We should side with Iran
Socialist Organiser1980 1980-10-25Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
WE BELIEVE Iran should be supported against lraq. Let us briefly explain why.
First of all the common ground. Both Iran and Iraq are capitalist states (though hardly normal ones) and both states are oppressors not only of the working masses but also of national minorities.
This is clearest in the car of Iran, which is a patchwork of nationalities: there are an estimated 5½ million Kurds, 1 million Baluchis, 1 million Arabs, 750,000 Turcomans and 11 million Azerbaijanis.
But Iraq is not fundamentally different: there the Kurds are again an oppressed national minority, but more, the ruling group is composed of people largely from a single clan among the minority Sunni Muslim population, while the vast majority of Arabs in Iraq are Shi'a Muslims, as in iran.
Thus both states have the same class character and neither will be an opponent of absolutism or a liberator of national minorities.
However, Iraq's invasion of Iran does two things that must be opposed.
Firstly Iraq's invasion of Iran is a denial of the self-determination of lan.
That is true, even though the area under attack and partial occupation) is in a province which has been the victim of national oppression by Iran.
Invasion
The province of Khuzestan (previously called Arabistan) was that part of the Persian Empire (and later of Iran) in which the majority population were Arabs. By means of a policy of 'Pers¡anisation', which included discriminatory employment practices, the Arabs lost their clear majority, though the government does not dispute that most of the population is of Arab origin .
It is not possible to know exactly what the real numbers are - the government claims the Arabs are not a minority in the province except in the rural areas.
No one worthy of the name of Marxist would oppose the right to self-determination of the Khuzestani Arabs. It does seem, however, that they have consistently demanded not secession but cultural and political autonomy. (Of course, this more modest demand might mask a bolder one, but there is some evidence - not least the attitude of these Arabs to Iraq's invasion — that autonomy is what they really want).
Iraq's invasion seems calculated far more as an replaced by the forces Iraq has been supporting since the fall of the late Shah: ex-Prime Minister Bakhtiar, imperialism's great hope, and General Oveissi, the 'butcher of Tehran" , responsible for the Tehran massacres of 1963 and 1979.
Secondly, Iraq's action, if it is successful, will enormously strengthen imperialism. While most of the anti-imperialist rhetoric of the Khomeini regime is dangerous demagogy, and while it would be absurd to see in that regime a stable anti-imperialist force, the fact is that imperialism has been weakened by the tall of the Shah. Iran's refusal to police the area for imperialism and its change of policy within OPEC both constitute a set-back for imperialism. newspapers should offer my views. Dear Comrades, I would like to comment on your otherwise excellent coverage of the Labour Party conference. This relates to the question of the block The article 'Half a Revolution' by John O'Mahony quite rightly points out that the left's reliance on the block vote is a source of great weakness, and berates the unions for their lack of democracy (quite right again). Then however the question is left in the air.
What are we to do about the block vote? It seems to me that it is clearly undemocratic - at the moment even a union like the AUEW which has (at least formally) a relatively democratic structure. Can the block vote be made democratic or should it be scrapped? These are questions to which Socialist Organiser should apply itself.
There is nothing wrong at all with the trade unions dominating Congress, after all if we are serious when we
----- pull-quotes -----
attempt to cripple the Iran- ian regime and have it