Half a revolution
Socialist Organiser1980 1980-10-11Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
draws a balance sheet on Blackpool and the tasks facing TO JUDGE by the frenzied and almost demented baying of the press, a revolution occurred at Blackpool: "Benn's October Revolution", as one paper put it. A new Labour Party is born, proclaimed the Express.
Not quite yet. Blackpool merely unblocked some of the passages through which a real revolution can surge.
It is one of the most important political breakthroughs for the labour movement in decades: but at best it is half a revolution: the opening half. We would do well to remember what Saint-Just said during the French Revolution: Those who make a revolution by halves only dig their own graves. Blackpool decision in principle on electing the leader, the electoral college will give the unions as the unions, and the local Parties (including union delegates), a direct voice in exercising control over the Party leader and over the Prime Minister if Labour is in office.
This direct dependence and control is a powertul extension of the competence of the labour movement. Previously we sent MPs who entrenched themselves in the bourgeois Parliament and set up Labour Governments which entrenched themselves behind the state machine. From now on we send representatives — and we can call them back, too.
If we organise to make these reforms work for the working class, they are the beginning of a situation that has not existed in the three-quarters of a century since the trade unions developed a political arm. Direct channels are being opened for the control by the labour movement over our own representatives in Parliament and therefore. if Labour has a majority, control over Parliament.
And we can win the next election. That is why the ruling class is scared.
All the more significant therefore is the conference decision to support direct action now against the Tories (on the cuts), and not to wait for the election.
• The right wing is heavily discredited. The Gang of Three spent the week threatening to commit political suicide if the Conference did not stop cutting their throats. They have still got great reserves of support which the press might help them mobilise.
But their only immediate hope is the unions. Their desperation is shown by Owen's open attack on the union block vote. If the block vote does not save him, nothing will in the period ahead.
HOWEVER, the strength of the Left is full of weaknesses.
• The Left's reliance on the block vote is a source of great potential weakness.
A strange unevenness Conference voted both for incomes policy and against it.
The proposal to withdraw from the Common Market is not part of a drive to secure Britain for the workers, but a reflex of little Englandism at best. and chauvinism at worst. It is also nonsense. It implies that Britain can be self-sufficient. It cannot. Apart from 1 questons of internationalist principle. the British workers need the European working class. Our central weakness is that the working class movement does not yet have a coherent policy to deal with the enormous crisis of British society. It has a hodgepodge of measures which propose more or less drastic tinkering with the economy and the political system not its replacement by a radically new system. Nothing less than the submission of the economy to democratic planning on the basise of social ownership will allow the regeneration ¡ WE WILL FiGHT... … AND FIGHT ACAIN Garlan The Tory Sunday Telegrat of British society and provide a new dynamic and purpose for the economy.
This means that the working class must take over the monopolies (about 200 of them) and begin to plan and organise the resources we have to serve the needs and interests of the working To do that we need 1o organise ourselves to take on the existing rulers who control not only the press and the House of Lords but the police, the civil service bureaucracy, and the army. The experience of the whole world and the class struggles of all history, from Britain itself in past centuries to Chile seven years ago, shows beyond reasonable doubt that they wil use those weapons against us if we seriously threaten them.
The violence and unscrupulousness of their press now, early in the game, is a declaration of intent by the ruling class — which has no scruples where protecting its rule is concerned, and has the potential to attempt the violent destruction of the labour movement.
the 1524 the 1974 Manifesto) of the What is Labour's policy?
It was Wilson's veto (for 1973 Conference decision to nationalise the 25 biggest monopolies that triggered the campaign for Labour Party democracy which has now changed the basis of the Labour Party. Yet the first version of the 'rolling manifesto issued by the leftwing NEC' this summer omitted that policy.
Instead it had various posals for attempting to regulate capitalism so that it would behave like something else while still controlled by the capitalists.
At Blackpool a resolution committing Labour to nationalisation under workers' control of firms making workers redundant was defeated. Tony Benn spoke against it. Labour needs a firm commitment to nationalise the major firms of the economy as a basis (the only possible basis) for creating a democratically plannea economy• In relation to the ruling class's massive reserves of power and force concentrated in the state machine, Labour, as of now, proposes to abolish the House of Lords, to pass an Information Act to reduce official secrecy, and to abolish the SPG. This is ridiculously inadequate!
For all his valuable exposures of the unelected and undemocratic power of the permanent civil service bureaucracy: Tony Benn does not favour dismantling and ... AND FIGHT...
TO SAVE THE PARTY WE H got it right for once destroying that power. He does not even propose the US system in which many public officials are elected.
He wants the labour movement to act as an extraparliamentary force to counterbalance the bureaucracy's influence on "the Minister"
The most useful thing about the outcry against Benn' Blackpool speech on the House of Lords is this lesson: if that is what we get when we threaten one of the checks and balances that protect capitalism, what would the Tories and their class not do its direct control of the MPs it elects.
In the last analysis, the capitalists' power resides not in Parliament but in control of industry and in the monopoly of force in the state. We must not confuse Parliamentto use Parliament and to control our MPs; but the working class will take power where power is to be found, in society and by destroying the bourgeois state.
SO WHAT dangers does the Left face now?
• We may be cheated on the leadership question. A coup may be pulled by the election of Healey — who beleves that possession is nine points of the law. Or a wretched fake-left like Shore may be elected.
The fact that the Manifesto remains in the hands of the leader and the Shadow Cabinet (elected by the MPs) makes the selection of the leader of great importance now. As it is, Labour conference can still be ignored or manipulated. Reselection is a powertul weapon, but punitive and retaliatory rather than controling, and only every four or five years. If the right wing wriggle out of yearly re-selection of the leader, they will keep a huge power.
Any reliance on individual leaders is a danger for the Left. Despite everything positive Benn is doing now, his Conference speech against nationalisations confirms that rule in relation to him.
All sorts of manipulation by the right wing are also possible if they regain the initiative: a separate PLP leader. American-style 'primaries' to get round mandatory re-selection, etc. But the greatest danger for the Left is that we will fail to fight to rearm the movement politically, hot on the heels of the breakthrough on democracy. We must rearm the movement with real socialist policies at the same time as we fight for democracy.
At any given moment we must intelligently focus (as on the immediate struggle on the electoral college between now and the January conference), but it is an illusion that the transformation of the labour movement can be done in segmented stages. The energy that has helped secure the democratic advances is left-wing political frustration, desire for the Labour Government to be different next time, built up in the class struggles against the last Labour government. on reality, such a lack of clear definition of what is to be done and how, by whom and against whom, that the drive to renovate the labour movement can be derailed.
Whoever led it, a Labour Government elected on these policies would flounder. This needs to be said now while there is still time to do something about it.
As Benn said at conference, a Labour government would be tested in its first hours as to whether it would accommodate to vested interests or challenge them. If it set out to challenge pulicies the bosses consider fundamental, like EEC membership, but not to deal seriously with their right to own the means of production and their actual control of society, it would almost certainly wind up accommodating on the essentials. The point about ideas like price controls, presented in the rolling manifesto as a bright idea without any notion of ends and means and who and whom, is that they can only be jettisoned, and at the very point when workers who have been led to believe in them as realistic socialist policies are expecting them to perform their miracles: that is, when the Labour Left would assume governmental power.
The fuzziness now prepares the way for betrayal in future - even if one takes for granted the honourable intentions and sincere commitment of the entire leadership of the present Labour left.
SO WHAT do we need to do?
• • First things first. The Left, as broadly defined as possible, from Tony Benn to Moss Evans, must band together to consolidate the decision in principle taken in Blackpool on the election of the leader. We must maintain the Mobilising Committee.
• We must make re-selection work. We need to act with great urgency immediately to seize the chance to make a real breakthrough. We must turn the Labour Parties outwards against the Tories.
We must make a drive build factory branches.
• The basis for a democratic labour movement will never be secure until the unions are democratically controlled by the rank and file. We must turn to the unions. It was the skulduggery of Terry Duffy and people such as the leaders of UCATT and ASTMS that almost brought the drive for
----- pull-quotes -----
ary with state power. It is immensely important