Police power report calls for INDEFINITE JAILING WITHOUT TRIAL WITHOUT TRIAL
Socialist Organiser1981 1981-01-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
wardes). that The suspect's only safe- breach this code - like forcguard is a right of appeal ed confessions - should be * Against attacks on gays by the State; abolish all laws discriminate against lesbians and gay men; for the right gay community to organise and affirm their stance publicly.
* The Irish people - as a whole - should have the right to derermine their own future. Get the British troops out now! Repeal the Prevention of Terrorism Act, Political status for Irish Rep* The black working people of South Africa should get full support from the British labour movement for their strikes, struggles and armed combat against the white supremacist regime.
South African goods and services should be blacked * It is essential to achieve the fullest democracy in the labour movement. Automatic reselection of MPs during each parliament, and the election by annual conference of party leaders. Annual election of all trade union officials. who should be paid the aver* The chaos, waste, human suffering and misery of capitalism now — in Britain and throughout the world — show the urgent need to establish rational, democratic, human control over the economy. to make the decisive sectors of industry social property, The strength of the labour movement lies in the rank and file.
Our perspective must be working class action to raze the capitalist system down to its foundations, and to pui a working class socialis sistem in its place — rate: than haring our representatives ... re item and sa:-a: - at the ICS tries to appear as a nonpolitical guardian of public order, taking no sides in political argument or class struggle.
• The British state has worn this disguise more successfully than most. It has evenf convinced millions of workers workers that there are no political prisoners in the jails in the North of Ireland!
There's no war there either...
just "the troubles' , just a disturbance of public order...
FEW THINGS can be guaranteed to bring out the ugliness in our society as much as beauty contests. They don't just degrade women:
they degrade all of us.
Shortly before Christmas, that guardian of the nation's moral fibre, the Sunday Mirror, revealed that it had managed to pressure Coral Leisure, who control Pontins, who in turn sponsor the Miss Great Britain competition, whose title is 'owned' by Lancaster City Council, to readmit one of the finalists to the competition.
Caren Metcalfe had been barred from the final because she is deaf.
Of course, only the most dignified and humane reasons were given for this decision. "If she won, she would face the nerve-wracking prospect of an interview in front of the cameras" , said a Coral executive.
In reality, however, Caren Metcalfe's deafness offended against all the principles of the pin-up business. It threatened to take the whole pathetic affair off its pedestal of perfection; it threatened to defy the cardinal rule of all beauty contests by making the contestant come to life in human form, in a form that demands we respond as humans and not as drooling fools.
For all the busty posing, the flashing smiles and the provocative hip-swinging, beauty competitions are about passivity. They flatter not the female form, but the feelings of millions of men who want to dominate women and who feel that they cannot do that as long as the women are active.
It is the nearest thing to necrophilia: it works as long as the women are technically alive but without any of the qualities of independent life. Caren Metcalfe' 's offence is that she can't let us see her simply as a 'living doll'.
by Bob MORE powers for the police, less rights for defendants -that is the recipe of the Royal Commission on Criminal Procedure.
Their proposals, leaked to the press before official publication next Thursday, mark another step in the state's erosion of democratic rights.
Under the slogan of law and order, the state seeks to insulate the police still more firmly from public scrutiny Under the slogan of 'protecting the public interest seeks to set the police yet further above the people.
What does the Commission want?
* Extended police powers of arrest. Until now the police have needed a warrant to arrest anyone on a charge carrying less than a five year sentence. Without a warrant, the police could only summon such defendants to court.
Now, the Commission recommends that the police be granted the power to arrest without a warrant anyone for whom there is 'reasonable suspicion' of having committed an imprisonable offence (or even a finable offence, where there is a problem of identification).
The Commission contents itself with trusting' that these increased powers will be sparingly used and outlines some vague and all-embracing criteria, not backed by sanctions, which the police should follow in making decisions about arrest.
* Extended police powers of detention. Until now no specific rules about detention have been formulated, beyond the norm of habeas corpus, which prohibits undue detention without charge. Now the Commission recommends for 'petty' crimes that defendants must be charged within 24 hours or be released.
But for 'grave' offences (undefined) this 24 hour detention can be repeated if an FOUR Executive Committee members of the Paedophile .Information Exchange are standing trial at the Old Bailey from January Sth for 'Conspiracy to (shades of South Africa, in after 48 hours. Again, the commission 'trusts' that detention will not normally be imposed beyond two days.
* Extended police powers of interrogation. Until the present, suspects have the right - albeit often flouted or not used - to legal advice when under detention. Now the commission _ recommends that the police be able to bar access to a lawyer if they believe this might impair their investigations.
The "Judges' Rules" which have guided interrogation procedures in the past, are to be replaced by a hopelessly ill-defined 'code of practice' for the regulation of Corrupt Public Morals' There is no maximum sentence for this charge.
They are charged with publishing a contact list for members of PIE, so that paedophiles — adults who are sexually attracted to which - anage len sing ....es groups are as ine juage warns the jury that it was obtained in this manner.
* Extended police powers of search. The Commission recommends that the police should be granted unlimited power to enter a suspect's premises after arrest without a warrant. They justify this on the grounds that it merely ratified existing (illegal)
police practice. The supposed safeguard is that police write down their reasons for the search, and defendants can challenge these later in the courts.
The result of this commission is not only to increase police powers, but children — could get in touch with each other.
Allegedly individuals (not those charged) could use the sheet to facilitate illegal and immoral activities.
'Corrupting public morals' is not recognised as a crime - but 'conspiracy to corrupt' is. This is the only remaining common law conspiracy charge under which the penalty for 'conspiracy' is heavier than the act itself.
And, as with all conspiracy charges, the sort of evidence needed to convict is much more loosely defined than for ordinary crimes. Conspiracy charges have been used again and again when the police decide to clamp down but have little firm evidence - in the Angry Brigade trial, in the Shrewsbury 24 prosecution, more recently in the 'Persons Unknown' affair.
The stage is therefore set for a show trial. where what matters is not s much proving thai crime, were committed. let alone that an! child was harmed, but the creation of an atmosphere of hysteria, sensa. tionalism, and a public ery also their 'right' to police themselves. And this despite the undenied fact that the police already habitually flout the law on defendants' rights.
From within the Commission, opposition has come from only two dissidents, former 1&G general secretary Jack Jones and the Rev. Wilfred Wood, the black Canon of Southwark.
Some opposition outside the Commission is already being organised by the National Council for Civil Liberties. In a discussion with Socialist Organiser, the NCCL's legal officer, Harriet Harman, called the report "a charter for wrongful conviction and one that will further worsen already strained relations between the police and the public" PHOTO: PETER MARLOW For us as socialists, our commitment to exposing the undemocratic nature of all police in capitalist society and their role in serving our capitalist overlords, should not cripple us from undertaking, alongside civil libertarians, the urgent and practical struggle against the extension of police powers and for the extension of legal and public accountability.
The recently formed Labour Campaign for Criminal Justice will be holding at meeting on the Royal Commission on Wednesday 25th February, 7pm in the Jubilee Room, House of Commons.
One of the speakers will be Diane Hayter JP, general secretary of the Fabian Society and a conformist member of the Royal Commission.
This will be an opportunity for all members of the Labour Party to tell Ms Hayter what we think of the report and of those who put their signature to it, and to help build up the campaign to stop the report ever becoming for blood.
'Campaign against Public Morals' has been set up to defend the four. (There were originally five defendants, but charges against one of them were dropped because he is suffering from terminal cancer and not expected to survive the trial). Unfortunately the pamphlet concentrates less on the trial and more on the Campaign's own views of paedophilia (as potentially a means of children's sexual liberation).
Many in the women's movement, the gay movement, and the Left would argue that unequal power relations make adult-child sexual relations oppressive, not liberating.
But digging up an aneient and arbitrary law in order to prevent paedophiles from communicating with each other is in no way a contribution to protecting children, or to dealing with paedophilia constructively and rationally. Whatever our views on paedophiia, the labour movement must add its weight to the call to stop the trial.
----- pull-quotes -----
order is granted by a magis- interviews, the enforcement The extension can be repeat- of which is to be purely a ed indefinitely after that discipline. matter of internal police addition to Sir Michael Ed- through procedures
Further, evidence gained admissible in court, so long