WRITE BACK general
Socialist Organiser1980 1980-10-11Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
The labour movement I HAVE just received my "sample" copy of Socialist Organiser, and I am very impressed by it.
May I take this opportunity of making few comments through your columns.
Congratulations to Moss Evans. and his call for a mass protest by his union — this would go much further if other unions followed his example. Just how much more can we stand at the hand of Thatcher the Snatcher? Escalating unemploycrosion or mne workle cass position: just how much can we take before we say that enough is enough?
Now is the time for all to come to the aid of the Party, sa! once and for all that we've had enough, for if we don't it will continue to get worse. Why should we wait for the new financial year to suffer still further burdens by way of increased rates and rents. It is high time that we all stood shoulder to shoulder and said NO!
Monetarist policies are already being implemented by many employers; wage increases will be, as before, well below the cost of living ally affect the livelihoods of many of our brothers, not to forget our own standard of living, which will mean next to nothing. Let us come together in solidarity to protect the livelihood of our families. Mass action is but the only way to put paid to Thatcher and her Government.
Far too often the weak are made the scapegoats for monetarist policies, the weak who do not know their rights, the weak who are unable to stand up for themselves, the weak who are cast to one side all in the name of monetarist policies which are being • seen to fail — look at the CBI, Edwardes: are they not also saying enough? Only the CBi savs.
own mouthpiece says. enough of this, it is not working - get on with the job.
No, 1 say to you, join Moss Evans' call for a General Strike and show this reactionary Government that enough is enough: you are not going to walk over us any more.
Yours fraternally, TONY BILES
Write to: 5 St.
Hill, London I IN HIS ARTICLE 'Noble Manly', Tom Cast rightly condemns br for the organised and I ised thuggery that if is. avowed aim of the gan to club the other man submission, or to injure so badly that the autho are forced to intervene.
To enjoy this spec tacle is surely to take deligi ht in a rather pernicious for m of entertainment V vhich 'body' will collapse first!
However, while it is easy enough for us to conc demn the argument that br axing is the poor boy's only way to fame and fortune, it is a sad fact that there is a br oxing boom in the ports and v 'alley towns of South Wales , because of the present eco nomic depression.
The boys are not conned into boxing by devious traigers, nor do they go into "WHAT IS history but a tale agreed upon?' • said (I think) the first Bonaparte. There are also, of course, facts. Tony Benn's account of the development of the Rank and File Mobilising Committee for Labour Democracy would be less of a "tale' and more like the actual history if he had a clearer grasp of the facts.
In his interview with Pat Kane and Hugh Richards (Socialist Challenge 165), he says: "All of a sudden, and very much to my surprise, there was the development of the Mobilising Committee When the Militant tendency came in to the Mobilising Committee... all of a sudden it began to come alive...
This account bears no resemblance to the reality. Apart from the fact that the Mobilising Committee did not die when Militant joined, it is the opposite of the truth.
The facts: Militant's involvement came after the Mobilising Committee was launched. It has been a formal involvement, tokenistic to the point of being nominal involvement. For example: Militant took 50 of the first broadsheet about one for each of its organisers. (total sold: 17,000). It took 75 of the second broadsheet (which carried an article by one of its people). The , LPYS, completely dominated by Militant, took 200 copies of to the report on the Beyond the Fragments' conference in SO 25 by Sophia Caplan which, I feel. was characterised by snide asides rather than by serious analysis.
While I am not a sympathiser of the various libertarian currents mentioned (in fact I am an so supporter), 1 must protest at the implications that the women's movement and the libertarians are not part of the left, or that they abstain from combative political actions. Both implications are patently untrue.
Admittedly, antipathy
Leninism, as a reaction a serious weakness in these movements but, given the smallness of those currents • == fourd around Workers' Action. Socialist Organiser and batten : and • it becain iney enjoy beating iman people up. Boxing is seen as ›xing a legitimate means for young egal- boys to get out of the poverty • The and boredom of unemployne is ment, or to avoid the prosinto pect of unemployment.
more than he is hurt himself, then he can get on, and for him, boxing : is a good, enjoyable sport - which is why Pinter, and all the other 'successes' • are able to shrug off the damage done to their opponents by blandly stating that "Life must go on"
What sort of life is that? It is a deliberately brutal and destructive life into which they are pushed by the promise of an escape from poverty. But just think of what they're involved in.
As Tom says, possibly the most persuasive argument against boxing is the sight of the first, none of the second. Less than 100 of the first broadsheet were ordered by Militant supporters. in the provinces; none, as far as I know, of the second.
The paper Militant has only had lukewarmoccasional little articles on thé Mobilising Committee. Militant has not been involved prominently in organising. local meetings (with perhaps one exception); in most places. it has not been at all involved, even to the extent of its people turning up.
In short, Militant involved itself just enough to keep contact with the 'Tribunite/ Bennite Left' and just enough to stop its supporters asking why it stood aside. To the specific work of the Mobilising Committee, its contribution was marginal: that is, unless Benn thinks Militant has an occult en's movement can hardly be blamed for not noticing our 'perfection', overshadowed as we are by the SWP. CP, etc.
The women s ..itn. has done much good work t areas unforgiveably ignored by the Trotskyist left in :t.= past, and it we wish to c..the labour and wome: = movements under the barce: of revolutionary sxi we would do well to as a. ledge this rather thar : :=from the sidelines. *: =-* demonstrate our superiority in action ac=: than expect people i aciep: it on faith, and we must show our willingness to learn from the " women's movement just as we do from the labour movement.
LES HEARN Lambeth SO patieng in boxers, pre maturely aged, with their twisted hands and deformed faces, doing their roadwork for the chance that still may come"
It's tragic that a good, honest boy like Johnny Owen was forced to decide at the tender age of 8 that the greatest contribution he could make to British society was to climb into a boxing ring. to stealthily and skilfully hammer another human being into submission. In Pinter he found somebody who could do it better.
Johnny Owen, the boxer, was as much a victim of the present distortion of human relationships as the prostitute found floating in Newport Dock, but the battering he received was legal.
Yours fraternally, MIKE THOMAS ON tion that there has been "great splinter activity outside and inside the Labour Party. The SCLV initiated the Mobilising Committee and, together with the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy, 'carried' the major weight of its uniting and organising work, both at the centre of the campaign and throughout the country.
But comrade Benn or his advisors may just have noticed that the SCLV forms the revolutionary socialist wing of the Mobilising Committee..!
Yours fraternally JOHN O'MAHONY (SCLV Steering Committee) * This letter has also been sent to Socialist Challenge, commenting on their interview with Tony Benn in their Labour Conference issue.
= =33 == -="÷ =÷÷45-:
-et a -em generation oi younger, more left wing activists is working its way through the trade union structure, and was visible at the Conference.
Between now and January, the right wing will spend all its time trying to carve up the electoral college. The half dozen main union leaders will get together and try to BLACKPOOL '80 must go down as one of the momentous Labour Party Conferences.
Not because the Conference voted to commit the Party to a whole range of socialist measures such as the 35 hour week, expansion of public ownership, wealth tax, ending of nuclear weapons, opposition to wage control and support for a vital emergency motion from Lambeth proposing a united labour movement response to the Heseltine axe •- but because of the depth of the constitutional debate.
Steps were taken to give real effect to ending the élitist position of the Parliamentary Labour Party and making it accountable to the movement as a whole.
The now mandatory reselection of MPs must mean that the arrogance of "our superiors"' such as Joe Ashton MP will be threatened. How many MPs would vote for a 5% pay policy in defiance of the Party, whilst threatened with removal?
Although the leadership issue was not settled, the principle of a wider franchise than the Parliamentary Party must extend the debate about democracy throughout the labour movement.
Trade union delegates will now be involved in choosing the Labour leader, and this will no doubt turn the mind of union members to many other aspects of democracy within the trade union movement.
Anyone who witnessed the naked power broking of the •. ew. SEE:
Callaghan is giving no lead at all, and the Party desperately needs a leader prepared to fight the Tories. Callaghan is just waiting for his gold watch.
It's important that the January conference should both decide on the electoral college and elect the new leader. There's no good reason for delay.
eremy Corbyn right wing trade union general secretaries in Blackpool, in a desperate effort to protect Callaghan, must seriously question the present set-up. Individuals rushing from smoke-filled rooms to drink-sodden bar "offering" the support of their entire membership in return for some deal or other, is not a pleasant sight, and hardly fits in with the image of accountability.
A useful guide to the success of a Labour Party Conference is the press reaction to it. For months, we have all witnessed an almost unprecedented campaign of adulation for the 'Gang of Three' • and joyous declarations about the impending eclipse of the lett. The fury of the press, and their inability to report accurately on the proceedings, amply demonstrates the need for activists to go out and campaign, and to build the Party at local level.
The strength of the Labour Party, as opposed to other socialist parties, is its direct trade union link. The weakness is that too often, this is seen as a formal link and not a sufficiently alive one at local level.
To hold the Party to the decisions taken at Blackpool must mean that we use to the full the opportunities of accountability, but that we also extend our appeal to workplace activists, and persuade them to pressurise their union leaderships to back a genuine electoral college in January
----- pull-quotes -----
and in consequence our pur- chasing power will eventu-
: him If a boxer is successful, rities if he can hurt his opponent
MOBILISE FOR Ken Livingstone