Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[no cuts. But it requires more than one…]

Socialist Organiser no. 31, 6 December 1980 · scan p. 9 · about 451 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

no cuts. But it requires more than one council taking that decision. You're not suggesting that we should take a decision now that the council should go bankrupt?

You can t mobilise forces if you say to people: We want you go sellin come houses. you re not pursuing. C! That's right. We have no intention of being excluded from the stage on that single issue.

I hope your paper will be backing Lambeth council in the stand it intends to take. year old boy. by then grotesquely deformed. was driven out into the streets to hawk. But passers-by horner, away his hawking from him In brought him no reward but a good whipping from his father. His hawking finally came to an end in about 1880 when the commissioners refused to renew his license.

Alone and unable to find himself for exhibition as a freak. The Elephant Man all was vUIl.

Torr soon passed over his 'act' to the impresario Tom Norman. In 1884, while Norman was exhibiting the Elephant Man in a store front in Mile End, the 'act' was seen by the fashionable surgeon Frederick Treves.

David Lynch's film starts at this point. It takes us from Treves' 'great find' when Merrick was 21 to Merrick's death at the age of 27. We see the impersonality of the stiff-collared doctors. the hostility (at first) of the OC atter the presidential elecan Ausurian impresario who mistreated and cheated Merrickl recantures him during this disgusting bacchanal and takes him to France to exhibit. There the Elephant Man is treated with even more violence than when Treves first found him chained, half-starved, beaten and broken in health.

On his escape and return to England, Merrick is chased by a mob that corners him, but he is rescued by police who take him back to Treves. Again he is fêted by society, even receiving the applause of a theatre most of its members fled sick and appalled.

When Byce's sideshow is closed down, the police give as their reason that 'This exhibit will degrade the viewer" • Of course, this is nonsense: it is the fact of exhibition not the exhibit itself that degrades. The same is true of the film: it is not Joseph Merrick, brilliantly played by John Hurt, who degrades, it is the way his wretchedness is exhibited for commercial gain that degrades.

Soon after, Byce arrives at the hospital to reclaim his human 'property': "He is my livelihood. He is the greatest freak in the world" he snarls at Treves. "You only want the freak to show those doctor friends to make a name for yourself." Perhaps the same accusation should have been snarled at David Lynch.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 31

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →