Saunders becomes precedent
Socialist Organiser1980 1980-11-22Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
John Saunders, working as a handyman at a Scottish residential schools camp, was sacked in 1979 because and only because he was gay. The Employment Appeals Tribunal said that reasonable employers' couldn't be expected to know about 'modern scientific opinion' that ays are no more es or ess with workers, or anyone else..
The judgement was used as precedent in June 1980 when a Coal Board worker, who was know to be epileptic by his employers, WAS deemed to have been fairly sacked after an unexpected critical attack. His doctors informed the Tribunal that new medication could keep things in hand, but the Tribunal said 'reasonable employers' couldn't be expected to know about 'modern scientific opinion' , upheld the sacking as fair, and quoted Saunders as precedent.
I have checked the Tribunal's membership, and Lord Macdonald President Tribunals in Scotland] and James Jack [former General Secretary of the STUC sat on both of these fateful 'courts'. It is a disgrace that a former Labour Movement leader and spokesperson should side with the State to crush workers' livelihoods by pandering to the prejudices of employers, including the Nationalised Industry employers.
The Saunders Case is being appealed to the Court of Session and will come up most likely in February 1981. Whatever the result we must demand fundamental changes to the Employment Protection Act because it no longer provides the semblance of protection to the workers it is supposed to protect.
The Labour Movement in Lothian is worried. Edinburgh Trades Council and North Edinburgh CLP have sponsored a Half-Day Conference on 'Gay Rights at work. The Valuers Depart-