Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Ikeding fine leader

Socialist Organiser no. 27, 11 October 1980 · scan p. 4 · about 1,360 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

Campaign for Labour Party Democracy, presents a personal view of the Blackpool Labour Party conference.

THE TORY press greeted the outcome of this year's Labour Party Conference with horror. 'Labour Anwere the headline Chaos?

The comments in the 'quality' newspapers were no less hysterical. The Times perceived what happened at Blackpool as "the dark side of Britain" and the Guardian spoke of the labour movement being rocked by the revolt of the 'lumpen polytechnic".

The Sunday Times discovered in Blackpool the road to serfdom, while the Sunday Telegraph is haunted by the vision of a Britain enslaved by an unrepresentative Commons majority acting as "agent of a revolutionary caucus" • By contrast the ObservParty so iven icted internal C micicl predicted that dissensions will wither away.

The Observer's fantasy was fittingly underwritten by members of the Labour parliamentary establishment. After Wednesday's vote on the Party Leader, Shirley Williams quickly wrote off all Labour's chances of winning the next general election. again to be gagged.

Finally, conference rejected the alternatives offered to it which would have enabled it to implement the principle of a wider franchise for the election of the Party leader which it had just endorsed.

Thus virtually the only new step forward in a democratic direction was taken when conference voted in favour of this principle. The proposal itself is hardly revolutionary. After all, this is how the European social democratic parties elect their leader. It is theretore quite misleading to pretend that the victory on this issue was by itself a major one.

There are, however, some reasons why, despite the number of setbacks in other directions, this step could become vital, and, on balance, give this year's conference the importance claimed for it by both opponents and some supporters of reform.

In the present context the question of method of electing the leader, like that of mandatory re-selection before it, has clearly come to occupy the central position in the current stage of political struggle. That this is so is indicated by the heat which this conflict has generated.

As a result even a modest advance in this area assumed the significance of a major breakthrough — certainly in the eyes of the defenders of the status quo. However, whether their assessment is correct, and not just the product of hysteria or euphoria, will only be decided by the outcome of the struggle 611' Callaghan's concept of the Li the rank and file launches ti orbit, then falls safely into which this advance made possible. It will entirely depend on the extent to which the opportunities which the extension of the franchise offers, will actually be used.

It will depend on conference adopting next January a method of election of the Party leader which would ensure that the rank and file are given a significant say.

More specifically it will depend on the adoption of a provision:

La) for direct representation of CLPs in the electoral college of no less than 30%, Mb) for an automatic option elect a new leader annual(and not once and for all); c) for a recorded vote. It is customary for trade unions and CLPs to declare how they voted. There is no reason why this principle should not be extended to MPs who, at present, are allowed to keep their preferences secret (both in respect of policies and personalities). The PLP will not be accountable until this anachronistic practice is ended.

Of the three options that were put to conference, only the CLPD proposal, reluctantly backed by the NEC, fulfilled these conditions. Both the NEC's ⅓:⅔:⅓ 'amendment' and their subsequent proposal providing for a 40:30:30 representation for trade unions, PLP and CLPs failed to satisfy these requirements, since the annual election principle as well as the provision for a recorded vote was omitted from them.

Even though tactics at conference dictated that all three proposals should be supported, in the new situation it is crucial that all these provisions are incorporated in any new proposals.

Opponents of reform, having failed to frustrate a decision on principle, will no doubt try to minimise the 'damage' by producing a "soft' option. The only way to counter such moves is:

a) to work out as soon as Bassid one wore pose based the •aoove three conditions and at the same time likely to be acceptable to the majority. CLPD will shortly be circulating a draft.

b) to campaign for the adoption of the new proposal as widely as possible. It is essential that it be put forward by a vast number of CLPs and at least some trade unions.

Apart from the CLPD normal channels, the Rank and File Mobilising Committee will have a vital role to play here. Massive support alone will defeat attempts to render the newly won principle harmless by its integration into an establishmentarian setting.

Unity among those favouring democratic reform is essential. It is to be hoped BOUR PART abour Party: he MPs into the ocean. ».

that Tribune MPs will this time join in the common effort and that Militant supporters will refrain from producing slightly different proposals.

Hopefully unity will be made easier by the fact that the January conference will be limited to one issue only.

This may spare us the repeated experience of being lectured at by some comrades from the LCC and Militant, for example, on the relative importance of constitutional issues.

Space allows only a brief mention of other matters.

Still on the constitutional issues, the suppression of the vital resolution on democracy within the PLP passed almost unnoticed. The Conference Arrangements Committee ruled that the eight resolutions and amendments on this subject were not eligible to become a composite resolution since three resolutions were identical and "therefore" could only be amended.

This rule is unwritten and contradicts the official circular to all organisations which states that, 'It is the established practice where seven or more organisations are involved with resolutions or amendments on the same subject for group meetings to be held on the Saturday afternoon preceding the Conference"

Kepresentations to the Standing Orders Committee by the delegates of all the eight CLPs proved ineffective and the Tottenham delegate when moving the reference back was not allowed by the chairwoman to say more than a few words. The subject - which includes the demand for the availability of a detailed record of PLP deliberations and decisions - was thereby successfully kept off the agenda. It is imperative that it be debated IICAE vcar. since democracy in she PEP 15 r precondition for the effective monitoring of an MP's performance.

On other subjects, the compositing session on economic strategy failed to produce an acceptable composite which would have included the demand for a significant extension of public ownership in industry and financial institutions as well as a commitment to a realistic rate of economic growth. What emerged instead was a resolution with 'maximalist' demands including our old friend the call for the nationalisation of 200 monopolies.

Predictably this was heavily defeated. A definite commitment to the adoption of vital measures for the control of the economy was thus prevented. Once again the ultra left has col-PL.P Ivan luded with the Right to maintain the status quo. Will the Militant comrades ever learn?

Among the emergency resolutions that on Poland was perhaps the most important.

It was also kept off the Agenda. This was made relatively easy by the fact that from among the many resolutions submitted on the same subject that inspired by Militant was chosen.

It contained primarilý Militant's advice to Polish workers, and had practically nothing to say on how the Labour Party might help the newly emerging movement of the Polish working class.

The demand that the Labour Party should recognise the newly-formed Solidarity trade unions as the only authentic representative of the Polish working class was thus not made. Hardly a demonstration of international working class solidarity.

• Renewed efforts in this direction are imperative if the British labour movement is not to be regarded by the East European workregimes they have to live under.

----- pull-quotes -----

ing class as an accomplice of the oppressive bureaucratic

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 27

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →