Resigning and resisting
Socialist Organiser1980 1980-09-27Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
IN THIS Socialist Organiser, Hackney Labour councillor JOHN SWEENEY and Lambeth councillor BILL BOWRING continue a debate opened in the January 1980 Socialist Organiser: would it strengthen the fight against the Tories if Labour councils resigned and went for re-election The debate was opened in a Socialist Organiser interview with Sweeney and another Hackney councillor, "I'd like to see the council resign. If four or five councils resigned and went for re-election on a platform of no cuts, and if we came back with, say, a doubled majority, then we'd have a platform. We could say: we were elected by the people of this borough to make no cuts; and Kodikara: "I don't agree with you on that. We were elected on a manifesto to increase and improve the services in this area. We can't do that because of what the government is imposing on us. We should be campaigning; we shouldn't cop out now and say we'll go back and Sweeney: "If you did resign, it would force you onto the doorstep. It would force the Labour parties to debate their position. That's why I saw resignation as a tactic for getting the issue out of the council chamber, into the Kodikara: "The whole focus of the struggle would be directed towards an election campaign, away from the actual fight against the cuts. We have been elected on a programme, i don't see why we should have to seek another mandate. The Thatcher programme is a direct assault on working class living standards. We should defend the working class people who elected us, and if we're going to do that we've got to fight" JOHN SWEENEY's arguments, which pose resignation by councillors as a tactic for immediate implementation, are thrown into sharp relief by Heseltine's announcements of last veek.
Ted Kni • leader of Lambeth Courcil, hus said:
... in "ambrth. we lose £2.1 millior as a direct penalty; a further :1.4 million as a result of his removing £200 m from the rate support grant; and we lose a further £10 million as a res'ilt of his cutting the urban aid programme.
•What Heseltine has done is take his revenge on those authorities which have refused to reduce the social wage of working-class families in their boroughs". Heseltine: moved faster than most councils feared, catching out even those who thought they were being 'responsible' In addition, Heseltine has refused to allow any further money to be spent on the Brixton Recreation Centre project"— a large construction site being built by a direct labour force whose future must now be in doubt. A number of Labour local authorities are therefore facing immediate decisions as to whether to cut, or levy supplementary rates — a 25p rise would be required in Tambeth. This new situation nas arisen before Heseltine's Local Government Act has even reached the statute book.
John Sweeney is quite correct when he says that local councils should not carry out these savagely anti working class measures. His article shows that he recognises that the probable result of a successfully re-elected Labour council defying the Labour Party Confere Fringe Meeting 5.30 Tuesday 30 Sep. NEEDED TO FIGHT THE TORIES:
LABOUR DEMOCRACY AND TRADE UNION DEMOCRACY Speakers: Reg Race MP, Stephen Corbishley (CPSA, Brixton dole personal capacity). Chair: Jonathan Hammond (NUJ NEC, in personal capacity). At: Hotel & Guest Hous Association, 87a Coronation Street, Blackpool government would be the appointment of commissioners or receivers. This would happen to any council, reelected or not, taking such a step.
The question is whether the tactic of resignation and re-election before such a confrontation would significantly improve the prospects of defeating the government.
What is quite clear is that there will be a real and bitter fight within our movement to achieve a confrontation at all, since a confrontation will mean breaking the law. The Labour Party's official line is that Councils should try, within the law, to mitigate the effects of Tory policies, and wait for the next General Election.
Take, for instance, the forced sale of council houses. The Party's 1979 Conference, resolution on housing 'urged' Labour councils "to actively oppose' the Tory legislation "in whatever lawful ways they can'. At a conference called by the National Executive Committee in Sheffield on 6th September, only N.E. Derbyshire and Lambeth, out of 70 Councils attending, spoke in favour of an outright (and illegal) refusal to operate the 'right to buy provisions in the new Housing Act.
Lambeth's officers are now arguing in favour of slow implementation' of the Act, and warning of the dire consequences — surcharges or even prison — or anything more militant. The Act is drafted in such a way that even slow implementation would be pretty rapid. There will therefore be great pressure to capitulate, by selling council houses, by cutting either directly through redundancies and cuts in services — or indirectly, through rate or rent increases.
In the view of Lambeth Labour Left, which I support, it is and would be impermissible for Labour councillors to be the agency through which Tory crisis measures are imposed on the working class. Just as the shop floor representative, in accepting a position of leadership, accepts also the possible consequences in victimisation, loss of livelihood, or worse, so the councillors should face up to the possible consequences of illegality.
Where John Sweeney's argument is correct is that those Labour councillors unwilling or unable to take such a stand should be able to resign — to allow others to take their places.
Canterence Fringe Meelins Socialisi Organiser 5.30. Tueeday 30th TORIES: LABOUA DEMOCRACY AND NEEDEO TO FIGHT THE TRADE UNION DEMOCRACY •NCI NEL pe osa ONATMiNHAMMAUNO Campaig: Committer At Hotel & Guast House 87a Coronalion Straot Socialist Organiser will be producing a daily conference Briefing at Blackpool, as we have for the last 2 years. He is also right when he says that there must be a campaign — as he said in an interview in the January 1980 SO, "getting out of the council chamber" • However, 1 cannot agree that the alternative is to get onto the doorstep in the election campaign which would follow mass resignations.
It is quite clear that the Tories' policies can only be fought by a campaign which either forces a radical change of policy towards local government — as well as in the Health Service, education, etc. — or brings about the downfall of the government itself. Such a campaign will not arise out of by-election campaigns, or even localised rent and rate strikes. It will on a 'no cuts' platform?
Patrick Kodikara. Sweeney argued:
we'd have some force behind us"
contest again"
borough" require the mobilisation of the trade unions and of the working class community as it is organised in tenants, residents, and interest group organisations.
In that sense, the November ist conference at Camden Town Hall, called by Lambeth Labour group and sponsored by the local authority unions, is a vital and revolutionary step forward. A commitment to strike action in January 1981 must be fought for, with the perspective of bringing local government to a halt. Action sufficient to change Tory policy may very probably be that which will bring them down.
But in my view such a call from Labour councillors and party members will have no credibility if Labour councils are prepared to cut or rate or sell their way out of the immediate crisis. That is why councillors must be held to a principled position of no cuts, no rate increases, and no sales: which means confrontation.
In the context of mobilising the sort of campaign that is then required, John Sweeney's argument for mass resignations, with the few weeks' respite and electioneering which would ensure, do not seem to me at all convincing. LOCAL AUTHORITIES are in a state of crisis. They are being forced to dismantle essential services on which large numbers of working class people depend; and at the same time to destroy jobs and enforce redundancies that will result in even more people being unemployed.
With the advent of the new local government act the last vestiges of local autonomy will disappear and local councils will be in the full control of central government, who will then use them as instruments for enacting Tory policies.
It will be an end to the hopes of many radical socialists who saw their presence on local councils as a means of capturing part of the machinery of government and making it work for the benefit of working people. Of course it may be that even the pre-Heseltine structures of local government were not suitable vehicles for carrying out a socialist programme, and so when organising against the present round of cuts the Labour movement should be debating what kind of changes need to be made, and what kind of organisations we want to see come into being.
The real control over coun cils by central government is through the control of their finances. At present local authorities rely for two-thirds of their money on central government. This means that a council's policy must accord with government guidelines or else funds are withheld.
Banks
The prime example is housing, where local councils are forced to put the rents up in order to obtain subsidies. Even when councils raise the money themselves, by borrowing from banks, they must first get government approval for the project.
This approval for councils to spend their own money is called loan sanction. So even by JOHN SWEENEY in areas of immediate and desperate need - such as much-needed nurseries or old people's homes - the council must first get permission to spend the money. The only real freedom coun cils have is deciding the colour schemes for the building the government allows them to put up.
Cuts
Of course this analysis oversimplifies the situation, since there are very important areas, such as the funding of law centres and community nurseries, where the council can act independently. But in times of government cuts — and this is when these kinds of services are most needed — these are the very projects most threatened.
The real issue is whether or not the gains in the provision of a few fringe services is worth the loss of having to impose cuts over a wide range of services and impose rent and rate rises in times of falling living standards.
The extra restrictions and implied penalties for nonconforming councils in the forthcoming Local Government Act have brought many of these issues to a head. The government is demanding a reduction in council spending, but nearly all local authorities are going to be overspent because of high interest charges and inflation -both of which have been brought about by government policies. Even though the extra spending is not the 'fault' of councils, the government refuses to help them, and is insisting that any overspending this year must be repaid next year in the form of extra cuts.
For many councils these extra cuts must take the form of enforced redundancies, creases. If councils are then removed from office because they won't implement government policies and the commissioners are put in — as a recent report in Time Out magazine suggests — then local resistance, possibly in the form of rent and rate strikes, should be organised.
This will cause a constitutional crisis, but it will put into clear perspective those who are really making the cuts and why.
The tactic of resigning could be criticised as handing things over to the Tories — especially in those areas where there is a sizeable minority of Tory councillors who could presumably run the council in the absence of Labour members. However, the time scale from resignation to re-election would average out at about six weeks, and I would contend that there is very little that a makeshift Tory administration could do in so short a time. And even if certain measures were rushed through, the returning Labour councillors could rescind them.
For many local authorities there are inconsequential amounts of Tories - in Hackney there is only one — and so the question of a Tory takeover doesn't arise. It could be that the strategy of resignation is best suited to a small number of authorities where there is no chance of letting the Tories in; but even if only four or five London boroughs were to resign they would confront the government with re-elected councillors representing over a million people.
It could cause the kind of confrontation that would force a general election that would — as happened with the miners - sweep , the Tories from power
----- pull-quotes -----
SOCIALISI ÖRGANISER lTheir Labov Party OrIOWrs