Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Will if lead the fightback?

Socialist Organiser no. 31, 6 December 1980 · scan pp. 8–9 · about 1,995 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

Ted Knight speaking on November Ist for ail: for

Value

We will use those as a platform to mobilise support in Lambeth for a campaign against the government, demanding more central government funding. We will campaign over the next two months, and I'm suggesting that we should demonstrate the value of local government to the people of Lambeth and also to the Government itself by a week of action at the beginning of February, in which we will invite the trade unions to use all their resources, including industrial action, to ensure that Lambeth people understand what services fron the council mean.

massvseto In other words, we would bring Lambeth to a halt in that week, and we would make an appeal to workers and to Labour counciis throughout London and the rest of the country to join us in that action.

For the recall conterence which was suggested for January, we would ask the Steering Committee to consider asking people to bring commitments as to what action ihe! can take to support Lambeth in that particular week.

We will also proaching the trade unions outside the local authority sector to invite their support in whatever form they think possible during that week.

At the present moment the trade unions in Lambeth are giving this considcration. and also the Labour parties will be considering this strategy over the next month.

It were suceessful, and "c come to a general agreement that it is a possible strategy, then we should be able to launch a major anti- Tory campaign in favour of more central government funding and a change in policy between now and that week of action in February.

There is no war that we should confine this purely 10 an industrial or a council matter. We need public support. And that requires i campaign by the local Labour parties alongside the trade unions and the Labour council.

• But the conference resolion called for Labour councils not to sell council houses. Will Lambeth be continuing to sell?

Issue

We won't be changing our view on this issue. We took our decision, not because we are in tavour of ¡ESSA HOWLAND (IFL) the sale of council houses, but because, quite clearly, if we were to take a public stance on that issue then we would be liable to be heavily surcharged and excluded from office. Our view was that this was not the issue on which we could get our councillors excluded from office.

That still remains the position. There's a major fight ahead and we intend to be here for it. We don't intend to be diverted on a single issue.

•• But Greenwich council, and also a number of NALGO branches, have taken a stand against council house sales. They've started a struggle. Doesn t that change the situation.

Not at all. Greenwich is the only council that has firmly taken that position. The advice on which they took it is in my opinion very suspect - they were the of being surcharged.

The fact that NALGO is involved in an industrial dispute is a decision for NALGO. It doesn't affect our position.

Is it not the case that Lambeth NALGO have protested against the council's decision?

Well, of course they have protested against it. because they are themselves in danger of being surcharged. What they have suggested is that we should take the danger of surcharge, and not them. Well, that's fine, but it's their decision. not ours.

did pass a resolution suying that councils should not sell council houses. .!: The conferenee was a ›attorm trom which guideines were drawn. Ihey aisc called on the TUC to prepare for a general strike. That's fine. but I don't necessarily think that we are guided by every resolution that was passed. •• You have the conference, and it calls on councils, trade unions and so on to make various commitments. And then Lumbeth Labour group, which was a leading force in orgamsme the conference, comes back to another conference and says: We haven't carried out the action that the first conference • called , for. However, we've got another course of uction, which ne didn't put to the conference...

! The conference agreed that 'individual councils and individual trade unions would take whatever action they thought was appropriate, including industrial action. We're suggesting that the conference with a positive position, calling on people to take whatever action they can to support US.

The conference called for Lambeth to take a stand, and it was not suggested that the only stand we could take was on the sale of council houses. Far from it, in fact. The emphasis of the conference was on the economic cuts which are being directed against local authorities.

What do you propose we do?

•• Carry out the commitments called for by the conference. Launch the broadest campaign you can for other councils and Labour parties...

Scan page 9

Organiser • • What do we do about the financial situation facing this Council?

• Let's pursue this from a different angle.. Even if you get very widespread support the week of action in February, it is not probable that the Government will buck down ufter one week. So we need to have some perspective for what happens after then. What perspective will you be putting forward?

CL We'll have to evaluate our position at that time. 1 can't speculate now.

• What sort of campaigning activity would you like to see between now and February? = The Labour parties throughout the country should be mounting a campaign explaining what the Government is doing. Coordinated action in February could give them a focal point. That was what was missing at the conference: a focal point.

• But the conference did make a proposal about the focal point. The conference said that to defeat the cuts, some councils must be prepared to take a stand against the Government, to the point where they say they're not making cuts. they're not raising the rates, they're not raising rents and charges. The labour movement must be mobilised to support them, through industrial action, through tenants' action and so on. if the Government tries to step in.

SO We could take the stand that we would make strike. you re strong enough. if vou force the Government to back down, then we won't make cuts. But it vou're not strong enough. then we're sorry. but we're going to make the cuts and raise the rates and rents. •3 We're not saying that. We're saying we'll have to make an evaluation. We'll have to consult the trade It requires someone to go first. When you cull on workers to go on strike. you're usking them to take risks, like the councillors would run risks by defying the Government. But the Tories won't be defeated until substantial sections of the labour movement are ready to take the risk...

_ That's right. • • ! Lambeth council. which has been put in quite « leuding position. says it will go as far as it can short of taking that risk...

I! What risk? The counrupt. The lancers in the lUDl Town Hall would have no wages. We can't take that decision ourselves. We must consult the unions. - You have had a conference at which a large part of the Lambeth labour movement was represented. You're in a very strong position. then, to go to the local labour movement and say you intend to carry out the policy decided by the conference.

C! That's exactly we intend to do.

• Except that the mumn line of action you're proposing is one that wasn't decided by conference. und other action which was callby Andrew TRAPPED by a threatening mob on his return to England from France, Joseph Merrick alias the Elephant Man stammers fearfully, "I'm not an animal. I'm a human being. I'm ... a man.

The same words appear on the posters advertising David Lynch's film, The Elephant Man, announcing presumably that this quote the subtitle of a 1970 biography of Merrick) 'A Study in Human Dignity But is it? Is it an account of the undiminished humanity of even the most hideously deformed person - at the same time a study of the easy inhumanity of normal society - or is it a piece of tasteless voyeurism tinged with horror?

Joseph Carey Merrick was born in Leicester in 1862. He was not deformed at birth, but when he was about two he developed a swelling in his lower lip which spread to his right cheek. Before long, his head became quite misshapen, deformed by hard protrusions on the forehead and a great pink fleshy mass on the right side of his face which further contorted his mouth.

His right arm and both feet also swelled, and huge folds of blotchy fungus-like skin hung over his back and hips. Today, the general condition of which this case is still the worst recorded called fibromatosis. But in the 1860s, the condition was attributed to the fact that Merrick's mother had fallen during her fourth month of pregnancy after being panicked by a circus elephant.

After his mother's death in 1873. Merrick's TALAPT remarried and the elevenOver the next tour years, Joseph Merrick's life was ground between the millstones of workhouse discipline and a rapidly worsening deformity. In time it became almost impossible for him to eat and he was admitted to the Leicester Infirmary. "I had to undergo an operation on my face, have three or four ounces of flesh cut away" , he later recorded.

Now he hit on another idea - again preferable to the rigours of the workhouse: he wrote to a music hall star, Sam Torr, offering hospital authorities and the horror of ordinary people. Merrick is not crushed by either the physical nor the spiritual torment howeyer, and soon he is patronised by high society, even royalty, as a symbol of their Christian compassion towards the deserving untortunate.

But dreadful ordeals still await him. The hospital caretaker leads a troop of drunks and whores to stare and mock at Merrick. His old 'owner', Byce, (presumably a fusion of two historical characters: Norman and audience as he shares the front of the royal box with Alexandra, Princess of Wales.

Shortly thereafter he dies at the hospital, choked to death by the weight of his head pressing on his windpipe, as he strives to sleep not as usual with his head on his knees, but head back on the pillow.... as normal people do.

David Lynch's film departs from historical accuracy at a number of points. In itself that's no crime. Why shouldn't he fuse the character of the (apparently kind) Norman and the merciless Austrian impresario and come up with the disgusting Byce? Why shouldn't Merrick receive the plaudits of the theatre audience when in reality he sat unnoticed at the back of the box, screened off from the public?

There is no oftence in that. Yet, the fact is, that every time Lynch departs from the truth, he presents us with one of the many scenes which fill the viewer with an overwhelming sense of revulsion. You are left wondering whether Lynch isn't more interested in a sort of emotional stunt work than in the development of his announced theme of human dignity or any other less developed themes.

Not long before I saw The Elephant Man, 1 saw Tod Browning's 1932 film Freaks. Banned until 1963, this film had a reputation for being tastelessly voyeuristic. But, in fact, it is not. You leave Freaks feeling unpatronising admiration: for ue sundarity or the circus freaks, feeling a common bond of warm humanity with them and only hate for those who seek to exploit them. The Elephant Man, by contrast, just makes you feel

----- pull-quotes -----

Fine •• Bill the conference

we've got to take a stand in February. We're going to

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 31

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →