BENN ON LABOUR DEMOCRACY Like Poland ike Britain
Socialist Organiser1980 1980-09-13Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
At the TUC fringe meeting: Tony Banks, Tony Benn, John Bloxam a guide to the issues TONY BENN told 200 TUC delegates: I SAY to you candidly that even if the TUC were to say that there should be no Cruise missiles sited here, and if the Labour Party conference were to say there would be no Cruise missiles here. there is no reason whatever to believe that a Labour government elected thereafter would in fact remove the Cruise missiles. There is no reason to believe it, because there is no mechanism to ensure that it will happen.
Events in Poland in the last few days - which have indicated the desire for democratic control of the trade union movement in Poland - have come at a time that is very helpful for us. It indicates that it's not only in Britain that people in the labour movement want to control their leaders, and not have their leaders control them.
The only way that members of trade unions affiliated to the Labour Party can influence the manifesto for the next general eleçtion, or be sure that the by VLADI DERER THE AGENDA for the forthcoming Labour Party Annual Conference is now out. It shows that the Party continues to give high priority to constitutional reform.
About a third of all the amendments to Conference resolutions are on Labour Party democracy. Thus, contrary to the assertions of the opponents of reform, it is clear that the Party is not 'getting bored' with constitutional issues.
The fact that relatively few CLPs chose constitutional reform for the subject of their conference resolution (21 resolutions and 16 constitutional amendments) must be put down to a misunderstanding by the CLPs. They confidently expected that their submissions to the Enquiry, which many of them prepared with meticulous care, would carry weight.
A large proportion of these submissions were in favour of mandatory re-selection, elec-.
tion of the Party Leader on the basis of a wider franchise, and NEC's final responsibility for the Manifesto. It may have seemed supertluous to many CLPs that their Conterence resolution should once again reiterate their position.
Insofar as this was the case, their mistake was soon revealed. The majonty of those serving on the Commission of Enquiry paid little attention to the submissions, and the Commission finally decided not to pronounce on the three issues. The lesson is clear. The only way CLPs can influence Party policy is by making sure that Conference takes the right decisions, for, as far as the rank and file are concerned, it is allu Conference alone which carries weight. And the right decision at present means the introduction of procedures which will give ordinary Party members greater control over their elected representatives.
Leadership: In relation to the leadership issue, the 60odd amendments on constinext Labour Government carries out that policy, is by supporting all three constitutional changes. If these changes were blocked by trade union votes at conference, the trade unions themselves would be voting to weaken their own influence in the The political demands for full employment, the restoration of the welfare state and for peace, which will be coming from the TUC at Brighton this week, cannot be put into effect unless the trade unions vote in support of these same policies at the Labour Party conference, and vote to ensure that those policies are made clear in the manifesto and are carried out.
Rousing speeches at Labour Party conference, followed by massive votes in support of clear policies, raise legitimate expectations that if a Labour Government is electea these policIes Will be carried out. But if these policies can be vetoed by the Parliamentary leadership, for example on the abolition of the Lords, tutional issues now on the agenda give Conference an opportunity to be presented with thod of electing the Party Leader. Firstly, amendments to the Tottenham/Hendon North resolution (Resolution 14) from 10 Constituency Labour Parties (CLPs) and the National Organisation of Labour Students would make it possible to produce a composite resolution which will enable Conference o vote simply on the principle hat all sections of the Part should participate in the election of the Leader. Secondly, the 25 amendments to the two resolutions -from Thirsk & Maldon , and Scarborough (Nos. 11 & 12) -make it possible to produce a composite resolution demanding that Conference be allowed to vote on the constitutional amendments submitted this year. Unless such a resolution on the method of electing the Party Leader is framed and adopted, the 8 constitutional amendments lagenda pp. 15-16)
all containing the model CLPD proposal on the subject, would be taken this year • but not would automatically be reSend recommendation to Cont ference the following year (1981). It is true that because an identical proposal has now beer donted by the NEU (Agenda p.7), the above composite may be unnecessary. However, the NEC are not united behind the proposal. It may well happen, as it did last year on the Manifesto, that NEC will withdraw their own original proposal at the last minute.. In this case Confer ence would be unable to vote o 1 the and completely different policies can be introduced that are not in the interests of the labour movement, for example, a compulsory wage restraint policy, confidence in the labour movement will be undermined.
The Labour Party can only defeat the Conservatives in the next general election if it says what it means and means what it says.
constitutional change proposed in the amendment, or even on its relative merits - as no general resolution on the proposal was submitted this year.
The procedural composite 1s therefore quite vital.
Thirdly there are the various alternative methods of electing the Leader. The vote on these would come last. Among these, the constitutional amendment should clearly be taken first, as, it it is passed, the constitution would immediately be amended. Should Conference reject it, the next alternative is embodied in the Sheffield Brightside motion (no.16).
The composition of the college suggested in this resolution gives equal say to the Parliamentary Labour rarty:
the Constituency Section, and the trade unions. So far as the Rank and File Mobilising Committee and CLPD are concerned, it is an acceptable second mitted an amendment to this resolution demanding that, in the event of its being passed, the NEC should prepare a constitutional amendment along the lines suggested, to be put to Conference immediately. It is quite essential that the NEC should be prepared for this contingency. for if and only if a constitutional amendment is passed will the election of a new leader under the old Ul a Finaliy, there is the resolution trom Leeds South, which turned away from the Mobilising Committee's meeting at the TUC on September 1st. 200 packed into the meeting room while dozens of others milled around outside the doors trying to hear the speeches. The meeting wasn't a run-of-the-mill conference fringe meeting; it was part of a battle. As Tony Benn, Ron Todd from the TGWU, and John Bloxam from the Mobilising Committee were speaking in the Royal Albion Hotel, the enemy were gathering at the Metropole. Equal On the Campaign for a Labour Victory's platform David Owen, Terry Duffy from the AUEW, and CLV spokesman William Rodgers were outlining their plans to fight against Labour democracy.
The audiences for the two sides were roughly equal. The money spent is also backed by the National Advisory Council of the ILP (Independent Labour Publications). Its proposals give the PLP 50%, TUs 25%, CLPs 20%, and other affiliated organisations 5% in the proposec electoral college. Unlike in the CLPD/NEC college, no provision is made for record voting and for an automatic option of an annual election. In the interests of democracy, it is vital that this proposal is rejected. The fact that the PLP would continue to enjoy a dominant role would mean that the adoption of the Leeds South proposal would merely perpetuate the present system in a new form.
Manifesto: The proposed constitutional change giving the NEC the final say in the wording of the Party's Manifesto is covered in the constitutional amendment proposed by the NEC (Agenda p.7).
It is unlikely that the NEC would withdraw it again this year, but should it do so, practically the same amendment was submitted last year by Chipping Barnet, Hendon South, Louth, and Selly Var (see NEC Report p.18) and Conference will be entitled to vote on it. Re-selection itself continues to be on the Agenda. Just how it is going to be debated and voted on remains an open question. Strictly speaking the only thing that needs to be done is the adoption of amendments which are consequential to those changes in the constitution already effected last year. Such amendments are being put forward by the NEC.
Normally such tidying up processes would be wholly non controversial. Re-selection, however, is not uncontroversial! Its onnonents. having lost Tahnur democracv by the CLV on producing a glossy printed briefing, handed out by suntanned right-wingers in smart suits, was more than matched by the Mobilising Committee's determined lobbying of delegates during the two days before.
Never Opening the Mobilising Committee's meeting John Bloxam said: "The issue is whether we're going to have another Labour Government like the last one. The Mobilising Committee's new broadsheet says it all in the headline: 'Never Again' "It's whether we can have the possibility of a government representing the working class in the same way that the Tory government militantly represents their class." the argument, have still tried, and tried successfully, to stop this much needed measure by putting every possible obstacle in its way. It seems more than likely that they will try to turn the vote on consequential amendments into one on principle. they are successiul we will have yet another year during which the existing provisions for re-selection cannot be activated, and Labour Party members are unable to use this important mechanism for securing accountability. Supporters of reform must remain on the alert against this danger.
Finally, the agenda contains a number of resolutions and amendments on issues which are in many ways complementary to the three major ones. In their case, the prablem will be to get the issues debated. Firstly there is the demand that the Women's Section on the NEC should be elected by Labour Party women themselves at the National Conference of Labour Women. The Be elected by the mate hominated trade union block vote.
It might seem obvious that for women to be attracted to the Party, it is essential for them to elect their own representatives. This would show that the Party, in action as well as in words, is for women to make their own choices.
Unfortunately few. affiliated organisations think this.
Only one resolution and two amendments on this subject appear on the Agenda. It will take much-needed positive discrimination to get the subject debated. The problems of the other constituencies struggling to get the constitutional issue of their choice on the Agenda are different. There would appear to be no difficulty about them having a legitimate and technical claim to have their subjects debated.
The present practice is that if seven affiliated organisations send resolutions/amendments on the same subject, they are invited to attend the "It's about whether we can have a party that can attract mass membership; particularly amongst working class people, women and black people... a party in which policies aren't thrown in the dustbin, and where members aren't just footsloggers for others.
"It's about whether we can have a united determined and credible opposition to Thatcher's government - an opposition which can fight to sack Thatcher at the earliest possible opportunity."
Tony Benn followed up this theme in his speech saying: "We face the most serious challenge that has been faced by the labour movement, possibly since 1926, and we must be united. We can only be united round a structure of our party that is democratic.
Broad
"We want a broad and tolerant party, but the decisions must be made by the members of the party at the conference, advocated by the candidates, and implemented by the government.
Many of the questions at the meeting were about how we could fight for democracy in the unions to bring about reforms in the Labour Party. The Labour Co-ordinating Committee/ Socialist Organiser trade union conference on November Ist should be a place to start answering those questions in practice.
compositing , session on the Saturday prior to Conterence. l'here, a resolution iș producer vhich appears in the booklet oi composites from which the subjects for debate are chosen.
The question of democracy in the Parliamentary Labour Party in fact attracted eight resolutions and amendments. In addition, there are eight constitutional amendments proper on the issue. Yet no group meeting to finalise a composite was fixed. Instead there was to be compositing by post T'his is unusual and there is anxiety that composites not emanating from the compositing session may inadvertently be omitted from the booklet of composites and overlooked when the timetable is being devised. The democratic reform of the Parliamentary Party is of course most important if, among other things, re-selection is to work.
Labour Group democracy is another subject for which no compositing session has been called. There are altogether seven resolutions and amendments on this subject. They have however been artificially 'Group Leaders" (resolution 26), and "Group Standing Orders" (resolution 27). As a result, neither subject on its own has the backing of a sufficient number of organisations.
This may of course have been due to an oversight.
Nevertheless old hands will remember that back in the '60s the method of placing under different headings what were basically resolutions on the same subject, was used successfully to keep debates on the extension of public ownership off the Agenda.
Delegates should be on the alert and support all moves to give Conference an opportunity to consider all these important issues.
Published by Socialist Organiser, 5 Stamford Hill, London Litho [TU]. Signed articles do not necessarily reflect the point of view of Socialist Örganiser.
----- pull-quotes -----
bour guice