Missing the Int
Socialist Organiser1980 1980-11-22Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
Challenge
The Campaign for Labour Party Democracy favoured Foot as leader, against Healey. VLADIMIR DERER, secretary of the CLPD, explains why he believes left-wing critics of voting for Foot were In Socialist Organiser no.27 John Bloxam argued that the Labour Left is wrong to push for withdrawal from the EEC. GRAHAM NORWOOD takes SOCIALIST Challenge is critical of the position adopted by the Rank and File Mobilising Committee, the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy, and the Labour Left in general on the issues arising out of the Parliamentary Labour Party leadership elections.
Its editorial of 6th November claims that the Labour Left has "got itself into a hopeless tactical tangle"
"Having just a couple of weeks ago denounced the whole election as a fraud"
Socialist Challenge goes on, "the left has now forgotten its own starting point. By launching an all-out campaign for Foot it is lending legitimacy to the whole undemocratic charade. The illegitimacy of the MPs-only election is being lost in the hustle to get Foot elected".
The question of what is one's starting point is indeed important. For the Labour Left, or at any rate up the debate.
THE EUROPEAN Economic Community - through the individual nations within it and through the bureaucratic supranational state system it imposes over those nations - enshrines the ethics and workings of capitalism.
So long as that remains the case, it is Labour' s responsibility as a party committed to the scrapping of capitalism, to withdraw from the EEC.
Face Labour must similarly face up to other forms of capitalism, as expressed through private ownership of land and of industry; as expressed through wage controls and the cuts public expenditure; and as expressed in growing state powers for the police and services, and restrictions on civil life through the Prevention of Terrorism Act and new infringements on the right to strike.
But the EEC lines up with those capitalist forms and therefore must be considered as a challenge for Labour: to ignore it is to try to defeat capitalism elsewhere, whilst letting it escape through the loopholes of the Common Market.
For a number of reasons we must withdraw from the Market, and offer a socialist alternative:
1. It aids capitalism within the EEC, by encouraging artificial marketing and agricultural conditions to the benefit of capitalists in the member nations.
2. It aids global capitalism, by enhancing the privileged industrial positions of the European states, to the detriment of ever more its most consistent protagonists, the starting point is the recognition that, at this stage, the main arena in which the struggle for socialism is being fought out is the existing political structures. This means above all the Labour Party.
Those socialists who place themselves outside wrong.
the Labour Party have in fact abandoned political struggle and opted for the status quo, which accommodates them in a 'radical' ghetto.
Real struggle for socialism must give a high priority to the practical struggle against those elements in the Labour leadership which are ideologically opposed to the Party's nominal aims. This implies not just ideological against reliant Third World nations, whose relative poverty increases in comparison to overall EEC growth.
3. The Common Market serves to institutionalise capitalist power blocks in two ways:
(i) It diminishes the rights of socialists to initiate new ideas within one or more member countries. The immensity of the EEC requires similarly immense capitalist bureaucracy, which will inevitably see socialist innovation (i.e. cooperatives; municipalisation of local finance; nationalisation, between two or three states, of multinational capital) as nothing more than an irregularity to the normal large-scale capitalism. Such innovations will thuse be dismissed.
(ii) It legitimises the power block of NATO, by forming a potentially-cohesive economic grouping wedded to Americandominated capitalism: the perfect supranational economy to serve a future nuclear war.
For these reasons, we must rid ourselves of the EEC. For, make n criticism but political opposition, i.e. a struggle for their removal from politically important positions.
Those, on the other hand, whose 'political' activity is exclusively restricted to ideological exposure (basically propaganda group activities) nannin antinitioc) will be satisfied with 'winning the argument, forgetful of the fact that this, by itself, is politically of very little consequence.
The decision of the PLP to go ahead with the election of the Party Leader was primarily an attempt by Labour's right wing parliamentary oligarchy to secure the leadership for their own nominee. The argument about legitimacy was in this context inevitably of secondary importance: withdrawal mainly because The main purpose behind the demand that the PLP suspend its Standing Orders was to prevent the election of its right wing nominee. To allow one's tactic to be circumscribed purely by considerations of legitimacy is to act as if the issue is being fought out in a court of law rather than in the political arena.
In any case the PLP's decision was only politically illegitimate: it was taken in defiance of a clearly expressed wish of conference. Technically it was legitimate: the PLP did no more than comply with its Standing Orders.
