Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

What the Lef Must Do

Socialist Organiser no. 28, 25 October 1980 · scan pp. 3–4 · Bruce Robinson · about 1,487 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

tive Committee by the Labour Party membership in 1975. Since then he has not dared to stand for the Now the MPs are threatening to impose Healev on the Party as leader. And both Healey and his main rival, Peter Shore, insist that if the MPs don't like NEC.

the Party as leader. And rival, Peter Shore, insist whatever leader is elected by the Party, then the Party will have to accept the MPs' choice.

What should be done?

• Constituency Labour Parties. (and trade union branches, through their delegates to CLPs) should demand that their MPs support moves to suspend Parliamentary Labour Party standing orders so that Michael Foot, as deputy leader, stands in as leader until the January special conference.

Anything else is an attempt to cheat and frustrate the Party's decision for a more democratic method of election.

Failing suspension of standing orders, MPs should vote for Michael Foot as the leader least likely to pre-empt the January conference.

• The left and the Labour rank and file must be united to swing maximum support behind a clear democratic proposal for an electoral college.

The Rank and File Mobilising Committee will be organising a united campaign around five principles for the electoral college (see inset). Socialist Organiser believes that the best formula to fill out these principles and get a united campaign is an electoral college of 38% trade unions, 2% socialist societies, 30% CLPs, and 30% MPs - with annual election, at conference, and with recorded votes.

By rights there should be no vote for MPs. MPs should be Party members delegated to do a particular job: that's all. But the job now is to get a formula which will extend democracy — and win at the Janroth Healey and his main hat if the MPs don't like uary special conference.

40-30-30 is midway b tween the two proposa narrowly rejected in Blac pool, 3-⅓-⅓ and 50-2 25. It is the basic formu approved by the NEC Blackpool (though the pr cise way the NEC put fo ward 40-30-30 had serio faults).

The Campaign for Lal our Party Democracy h: as put forward a similar forn ula, only with 30% for MI Ps and Prospective Parli mentary Candidates i stead of for MPs. The ai behind the provision fi Or PPCs — to cut down tr le weight given to MPs, an give more representatic to CLPs in Tory seats -one we sympathise witl But here and now the PP( clause will probably ju st give right-wingers a chan‹ ce to quibble and rally opinic against reform.

The Labour Co-ordin: ting Committee wants 4 ⅓-⅓. Militant wants 40-3 -30 without PPCs (thoug unfortunately in their ed torial they identify this wit the NEC's Blackpool fo mula and don't mentio annual elections and re corded vote).

All these groups shoul be urged to unite behin one agreed formula.

• In any case, resolutior should go in now in trad union branches calling o the unions to vote for an proposal satisfying • th RFMC's five principle:

• MPs wno arroganti try to place themselves at ove the Party should b firmly reminded by the CLPs that mandatory if selection is coming up. they don't want to carry ol the decisions of the Labor Party, they tan go else

Scan page 4

BRUCE ROBINSON reviews 'The IRA' , a 'MURDERERS', 'terrorists', and 'fanatics', are some of the more polite descriptions of the IRA in the British press.

The government also does all it can to avoid admitting that the IRA has political ideas and objectives: it criminalises the Republican prisoners; it refuses even to discuss negotiations on political solutions with the Republ icans; it talks only of a military solution - a crushing of the IRA and its supporters among the Catholics in the North.

This is sometimes even echoed by socialists who talk of the Provisionals' supposed 'anti-Protestant sectarianism" "individual terror"reactionary ideas" as an exuse for not supporting them against the British state.

Tim Pat Coogan is not sympathetic to the IRA.

But his book provides tacts to counter the myths.

For example, he writes of the Provisionals and their campaign over the last ten years: "When thinking of the IRA operatives one should not visualise hardened neo-psychopaths of icecold nerve. There are a few, but they are a minority.

This may sometimes seem very hard to accept... but the IRA make a firm and fixed distinction between attacks on UDR and RUC personnel and sectarian assassination.

1916 "It is official IRA policy as a chance to win Irish independence while Britain was busy fighting Germany. The 1916 Easter Rising, though defeated, marked the start of a five year war, in which the IRA was the organised militia of the Irish population, which had overwhelmingly voted for candidates committed to Irish independence in the 1918 General Election.

The IRA fought a guerilla campaign which was eventually successful, despite acts like the destruction of the city of Cork by the Black and Tans.

Treaty But there were important differences on the antiBritish side, which came to a head when the British offered a compromise peace to a war-weary population.

The dispute was not between socialists and their opponents - most of the would-be socialists, including the newly founded Irish Labour Party, accepted that "Labour must wait" until the national struggle was over. It was about whether the British terms, which included an oath of allegiance to the British king, partition of the country and British control of certain parts of Ireland, should be accepted.

The result was a civil war in which the Republicans, who urged rejection of anything short of full independence, were seriously defeated by the pro-Treaty ' Free Staters' Yet this defeat did not mean the end of the IRA.

The 1921 Treaty had not resolved the issues over history by Tim Pat Coogan either parliamentary 'constitutional' politics, or militan socialist politics. The parliamentary option was anathema to traditional Republicans, who favoured abstention from all Parliaments until a 32 County Republic existed. (This was one element in the split between the Officials and Provisionals in 1969).

The first "constitutional' movement was founded in 1926 when de Valera, the Republicans' main leader in the Civil War, split to launch Fianna Fail, which has been the governing party in the South for most of the time since the early '30s. Helped to power by the IRA in 1932, it quickly turned on them and began interning Republicans in the mid '30s.. Despite its occasional use of republican rhetoric, Fianna Fail is nothing but an open capitalist party Strikes The other response to the failure of purely military politics was to move towards the left. In the early '30s, in the midst of the depression, one.section of the Republican leadership began political campaigning on a socialist basis, and founded two organisations to do this:

Saor Eire and, later, the Republican Congress.

Despite resistance from IRA traditionalists, Republicelectoral politics, and the North on civil rights.

Split The issue of the Border and military activity very firmly took second place. As a result, when the Civil Rights movement threatened the Northern regime and the B Specials tried to unleash a pogrom in Belfast and Derry, the IRA was totally unprepared. The small number of guns they had were on loan to the Free Wales Army!

Coogan describes the situation: ' ... had the handful of IRA men not been present, Orange mobs, led by B Specials, would have burned the Falls Road to the ground, and, with it, every Catholic tamily which did not flee. But this circumstance, much as it may have rebounded to the credit of the individuals concerned, rebounded very badly indeed on the IRA's public image."

The Provisional IRA split shortly afterwards from the Officials. Though their political ideas at the time seemed to the right of the Officials and marked a return to a more traditional Republicanism, the Provisionals grew because they were willing and able to undertake the defence of the Catholics in the North.

Their function as defenders of the Catholic community • against pogroms, the RUC and B Specials, has areas of the cities and the poorer rural areas"

The IRA's role as a defender of the Catholic community goes back to the war 1918-21, when the RUC and Protestant sectarians hoped to drive as many Catholics as possible out of their jobs and homes in Belfast to reinforce the Protestant character of the North East.

The IRA's roots in the Catholic community do not mean that Republicans see Ulster Defence Association, searching for an agreed political solution.

All these attempts at unity have been short-lived, often because the Unionist rulers in the North, or more recently, the British, have consciously tried to break them up. A recent example is the assassination (probably by the UVF) of Protestant councillor John Turnly, a member of the middle class nationalist Irish In-

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 28

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →