09-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
discusses Peter Hain's vision of the road to social AN ESSENTIAL part of Peter Hain's framework for 'Reviving the Labour Party' is the dismissal of 'the myth that parliamentary and extraparliamentary strategies are necessarily in conflict, that there is a straight choice to be made between reform and revolution" • It is this myth which is largely responsible for keeping some self-styled "revolutionary" groups outside the Labour Party, and which prevents those that are within the Labour Party from having more than a marginal influence (despite their illusions to the contrary) on the polities of the party. The explosion of this myth is quite essential if we are to build up an effective unity of the Left, both within and without the Lahour Party, to include both self-styled revolutionary and so-called reformist elements. The hope that this is possible is strengthened by the existing, albeit insufficient, degree of such unity shown in the ANL outside and the Mobilising Committee inside.
The Labour leadership and the Tribunite Left share the blame for the perpetuation of the myth. The Labour Party has been 'far too committed to parliamentarianism". But if we are to accept the compatibility of the two strategies, then what is the role of parliament? Those who rely exclusively on the parliamentary struggle, Hain believes, must do so 'in the belief that real power les in Parliament" , and that must be rejected. However, using the argument that "effective power... really lies in big business, the multinationals and the private and public bureaucracies" to totally reject any role for parliament is also unacceptable. That rejection, after all, is based on a very static analysis. Parliament's role must surely lie in its potential as a source of power. As the existing The passive approach theoretical source of power, it has almost universal recognition and therefore legitimacy. Our task must be to use that legitimacy by giving real power to parliament, and ensuring the accountability of Labour's representatives there to the movement at large.
However, we cannot turn theoretical power into effective power by Act of Parliament, although some of the blockages in the system of parliamentary democracy are more easily removed than others. The abolition of the House of Lords and the removal of the obstructive powers of the Brussels bureaucracy are relatively easy to achieve. The implementation of an Alternative Economic Strategy and industrial strategy, and of an alternative defence strategy, on the other hand, depend on mass popular participation and support. We need to win not just the votes of, the electorate but their hearts and minds.
The success of the parliamentary strategy depends on the creation of a mass campaigning Labour Party, just as the possibility of creating a mass party deship of the party accountable to the rank and file.
However, the creation of However, the creation of a mass party relying solely a mass party relying solely on its existing institutions on its existing institutions is problematic. Ironically, is problematic. Ironically, the great strength of our the great strength of our Labour Party, its structural Labour Party, its structural links with the Trade Union movement, poses problems both for the nature of the party's development and for the modus operandi of the Left: for the nature of the party's development because the link, at least at national level, is between bureaucracies and we wish to develop in the workplace (as well as in the community) as a rank and file party. The possible solutions are the encouragement of more trade union affiliations on a local level, the establishment of structural links with Shop Stewards' Committees and Trades Councils, and the creation of workplace branches (though some think that this runs counter to the other two). But all this is certainly not serving the interests of the Trade Union leaderships who wish to maintain their influence in the party.
The difficulty for the Left in the Labour Party is the necessity often to rely on the support of sympathetic union bureaucracies (e.g. the ever-helpful (?) NUPE). while at the same time wishing to organise among rank and file trade unionists. Perhaps it is necessary to make assessments on the respective merits of each option in each individual case so that CLPD could seek the support of the leadership while the LCC was attempting to initiate a Broad Left organisation in the same union.
This suggests the need not just for a dual strategy, but also dual tactics for implementing those strategies. There may seem to be a contradiction in this approach, but that is unavoidable. In any individual case, unity in action around a set of demands is possible, despite differences of approach, long-term aim or analysis. This has been proved possible on the issues of Labour Party democracy..
It is also possible in the fields of sexual politics, racism, community politics» and defence. It should even be possible in the troubled sea of economic and industrial policy if we concern ourselves with the practical and tangible demands for implementation by the next Labour government and are willing to confront such realities as limited resources, conflicting interests among our own ranks and international trade in a capitalist As Peter Hain so rightly says, "Sectarianism is the cancer of the Left" , and on no account must this be all›wed to prevent the units in action' which 1s necessary to create a mass party.
BUS SToP LEAFLET New Fighi 1000 from London N7 An open letters section for the labour movement Write to Socialist Organiser, 5 ' Stamford Hill, London N16 Dear Socialist Organiser, Whatever happened to equal rights and positive discrimination? Whatever happenea to our nara-won reorms!
The gains made by women are now being eroded by the most reactionary Tory government we have seen in decades. We are once again being forced back into the isolation of hearth and home.
Once again we are being forced to give up our independence and self-respect and 'live off' another's wage (that is, if the man is working), or to go onto Social Security benehit and live in poverty.
We need to maintain our independent income hand-in-hand with our self-respect. Positive discrimination, which was brought in by a few local authority employers so that women got preferential employment, is becoming meaningless - women are being laid off first.
This is partly because & last in, first out' policy often operates. Camden Council, for example, have a policy of positive discrimination in favour of women and blacks. So, of course, it is women and blacks who have been the last to be taken on on any large scale.
If Carden are forced to lay off workers, the rule of last in, first out will hit women and blacks hardest.
The labour movement has fought for the 'last in, first out' policy, and it should be maintained, but where preferential employment has gone through on grounds of positive discrimination, then this too should be maintained and operated if redundancies are forced through. It is hardly the fault of women that they are usually the last to be emshould be be a the out pule should be used in the way that we, as workers, want it used, and not in favour of the bosses.
Unless the gains we have won are defended, they become meaningless. It is a false argument to say that positive discrimination means that we accept redundancies for men but not for women - just a cop out for not defending workers' rights.
The fight against unemployment must be fought by the whole labour movement. Unless that happens there will always be unemployment. But where redundancies do go through, they should not hit women hardest.
A fight to protect one job is the start of a fight to protect all jobs. Defend women's right to work!
FRAN BRODIE (Stepney & Poplar Labour Party & Fightback).
WE DON'T WORK FOR PIN MONEY!
vie.l Freds wages: over tee drus IT'S A WOMAN'S RICHT TO HAVE A JOB bar leaflet: £5 Ellington S
----- pull-quotes -----
WRITE BACK