This, incidentally, was one of the reasons why the argument about legitimacy failed to generate from the rank and file sufficient pressure to stop the PLP from going through with its pre-emptive strike which, as it turned out, backfired. For the Left to have continued to base its campaign on 'legitimacy' once the vote on the Standing Orders was lost, would have restricted it to calling for a boycott.
This may have pleased Socialist Challenge, but it would have merely helped to install Denis Healey. Even in the unlikely event of all the 66 MPs (who voted in favour of the suspension of Standing Orders) abstaining, this would not have made it 'much easier to argue the irrelevance of the outcome" , as Socialist Challenge suggests.
A 75% poll divided 2 to 1 in favour of Healey would have been a triumph for the parliamentary right wing.
Rank and file members of the Labour Party realised this only too well and, unlike the master strategists of Socialist Challenge, intensified their efforts to frustrate the right wing coup by mounting further pressure on MPs to vote for the only candidate who dis not push himself and at the same time stood the bes chance of stopping Healey than the support of perhaps 3 of the CLPs, ⅓ of the TUs, and ⅓ of the PLP (43.3% of the electoral college). If conference voted in its present form, Benn would be heavily defeated.
But the potential harm produced by Socialist Challenge's ill-informed 'optimism' is that it spreads a complacency that detracts from the urgency of preparing the ground for an eventual victory of a Leftwing candidate for leadership. A tolerant Party regime under Foot will be more conducive to such preparatory activity than Ivan the authoritarian Denis Healey.
Here once again Socialist Challenge grossly underestimates the extent of support : within the Party for the Labour Left and for the democratic reforms: it fails to see the : 'merit in avoiding a clash' between the PLP and the constituencies. It advises that the MPs' "challenge to Labour Party democracy needs to be taken on, full frontal"
Labour's parliamentary oligarchs would like nothing better than thạt the Left should be drawn into a precipitate and premature trial of strength. They know that in such a confrontation they could rely on the support of the unions as well as of the bulk of the passive membership. The latter's first consideration is their loyalty to the Party and concern for Party unity.
The PLP's obvious preference for Healey has enabled the Labour Left to draw on the vast reservoir in the centre by demonstrating that it was the Right which was anxious to precipitate new conflicts. So long as the composition of the Labour Party remains what it is now, the Lett cannot win without the support of the centre. This may mean that apart from pressing for such socialist changes as are already broadly acceptable, it has also, from time to time, to promote 'compromise candidates in opposition to right wing nominees.
Even Socialist Challenge must admit that it was the adoption of this tactic which led to the parliamentary right being hopelessly out-manoeuvred.
Labour leadership: no support for Foot
Fi Party will go stood will
Ca 36522 NEG CeR
Having tried to pre-empt the January conference decision by installing their nominee, the right have now to settle for someone whom they could have had without fuss in the first place.
While it would be quite inappropriate to join the Tory press in proclaiming the election of Foot as an outright victory for the Left, it can hardly be denied that it was a defeat for the right.
The trouble with the 'principled' critics of the Labour Left — and their mouthpieces in Socialist Challenge — is that having failed to become politically influential outside the Labour Party, they now accept (or some of them at least) the need to work within the Labour Party framework. Unfortunately this acceptance is only half-hearted. They still hark back after the dream-world (inhabited by the CP, SWP and WRP) in which the Far Left is engaged in an effective political competition with the Labour Party. Their continued preference for extra-parliamentary and extra-Labour Party activity as well as tactics appropriate to such an orientation, is a clear indication of this.
In the fantasy world in which the Far Left is a credible alternative to Labourism, it would, of course, be quite appropriate to see the difference between Foot and Healey, and the forces they represent, as at best a marginal one. In the real world however, the Far Left is politically irrelevant. Their pathetic pretensions serve no other purpose than to divert potentially revolutionary forces into activities which, from the point of view of the bourgeois status quo, are perfectly safe.
Acceptance of work within the Labour Party framework involves the recognition not just of the limitations imposed by this framework, but also acceptance of the need to carry on such struggies as are possible within it. Failure to use all the opportunities that the Labour Party framework offers, is tantamount to a failure to engage in the political class struggle.
----- pull-quotes -----
The case against the Common Mar