Labour Leader Election the Crucial Issues
Socialist Organiser1980 1980-10-25Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
VLADIMIR DERER, secretary of the Can paign for Labour Party Democracy, talked to Socialist Organiser.
There are three major principles as CLPD see it.
* One is that the range in which the proportions in which the various sections of the Party are to be represented in the college should be defined between 50% for trade unions, 25% for CLPs and 25% for the PLP, at one extreme, and the ⅓, ⅓, 3, postion on the other.
* The second important principle is that the election for the leader should be done on an annual basis. Conference should have the option every year to elect or re-elect that existing leader of the Party.
* The next important principle is that all votes should be recorded. This of course is solely for MPs. By and large the votes of the CLPs and the trade unions are already known, as the CLPs mandate their delegates and the unions hold their meetings on how they will vote prior to conference.
In itself, recording votes would not be an innovation, but it would formalise the present position, so as there could not be any mistakes as to how the various delegates voted. It would be an innovation for MPs, who at present vote in secret and are not mandated.
We consider this to be absolutely vital if accountability is to mean anything at all in relation to the important choice of who is to be leader of the Party.
Apart from these three principles, there is the question of the Prospective Parliamentary Candidates. CLPD has always included them in our formula for the electoral college, The exclusion of the PPCs is not warranted on principled grounds. A large proportion of the PPCs are potential MPs and could be asked to be treated as Parliamentarians.
other digging, lations are likely to come up? What are the dangers?
VD: At this stage it is likely that the proportions 40:30:30. ⅓;⅓;⅓ and possibly 50:25:25 will come up again and will command wide support among those submitting constitutional amendments. What we must ensure is that the variants are presented in a setting which will guarantee that the other two principles, annual election and recorded voting, are also included in these proposals.
For this reason the Mobilising Committee, quite rightly, agreed that it would support any proportions: within the range I've mentioned - provided the other important principles were included in the amendment.
The dangers are only too obvious when we look back at the Blackpool conference. For instance, it would be possible for amendments to concentrate simply on the question of the proportions — ⅓, ⅓, ⅓ is very popular. — and to ignore the important issues of annual election and the recorded vote.
This would make for a Wels very weakened version of the college, which in the end might not make a lot of difference to the present system.
There are other dangers. Opponents of the democratic reforms could try to push through something which might be even worse than what we've got at present.
It is therefore very important that the principles CLPD supports, along with the Mobilising Committee become widely known so that CLP's and affiliated organisations are sufficiently well-versed and informed of the dangers that the opponents of reform are likely to come up with.
•N What needs to be done between now and January 24th?' VD: We need to win massive support for the amendments put forward by CLPD and the other affiliated organisations in the Mobilising Committee from the CLPs and affiliated organisations. Delegates with minority positions are generally prevailed upon to withdraw their resolutions, so we need a large body of CLPs and affiliated organisations behind few strong proposals.
What about the present leadership machinations!
VD: The PLP attempts to elect a new leader betore the January conference are clearly in defiance of the conference decision. They are obviously trying to install a new leader who will be difficult to get rid of after January. The saying goes 'Possession is 9 points of the law' Our first task must be to prevent this election.
Michael Foot, as Deputy Leader, should stand in until the January conference has met and decided how to elect the new Leader.
1o achieve this we have to get the PLP to suspend their standing orders. They can do this without difficulty because there are precedents. These are conditions that warrant it. It is important that we have a caretaker leader who would abide by the decisions of conference and ara nm-sem, stand only temporarily.
If Foot will not stand and there is no other candidate who would act as caretaker, then we should advocate a boycott of the election. The PLP are trying to make a pre-emptive strike to defend their privileges and are acting against the decisions of conference. Such an election must be discredited.
If such an election goes ahead, I think we must stop Healey at all costs. If he won, there would be a major crisis in the Party. There would be a direct conflict between the PLP and conference which could eventually result in a complete split.
What about the letter signed by 62 MPs saying that the PLP should elect its own leader whatever the Party wants?
VD: This is primarily a matter for the constituencies. MPs have to be reminded that re-selection will be coming up shortly. They should be asked by an emergency meeting of the Constituency to withdraw their names and vote for the suspension of standing orders so that a caretaker leader can be installed.