Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Labour/ireland Group Plans Conference

Socialist Organiser no. 31, 6 December 1980 · scan pp. 3–4 · about 1,549 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

McFeeley ON December 13th the Labour Committee on Ireland is holding a special meeting to discuss its submission to the National Executive Committee working party on Ireland. All active LCI members should attend this meeting to ensure that the submission is based on the LCI policies of troops out now and political status, and to launch an effective tight to win support tor these policies in the labour movement.

The British labour movement has, over the years, been passive and ignorant on the situation in Ireland, while its leaders have collaborated with the Unionists. the police and the military in their crimes against the Irish people.

On 29th March this year, abour 150 people from 44 CLPs met in London to change that situation. They set up the Let with the following statement of aims:

La break with bipartisanship:

• an end to the Unionist veto: • greater understanding of the views of Irish labour:

• a policy and commitment to the immediate and unconditional withdrawal of all British military and economic involvement in ireland;

• opposition to the policy of criminalisation of Irish political prisoners and support for their campaign for political status:

opposition to repressive legislation in Britain, such as the PTA The meeting decided to circulate a model resolution for Labour Party conference and to organise to see that it was discussed. Although this motion was defeated at conference, it did win support from a large section of the constitueney delegates.

Decisions, were also taken to support Charter 80 and to give it a high profile in the committee' propaganda material: to attempt to set up a labour movement conference on Ireland: and to hack troops out now and political status.

The implementation of these decisions has been uneven. This is partly due to inactivity of the rank and file, and partly the result of confusion and/or backsliding by officers.

The December 13th meeting must change this situation.

The LCI should also take advantage of the opportunity presented by national meeting to launch a campaign on the H-block and Armagh hunger strikes.

There is a vital job for the LI to do in broadening support for the Irish struggle beyond -mall groups of the

Scan page 4

WITH HIS election three weeks ago as Parliamentary Labour Party leader [which will almost certainly be confirmed under the Electoral College system to be danided at the Suecial Conference in January], it was in fact for the second time UCLIULU himself in the leadership of the Labour Party.

The last time had been just 20 years earlier, in October 1960.

Nobody then formally elected Foot as leader. It was to be a couple of months before he returned to the House of Commons after winning the Ebbw Vale by-election caused by the death of Aneurin Bevan. And his standing with the PLP then was expressed clearly enough when he had the whip withdrawn within four months of getting back into Parliament.

Least But Foot was, nevertheless, the outstanding leader - or at least, the outstanding orator and journalist — of the Tribune Left and of the Labour and trade union supporters of British unilateral nuclear disarmament when they won the Labour Party for unilateralism in October 1960. Against the bitter opposition of the Leader of the PLP. Hugh Gaitskell, who threatened to fight, fight and fight again' to regain the party, Labour Party conference decided that it wanted the next Labour Government to scrap nuclear weapons, unilaterally.

Immediately after the decision, the Labour Party was faced by an open revolt against its authority by the PLP. Gaitskell didn't hesitate about threatening to split the Party or about LAURIE SPARHAM (IFL)

pitting the PLP against the Party in the country.

He had told Conference in advance that the PLP would not be unilateralist, whatever Conference decided - the MPs could not, LAURIE he said, overnight become the 'unilateralists', 'pacifists', and 'fellow-travellers' that other people were'. Nor could Conference control or elect the Party Leader: he told Conference that the election of the Leader was not its business, but the business of the PLP alone. that Michael Foot found this stage was, remember, a man of 47 involved in a confliet in which — he believed 'passionately' - nothing less than the future of the human race was at stake.

The first thing Michae! Foot did was to prostrate himself publicly before the principle that the MPs had a sacred right to ignore Conference. In Tribune he rushed to concede that the MPs had a right to vote in Parliament according to their consciences. That too was something he believed in. "passionately"

The Scarborough Conference had, in fact, rejected a motion from Nottingham Central CLP that would have scotched such PLP pretensions. But now the revolt of the PLP could have been used as dramatic illustration in a campaign to convince the movement of the need to bring the MPs firmly under its control.

In fact the Executive of Victory for Socialism. Tribune's then rank and file organisation, voted down a proposal from Hugh Jenkins that they should answer the Gaitskellites with a reselection campaign to deprive rebellious MPs of the Party's endorsement.

In a sense that was to concede the whole game at the beginning, by giving up the sharpest weapon the Party had for dealing with the Left was willing to go the whole hog in a fight to mobilise the labour movement against the arrogant MPs - which it was not.

So Tribune and Foot kicked unilateralism upstairs in their list of priorities, into the category of good ideas and things they believed in "passionately" and concentrated instead on trying to find common ground on defence with Gaitskell. by adopting. as their immediare pructical policies what they thought might be acceptable-to a reasonable right wing MP looking for a compromise with the official Party.

Bit They sought a compromise which contained a bit of the substance and spirit. and a lot of the rhetoric of unilateralism, and might therefore attract the disarmers, while not being anything like unilateral nuclear disarmament. This.

they hoped, would - by gutting the Left - also conciliate the reasonable Right.

They thought they had found their issue in the US Polaris missile base.

Bi happy coincidence the Tory Government's decision to establish this base at Holy Loch, in the West of Scotland. came through just then. This. saki Tribune and Michael Foor.

custodians and champions of the Party's decision for unilateralism. is an issue that can unite us all.

They were wrong about this. The only unity the that they would not be the first to unleash nuclear weapons.

Should Prime Minister Macmillan and President " F Kennedy be "pressed"

"declare" that they would never use nuclear weapons first. asked Michael Foot in Tribune. That question, he wrote. "gues to the heart of the recent controversies about defence in the Labour Party'! (Tribune, 3 March 1961).

In this way, instead of fighting to consolidate the Party's official policy, the Left abandoned more and more ground. The idea that serious socialist politics mean deciding what is necessary and then fighting to carve it out of the existing reality - that was not their. idea. Compromise even about an issue involving the very fate of humanity. an attempt to averageout a common line with the Right on an agreed anti-Tory government rhetoric behind which all could, for the moment, unite, despite having antagonistic views - that was: the furthest But Gaitskell would have none of them. The Right had firmer convictions — or a firm commitment to the interests of the ruling class. anyway. They certainly had a better idea of what serious politics is: they sought a clear victory for their own position.

Gaitskell referred to the compromise-seekers with public contempt as men of infirm principle, as well he might. When Foot and four others voted against the Air Estimates of the Tory Gorernment. Gaitskell expelled them from the PLP.

The public spectacle of the unilateralists abandoning unilateralism as practical politics in vain search for a compromise, while the Gaitskéllites spurned them, helped the Right gain ground. They won the day at the Blackpool 1961 Conterence by 4,526,000 to 1,756.000.

Many things were untavourable to a stable victory for the unilateralist cause in 1960 - the majority was small, for example, politically unclear, and overdependent on block votes. bigots in the House of Commons, Michael Foot will apply the sorts of technique and advice he and Tribune offered to Gaitskell in 1960. If he urged them on Gaitskell, for use to deflect politics he "passionately" supported, Foot will certainly now use them against policies. like reselection, to which he is opposed.

Listen to his line now that Labour is unilateralist again, though as a member of the inner Cabinet Foot must bear part of the political responsibility for Callaghan's secret fund for updating Polaris. 'What I want to do now is to prevent the campaign on the arms race, which we urgently need, from being distorted by an argument between the multilateralists and the unilateralists. That may be a difficult thing to do, but then life itself is difficult (Guardian, 13 November 1980).

Who can gain from such techniques? As always, those who benefit from the status quo, who would benefit if the Left offensive

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 31

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →