Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[fell dramatically. Now the school meal service is…]

Socialist Organiser no. 29, 8 November 1980 · scan pp. 2–3 · about 1,417 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 2

fell dramatically. Now the school meal service is deep in the red and the Council is trying to think of ways of rescuing it.

But to rescue it, they feel, they've got to spend money on a campaign to encourage kids to want school meals. The only suggestion so far - one that has caused some uproar — is to install space invader machines in the canteens.

It is not clear whether the idea was to entice the kids into the eating area and force-feed them on the spot or simply to use the space invader machines as a source of income.

My suggestion would be to have fruit machines where you could win real fruit and then you could get rid of the school meals service altogether. No? Just an idea.

Anvone that can tell Somerset Countr Council how :: saese more: should me :: "that don't count are: cancelling debt charges, increasing direct works instead of paying through the nose to private firms, abolishing the post of mayor in all the towns, or anything that smacks of socialism. And you're not allowed to mention fighting the Tory government, either.

Comrades Davies and Foster admit that neither Iran nor Iraq is imperialist, and that neither is a mere tool of imperialism. They say neither is progressive as against the other; that both states have the same class character; and that the working class rules in neither. Instead of concluding that we should not take sides, they bring in 'special' arguments to justify a call that SO should wave the Iranian flag.

They say that the invasion of Iran is a denial of 'the self-determination of Iran' • Any invasion violates 'the integrity of the invaded state. Without invasion, opposing armies would never come to grips, and wars would be impossible except at sea or through bombardment!

Support for Iran because Iraq now holds some of its territory is also in principle a commitment to support Irao if the Iranians enter ==. erntory - as the! =2!

SIde :. M...change sides with ine turements of the armies on the borders?

Marxists take sides, if they do, for reasons other than the occupation of territory though that may be a consideration).

The comrades' own statement implies that we should defend the integrity of the ADDIS I ABABA Iranian state. Bur isnt it simply ridiculous to talk of "self-determination for Iran' when more than half of the population belong to minorities who are oppressed and persecuted by the Persians?

We used to talk of Iran as a sub-imperialism before Khomeini - not only because it was a 'sub-contractor' of US imperialism but because of its level of economic development and role in the area, and because of the oppressed national minorities within iran. The Islamic Revolution' altered only its subcontractor relation with imperialism.

Perhaps the minorities want only autonomy within Iran, not separation. But until they can say what they want without being persecuted or having to choose between the butchering (and anti-Shi'ite) Iraqi regime and Iran, then for myself T'1 keep quiet about Iranian selfdetermination' - except against NATO for the USSR -argument - it is not the rivalry of the two states over border territory or over the oil-rich Khuzestan area of Iran, inhabited by a persecuted Arab minority, which is being fought over. The real purpose of the invasion "seems' to be to replace the Iranian regime with former Shah-ites now in exile in Iraq. It is a political intervention to bring down Khomeini.

The Iraqi regime. does want to finish off Khomeini because it fears an explosion of Iraq's oppressed Shi'ite majority. Khomeini calls for the overthrow of the Iraqi regime and its replacement by & Shi'ite theocracy such as Iran's. Should we then sift through the records to see who 'intervened' first, Khomeini or Hussein, and take sides accordingly, against the 'aggressor'? That would be as absurd as siding against whoever fired the first short.

The idea of 'political interference' is here in fact a refinement of the idea that Iraq acts as proxy for the USA - an interpretation popular with some leftist commentators at the outbreak of the war. Now we have the idea of an 'objective political proxy' as obviously faise - abandoned, that is, by all but the perennial fools of the Fantasists International. whose most stable delusion is that they are Lton Trotsky's 'Fourth International. They think there is a profoundly port led by a cadre of a quarter of a million mullahs organised hierarchically: and, given the character of the narrow military despotism in Iraq, it is still quite likely that the war will result in its overthrow. (In discussions on the Socialist Organiser staff, the majority argued this at the beginning of war, when it was less obvious).

The wishes and hopes of the Iraqi rulers for a military overthrow of Khomeini, based on calculations stamped and limited by military bureaucratic thinking, are given far too much weight in Davies' and Foster's assessment. Events have long since proved it to be talse; instead of junking it, they refine it and mystity it.

They do not fully bring out, and are obviously reluctant to face, the implications of what they say - which is a pity. According to their own mental thing under threat, ana they say that it the obiectives of Iraq, defined by them as the overthrow of that regime, succeed, then there. will be an 'enormous' strengthening of imperialism. So they must then conclude not only that we should support the integrity of the oppressive Iranian state, but the regime too (until the workers can replace it, perhaps?)

The analogy with the Spanish Civil War merely begs the question: There was a clear and good class reason to But we would not, even while opposing a military coup with guns, support the regime or the mullahs. That's the analogy with Spain. What the reference to Spain really shows is how far from Trotsky are Foster and Davies, who support Iran to 'protect' the regime - they don't 'support' it - from a threat that has not actually appeared!

It is true that Iraq aspires to be the strong state in the area, but we should not therefore support the recent strong state - and in terms of real strength, probably a future one too. The great mass movement that toppled the Shah has been led into a blind alley by the Muslim reactionaries. Their anti-imperialism is not only demagogic, as Davies and Foster say, it very often has as its content a reactionary rejection of much of the modern world. Activities such as the hostage seizure serve the regime as diversions to deflect the masses.

They have not in any fundamental, stable or lasting sense broken with capitalism or imperialism. Within Iran we must support the workers against the regime. Short of an imperialist attack, we have no reason to support the Iranian state.

O'MAHONY

Scan page 3

ho change sheetagalast Header DENIS Healey is the labour movement's leading 'man of power', a former associate of the CIA and of the British military establishment, of the IMF and NATO, an ex-Minister of Defence and ex Chancellor of the Exchequer, by JOHN O'MAHONY A grubbing, visionless creature, he stands for a labour movement that never aspires to socialism, which continues to commit itselt, even now, to a voluntary confinement within least to smash the Stalinists (and the real left) within them. For this work the CIA adopted - as far as was possible for it -the techniques of the degenerate Comintern.

Stalin's Comintern had developed sinister methods of manipulating the labour movements it did not directly control to serve the been).

Having cut his second political teeth like that, Healey became an MP in 1952, then worked - together with Hugh Gaitskell, William Rodgers, and others - with limited success to purge the British labour movement of socialism. ed — but squeezed the working class and the so cial services instead.

He spearheaded the drive to cut real wages. He was the linkman with the IMF, and its bailiff in the Cabinet, pushing for Labour's savage 1976 cuts.

He presided over policies that doubled unemployment to 1½ million. Together with Callaghan, he rammed through the £6 limit in 1975 and the attempted 5% limit in 1978-9.

He could - but he won't — lay just claim to being the political pioneer in Britain of the grisly Tory

----- pull-quotes -----

False theory clear be a the red

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 29

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →