Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[These are grievous blows to the traditional method…]

Socialist Organiser no. 27, 11 October 1980 · scan pp. 5–7 · about 2,285 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

These are grievous blows to the traditional method of burying or fudging all important differences between Labour and the Tories. In a situation which may well quickly become explosive, they give good reason for the ruling class to gnash its teeth. They deprive the ruling class of a reliable fallback party of government such as Labour was after Heath was routed in 1974. (Whether EEC withdrawal would actually serve working class interests is a separate issue...)

Control gained over MPs is a sharp reassertion of the fact there is one labour movement, Labour Party and trade unions.

Re-selection gives the trade unions affiliated to local Lahour Parties a direct and regular role in determing what the labour movement does in Parliament. If we are not cheated on the allows certain trade unions to play a positive role in securing more Labour Party democracy when often they themselves are not at all democratic. It is good they play a positive role. But it is sheer illusion to dream that small groups of trade union officials wielding block votes can be stable allies of the Left on democracy. It is nonsense to think that they and their methods of functioning can be our allies in a serious fight for socialism.

• The second weakness is the lack of a real mass membership base in the Labour Party, the result of the way Labour has functioned in the past. Resolutions like the Lambeth one lay the basis for building up an active mass membership.

• There is also much political confusion. The conference voted to come out of the Common Market yet to stay in NATO: to unilaterally give up nuclear weapons -but to stay in a military alliance depending on them.

Scan page 6

HANNIYS SINNIO CONTRARY to all the press talk, my guess is that a lot of younger people, women in particular, and those that are unemployed, will be enthused about the activities that have taken place here. You can always measure conference by the enthusiasm of those attending. There were more people attending this conterence right up to the last morning than any time | can remember. The seats were full for nearly the whole time.

Now that must be a reflection as to what is happening outside. Working people must realise that if they want to get rid of Thatcher, they don't just want a Labour government that's going to threaten to do things. They want one which is going to carry out these promises, and that means that the accountability arguments have got to be sustained.

The new NEC must ensure that they don't get outflanked by the Parliamentary leadership, and like losing. They're not used to it.

Whereas some of us are used to losing, they will fight back with any kind of weapons at their disposal.

Then of course we have to carry out the campaigns we are committed to, like the unemployment rally on November 29th in THE DEFEAT of the right wing bid to alter the composition of Labour's NEC was universally portrayed by the press as a 'mix-up' One member of the AUEW delegation, Dougie Knott, was singled out as 'the man who didn't know who he was voting for'.

The Financial Times reported: "Sir John Boyd, general secretary, later claimed that despite instructions before the meeting, a delegate from Dorset, Mr D A Knott, had confessed afterwards he did not realise whom he was voting for.

"I told him who to vote for.

Sir John said.

«Mr Terry Duff. ALEH Merseyside. We've got to ensure that we are a campaigning party and not one simply devoted to winning Parliamentary or local government elections.

When we've left Blackpool, we're back to the picket lines, aren't we? We're back to the battles that are going to take place over wages, and my view is that instead of trucking along to No.10 Downing St trade union leaders ought to be putting in pay demands for 21% like they've given the police.

It used to be frowned upon when I first went to Parliament for MPs to actually go on a picket line. I remember in the cod' ainers' strike of 1972, 1 was caricatured in a newspaper for going on a picket line.

Had it not been for an illness, I would have been there at the Brixton picket line. I sent a message down, supporting them fully and wishing them well, and I was pleased that Reg Race and Stuart Holland went along.

And then we had Ken Thomas, the leader of the civil service union involved, who was attacking MPs for being there. I think Ken Thomas ought to be looking over his other shoulder, at the right wing in his union.

Because those people on the picket line, not just the MPs • but all the rest, helped to gain a partial victory for the two men concerned. KNOTT president, said that Mr Knott "was very, very sorry for what he did."

But Bro. Knott, who attended Socialist Organiser's fringe meeting at conference, explained there that he had made no mistake.

"Sir John, in commun with others, has been flattered by Fleet Street in some ways and, as I am, misquoted in others"

Dougie Knott explained: "I believe that the constituency parties, the workers at the bottom, are the people who should make the effective policy of the Labour Party and the working class morement" WHILE THE debate on democracy and accountability was not taken until Wednesday, its shadow loomed (threateningly for Labour MPs) over every Monday morning saw the debate on economic strategy, incomes, and employment. Two resolutions were passed contradicting each other on wage controls, a demand for 'selective import controls' was endorsed, and the conference rejected a resolution calling on the NEC to organise a campaign now to fight unemployment.

David Basnett, from the GMWU, moving Composite 19 on economic strategy, declared that the arguments of the '60s and '70s for totally free collective bargaining no longer applied, and we needed an agreement between the next Labour government and the IUC to work out an incomes policy but 'within the context of a national economic and social plan' What this meant was clearly spelled out by Denis Healey — who knows exactly what incomes policies mean, having had long experience of imposing them on the working class! An incomes policy is needed to avoid another winter of discontent and the embarrassment that caused the Labour leadership.

As a delegate from the floor pointed out, 'Dennis Healey is weeping crocodile tears. It was him that led the attack on the working class last time... No incomes policy has ever worked in the interests of working But the right wing insisted deceitfully that wage restraint could only be considered as part of an overal plan for socialism. Conterence rejected any form of wage restraint now under the Tories, and then said it should be possible under the next Labour government if it is worked out with the TUC. But we've had enough experience of this type of Social Contract swindle, as rank and file trade unionists will agree!

The CLP vote seemed on the show of hands to be mostiy against the post office workers' union resolution for wage restraint under a future Labour Government, and it was nearly the first card vote of conference. Then Lena Jeger made up her mind and ruled that the motion was carried.

Tony Benn (summing up for the NEC) argued against Composite 20 and 31.

20 called for public ownership and control of industry, achieved through an Enabling Act passed by the next Labour government la Militant-inspired resolution), and 31 for the NEC to organise a campaign to fight redundancies with the policy: cut the hours, not the jobs; nationalise firms threatening redundancies.

Benn said that since these issues had not been fully worked out between the NEC and the trade union leadership, no guaranice could be made about a future Labour governnie*. putting them into practice. Since these were the two resolutions to commit the Party to transforming this capitalist society into a socialist society, this hardly bodes well for the future role of the NEC.

CALLAGHAN'S speech stirred and surprised no-one.

Predictably he attacked the Tories, calling Thatcher •the most self-opinionated prime minister" since himself... sorry, he actually said Neville Chamberlain. He admitted that many in the Party thought him a bad socialist. But not to worry, as he was coming to the end of his political career.

He declared himselt for incomes policy, and against disarmament until everyone else has disarmed first. He had met Brezhnev and Cartand "None of the gen eration that went through the last war... will ever release the bomb". Some hope!

He finished off by calling for trust as an alternative to Party democracy. Trust him after what he did in the last Labour Government? He had to be joking. The disgusting thing was - he wasn't.

A large number of delegates walked out after Callaghan's speech and consequently missed the debates on the Health Service, Low Pay, and Social Security benefits.

All the composites were carried - including no.14 on Disabled Persons, against the NEC recommendation to remit. It called on the next Labour Government to restore all cuts in benefits and services that the Tories have made. Surely the NEC should have been in favour of that!

Tony Banks - speaking to Composite 25 on the NHS - drew attention to the disgusting spectacle of the harassment of old people for the sake of monetarism at St Benedict's Hospital. He pointed out the role of the police. 'They tell us there has been a shortage of police - but there never seems to be a shortage when there is a picket-line to bust up"

Alan Fisher, moving the Composite on Low Pay (35), managed to avoid breaking his neck while looking both ways at once. "Incomes policy as part of economic planning - I go along with that' • But: "we had to strike against the Social Contract in the winter of discontent"

He rounded off with a declaration: 'Never again must we tind ourselves in conflict with a Labour government over pay". Never again, indeed, must a Labour government try to cut the real wages of the working class. But if there is an incomes policy (worked out with the TUC or not), NUPE members will be in the firing line again.

On Social Security benefits, Terry Parry of the Fire Brigades Union pointed out that if private insurance companies did what the Tories plan to do with Earnings Related Supplement, i.e. we pay the money in but we don't get any out - they would find themselves before the courts.

•80% OF JUDGES, 86% of generals and 60% of Tory MPs went to private schools", said Graham Lane from the Socialist Education Association, moving Thatposite 22 on education.

ainst — and the Tories are busy transferring more money from the state education system to the private schools.

Conference passed unanimously the resolution demanding an end to private schooling. The next Labour government should make it illegal to charge for education.

But Neil Kinnock, summing up from the platform, still did not commit himself to restoring all the cuts the Tories had made in education. Instead he came out with an oblique explanation that there had to be enough money to go round, and JO THWAITES rel money had to be generated so that education could be freely available to all.

Restoring education to pre-Tory standards was not enough, he said. Very true - but where was the declaration that he would even do that? He didn't tell us.

Until the debate on transport, very little was said about what could be done now, before the election of a future Labour Government. Ken Livingstone pointed out that transport comes under the control of local authorities, so free transport was something we could implement now.

The resolution was overwhelmingly carried, but Ken Livingstone stressed:

"It's vital that the key constitutional issues are passed, to ensure that policies voted for at conference are carried into reality — otherwise we are just talking"

Despite Arthur Scargill's support for the composite on nuclear power, calling for its phasing out on grounds of safety, it was defeated. If the supporters of nuclear power could give him a cast-iron guarantee that nuclear power could be produced safely, said Scargill, then he would change his position. But he reckoned they couldn't; and that, as long as there are 1000 years ot coal beneath our teet, there is no need tor nuclear power.

Nuclear accident inspectors give 500,000 as the number of people at risk in an accident of the kind that nearly happened at Three Mile Island.

But the big votes backed Gavin Laird's claim that the AUEW protected its members and there was no danger to workers in nuclear power stations. If the AUEW 'protects' its members like that, then we can see why si ing jobs ha so little fig TUESDAY the begin slow busi the const ments. speeches Commissi report. W been done controvers ately, in through tl by laborio The N tion was on propr member:

supporte (rightly)

both wer When impleme file will they are option fi or to cr passive appealer wing di bates.

porters l the Par member the reci into the right -an appe family t wife an at a 'red THE M.

ference ment ( selection of electin Confe the car out. M please t always | constitu they ci Parliam This + MP fo ranted there w

Scan page 7

BLACKE

----- pull-quotes -----

they've got to understand that the right wing don't

DOUG WE OU mistake

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 27

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →