Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

The First Task of the Left

Socialist Organiser no. 32, 10 January 1981 · scan p. 8 · about 1,262 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

'The use of the army and the police against a government enjoying legitimacy by bourgeois standards is not a simple operation' VLADIMIR DERER, secretary of the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy, outlines a perspective for the Left and criticises John O'Mahony's perspective for a Workers' Government (SO 27/28).

THE correctness of the diagnosis that this year Blackpool was not just another Labour Party conference is being gradually confirmed.

The election of Michael Foot by the Parliamentary Labour Party in preference to its favourite son, the defection in all but name of Shirley Williams and David Owen, the acceptance of the wider franchise for the election of the Leader by union leaders previously hostile to the idea, are all indications that the process set in motion in the Ball Room of the Winter Gardens is going on.

We may: argue whether Blackpool really amounted to 'half a revolution' as suggested by John O' Mahony (SO, 11 October).

PHOTO: ANDREW WIARD (REPORT) But an exact assessment of the degree of change that has occurred is not really all that important. What is important is whether the Left will be able to take advantage of the situation created by that change.

One can therefore • only agree with comrade O' Mahony that "if we organise to make these reforms work for the working class. they are the beginning of a situation that has not existed in the three quarters of a century since the trade unions developed a political arm"

The obvious question is, how are we to do this. Comrade O'Mahony claims that 'Our central weakness is that the working class movement does not yet have a coherent policy to deal with the enormous crisis of British society. It has a hodge-podge of measures which propose more or less drastic tinkering with the economy and the political system — not its replacement by a radically new system • What we need, according to comrade O'Mahony, is "the submission of the economy to democratic planning on the basis of social ownership..." and the takeover by the working class of 200 monopolies.

To do this "we need to organise ourselves to take on the existing rulers" and here "the great hole in the leftward-looking renewal of geestion of he state on the queston of une state .

'It is an illusion that the transformation of the labour movement can be done in segmented stages The questions comrade O'Mahony raises — reiterates would be a more accurate way of putting it - are of course important, though some of the answers he gives are perhaps not as straightforward as he seems to suggest. Thus the replacement of the present by "u rudically new sy'stem is not possible overnight, i.e. without a transitional period such as would inevitably have to be full of "hodge-podge measures"

Nor is the failure to take account of the Marxist theory of the state "the great hole in the leftwardlooking renewal or at any says, 'We must not confuse Parliament with state power The state is not a monolith. The bourgeois democratic state, i.e. a state in which the ruling class relies on those who operate the representative democratic institutions to ensure that the latter arp used in ite ..- ULU 11l3 interest, is in fact full of contradictions. Under certain circumstances its representative institutions can be used against the interests of the ruling class, and the reassertion of the bourgeois supremacy within the state is by no means automatic.

'The first task... to ensure the carry out election pledges...' The use of the army and even of the police against a government enjoying legitimacy by bourgeois standards is not a simple operation. But, of course, no serious socialist would deny that such dangers do exist.

However, should the reiteration of old truths -particularly when they are presented in a somewhat dated setting — be our first priority? For the whole underlying trend of argument in comrade O'Mahony's 'Viewpoint' is directed against reformist illusions.

These certainly do exist among the broad masses (who do not read SO) and among many Labour Party members (who are just a little less likely to do so). But these illusions do not exist amongst the many socialists who do read SO and who comrade O'Mahony hopes to rally round its platform.

The main problem on the Left at this stage is not reformist illusions but sectarian illusions and practices. It was not reformist illusions which prevented -during the last forty or so years — the Left from producing a credible alternative to Labour's right wing leadership. It wasthe Left's preference for a fantasy world inhabited not by real people but lifeless formulae. And it was the Left' steadfast refusal to engage in such poltical struggles as are possible in the environment we actually live come politicalls influential, must show its capacity to gain support among the broad masses of the people as well as among the more class conscious elements of the working class. But people can be organised only around such demands as they are already preparig to ed to support. The programme of the Left, at any given stage, must therefore correspond to the existing level of consciousness of the people to whom we are appealing.

If the great majority believe that improvements in their condition can be achleved through the pursuit of social reforms, it is no good lecturing them about the need for a revolution. Whether social reforms can actually be achieved without radical change in the political structure can only be shown in practice and in any case most people will learn only from their own experience.

Only if those who oppose major social reforms resort to extra-parliamentary resistance will it be possible to convince people that extra-parliamentary means are required to reinforce the powers of reforming governments trying to carry out their programme.

Clearly the possibility that the ruling class may resort to force in order to safeguard its privileges must always be taken into account, as must the need prepare appropriate counter-measures. Nevertheless this is not the situation we are facing at this stage. The problem is not what extra-parliamentary action is appropriate to organise support for a reforming government, it is to get such u government.

And there is, of course, no guarantee, to put it mildly, that the next Labour РНОТО: KAREN GARDINER failed to carry out even the programme of the mild social reforms on which it was elected.

This failure was not due to the fact that "nothing can be achieved within the system • It was not 'The system which stopped virtuous men and women from carrying out their excellent intentions.

Barbara Castle when discussing the difficulties of getting through some of her social reform schemes put her finger on the real problem: It was not the Civil Service, let alone the police and the army, which prevented her mild reforms from going through. It was her Cabinet colleagues.

The first task of the Left must therefore be to ensure that the next Labour government is composed of men and women ready to honour Labour's election pledges and to ensure that these pledges are as radical as the present level of consciousness. of Labour Party members allows.

Labour Party members would respond positively to such aims and would rally around an organisation campaigning on such a platform. If the Left agreed to campaign on a programme of reforms it would be the first step towards winning political credibility and support.

----- pull-quotes -----

rate not in the way comrade O'Mahony poses it when he

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 32

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →