Benn should be Labour leader
Socialist Organiser1980 1980-10-25Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
The RFMC's 5principles 1. Annual elections - mandatory when the Party is in opposition, and optional [to be decided by simple maj2. Voting at Conference, with direct voting for every 3. At least two-thirds of the total for CLPs and trade unions, with the PLP vote not to exceed that of CLPs. 4. Recorded voting, details to be available to every affiliated organisation, without which accountability 5. Full provision for casual vacancies, on the lines of the CLPD constitutional amendment.
DENIS HEALEY was thrown off the National ExecuINEVITABLY the barons of the Parliamentary Labour Party have played the only big card they had left after Blackpool.
Callaghan resigned so that the PLP could organise a coup and install a leader of its choice - probably Denis Healey — who would then threaten a split be. tween the PLP and the rest of the Party unless he is endorsed by whatever el ectoral college is decided on at the January conference.
Once elected in November, Healey would have nearly three months to manoeuvre and blackmail the Party and even the union leaders to overthrow the decision in favour of an electoral college or gut it of meaning. These were the sort of tactics used by Gaitskell (and Healey and ority] when in office.
organisation and MP.
impossible. Rodgers) to defeat the 1960 decision for unilateral nuclear disarmament. What a disgusting farce! Mouthing claptrap to the press about democracy, the PLP is claiming that its 268 members count for more than the rest of the labour movement put together. Under the present system they do.
In fact, Tony Benn should be the leader of the Party.
All the indicators, from attendance at his meetings to opinion polls, show that he is overwhelmingly the choice of the members of the Labour Party. It is a meausre of how undemocratic the present system is that he has no chance of barons, elected under the now determines who is Labour leader. Benn is pledged to respect and fight for the policies the labour movement decides to pursue. He has shown a healthy contempt for the PLP by refusing to stand and thus lend credence and legitimacy to the barons' rump election. He is absolutely right not to stand.
Socialist Organiser has many political differences with Tony Benn. As we have argued in SO articles, he will inevitably disappoint those who now expect so much from him -indeed he will lead the labour movement to a catastrophic defeat — if he continues to stand on his inadequate present polities, or if the Party and the labour movement confine themselves to his policies.
Trying just to clip the capitalist tiger's claws and file down its teeth is & sure way, to get your head bitten off — like Salvador Allende did.
But the movement around Benn will grow and develop in the political struggles ahead, aided by the activity and ideas of the revolutionary Marxists in Labour's ranks. Will Benn himself develop? Perhaps. But in any case political clarity will come easier and sooner if Benn is elected leader than if he is blocked by the PLP barons and trade union water' or 'Peron in Spain' - with many workers expecting great things from an untried leader whose weak policies remain untried and thus can keep a hold on the movement. If they stop Benn being leader, that will hinder the development of the movement towards revolutionary polities.
And it is a matter of elementary democracy for socialists to demand that Benn should be leader of the Party. The Right say the Left are only looking for a system to get Benn elected. No so. The point is that under any democratic system he would be virtual. ly certain of election.
But any system so organised that the democratic choice is automatically exeluded because of a privileged franchise is a farce - an insult to the labour movement to the very idea of working class democracy.
We must use their system for now to get the best results out of it so that we can make a radical change Laurie Sparham (IFL)
in it. For now that means that all the pressure that can be concentrated should be brought to bear on the MPs to elect Michael Foot as caretaker leader.
But Socialist Organiser says clearly what many thousands of people in the labour movement think: After January Tony Benn should be leader of the Labour Party. And then we'll see.
JOHN O'MAHONY
----- pull-quotes -----
bureaucrats and plays the role of a 'King over the