Our answer to the FFC
Socialist Organiser1980 1980-12-06Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
GRAHAM Norwood, (SO
30) argues that the EEC "enshrines the ethics and workings of capitalism" and "So long as that remains the case, it is Labour' s responsibility as i party committed to the scrapping of capitalism. 10 withdraw from the EEC"
But to my mind he provides no reasonable argument as to how withdrawal from a capitalist EEC to an equally capitalist Britain moves the scrapping of capitalism forward one iota.
The reasons Comrade Norwood gives for opposing the Common Market are in fact arguments against capitalism in general rather than the EEC in particular. The "artificial marketing and agricultural conditions to the benefit of capitalists" merely reflect the natural laws of capitalist development in the epoch of large scale monopoly capitalism.
From Comrade Norwood's second point one would think that Britain played no part whatsoever in the imperialist division of the world before it joined the EEC, and that it would immediately cease to do so
it it were to withdraw.
The EEC was the inevitable result of the laws of capitalist development. It was necessary in the face of the strength of American capitalism for European capital to compete ettectively. Marxists do not oppose such developments for the sake of it. On the contrary, we see in them the development of the inherent contradictions in capitalism which will lead its replacement by socialism.
Seek
We seck to strengthen the revolutionary elements that contradiction through our intervention. We see in moves (however feeble) towards the removal of outdated national boundaries the possibility of removing narrow nationalistic prejudices. We see in the development of multinational enterprises through the EEC the possibility of multinational workers organisation, and a greater cross fertilisation and therefore richer content of socialist ideas and tactics.
Wit! rawal from : the ERC would weaken the possibility of such developments without doing anything to hamper the links between British and European capital which existed before Britain joined the EEC and which would continue to exist were Britain to withdraw.
Trotsky. writing in 1923. noted that 'the driving motor force to war was this, that the capitalist forces of production had oulgrown the framework of European national states.
'Europe cannot develop economically within the state and customs frontiers imposed at Versailles.
Europe is compelled either to remove these frontiers, or to face the threat of complete economic decay.
Our answer to the im.
passe facing European Writeback, This week we have letters on the Common Market and the Labour leadership. Do you agree? Let us know what you think: WRITE BACK to 5 Stamford Hill, London N16.
It this process is to be avoided, the question of fielding a left opponent to Foot in any election resulting trom next year's special conference is absolutely vital.
Clearly Tony Benn with his widespread support and his organised following is the most appropriate candidate to stand. SO has never pretended to believe that Benn will necessarily lead a real change in British society. Nevertheless we must take the lead in demanding Benn stands.
KEVIN FEINTUCK (Edgehill CLP)
don't work capitalism should not be withdrawal from the EEC, but for the Socialist United States of Europe.
The EEC represents no more of a hindrance to the development of socialism in Britain or Europe with Britian inside it than it would if Britain were outside it. Only if one believes that: socialism in Britain will be brought about by Act of Parliament could it be seen to be.
Though Comrade Norwood dissociates himself from the Parliamentary road, the logic of his argument is to accept the narrow nationalistic and reformist prejudices which underlie such a perspective.
When a socialist revolution occurs in Britain then obviously we will not allow ourselves to be dictated to by the EEC - but the Treaty of Rome will be the least of our problems!
To argue that Britain outside the EEC is in some way a progressive alternative to Britain inside the EEC is to sow reformist illusions.
Arthur Bough Correction The article on housing in Socialist Organiser no.30 credited to Dana Minns should have been jointly credited to Diana Minns and Mary Corbishley. Our apologies. MEETINGS SHEFFIELD Rank and File Mobilising Committee meeting on democracy in the Trade Unions. 7.30pm, Monday Ist December, Station Hotel, The Wicker.
¿rade unionist on *ihe Labour Party and the fight LEICESTER Women's Fightback day school.
Saturday 13 December, 10am to 4.30pm, at Belgrave Neighbourhood Centre, Ruthley_St, off Belgrave Rd. Discussion on unemployed struggles, women organising in the labour movement, cuts, new technology, Employment Act, housing.
LAMBETH Labour Left meeting: •Stop Council House Sales' • Thursday 11 December, 7.30pm, Lambeth Town Hall.
BIRMINGHAM Women's Fightback fund-raising social. Friday 19 December, 8pm, Golden Eagle, Hill St. Band ('The Set'), disco, late bar. Tickets £1 in advance from Marian Mound (194 Dawlish Rd, Birmingham 29: 021 471 1964).
GLASGOW hunger strike action committee demonstration: Victory to the hunger strikers, political status now! Saturday 20 December; assemble 10am, Craigendmuir St, Blackhill. BRISTOL Socialist Organiser group: discussion on the Alternative Economic Strategy. 8pm, Wednesday 10 December, 29 Muller Ave, Horfield, Bristol.
BOOKS ARE WEAPONS! KICK OFF 1981 WITH A FIRST OF MAY BOOK Voucher, the perfect seasonal gift from Edinburgh's comprehensive left/radical bookshop. 13 Candlemaker Row. Open 10-6 Mon-Sat. 031-225 . 2612. Browsers welcome.