[government will be a reforming one. Given the…]
Socialist Organiser1981 1981-01-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
government will be a reforming one. Given the present level of consciousness among Labour Party members, Labour supporters and Labour voters, there is not a hope that they would be prepared to support the kind of programme of radical social change that comrade O'Mahony advocates. Does this mean that there is no hope for socialism in our time?
The problem with the last Labour government was not that it lacked a programme which was sufficiently radical — which of course it did. The trouble was that it Every Labour Party member realises that the last Labour government went back on its pledges and thus helped the Tories to win the election. They do not want this to happen again.
But only the Left can actually initiate a campaign of this type. No one else will. We must engage in such political class struggle as is possible in the present sitaation. To refuse to do so on grounds of doctrinal purity is to contract out.
Scan page 9
"PEOPLE who pronounce themselves in favour of the method of legislative reform in place of and in contradistinction to the conquest of politica power and socia revolution, do not really choose a more tranquil, calmer and slower road to the same goal, but a different goal. Instead of taking a stand for the establishment of a new society, they take a stand for surface modifications of the old society... Our programme becomes not the realisation of socialism, but the reform of capitalism, not the suppression of the system of wage labour, but the diminution of exploitation, that is the suppression of the abuses of capitalism instead of the supRosa Luxemburg, Reform and Revolution. e can be as a minority. It does not ind such only relate to the masses. are al- It relates to individuals, Be, must acquire the levers to reach, ond to let alone organise, the reople to • That is why the so ling" groups are important. = can be While fighting together ind such with people who will are pre- struggle only for reforms But AL- it is essential to explain to sup- about socialism - on the e those basis of their own experNO serous socialist world cornterpose socialism to the fight for reforms. Now, on the contrary, the fight for reforms and against the vicious Tory counter-reforms is especlally important, in a situation where the Right of the Labour Party, those who built their plans for mild reforms on a continually expanding full employment capitalism, are public polltical bankrupts.
But it would be a selfneutering exercise If the Left were to confine itself to reforms and see this as counterposed for the immediate future to the fight for a new society, for socialism.
That would be to mistake where we are at, what we need to try to do, and what we can realistically attempt to do in the period ahead.
What kind of reform programme would Vladimir Derer put forward now? That is the key question. Would it be limited to what was considered - by an a-priori calculation — to be 'possible' without having to shake or overthrow capitalism? Or would it be drawn up according to the minimum that the working class can settle for if it is to begin to solve the problems loaded onto it by the crisis of capitalism — mass unemployment for example?
Vladimir Derer should think out what even modest reform like the 35 hour week (which would only go part of the way to answering the workers' needs) implies in today's conditions. Such a reform is inconceivable without mass industrial/political mobilisations of the working class. Even should a Labour government decree it, it would not be implemented unless the labour- movement mobilised itself and fought to impose it. Otherwise it would suffer the fate of the 40 hour week decreed by a reforming government in France in 1936: a pression of capitalism Itself".
trade unions — and a party committed to carry out the socialist transformation of society when it had convinced and organised enough workers.
Their method would be the ballot box, backed by force if (as they expected) the ruling-class state was used to stop them.
This was the Second International before 1914. Essentially it was an apparatus-building, bureaucratic, and propagandis view. It led to a situation where in fact the goal of socialism was forgotten and reform became everything, leading to reconciliation with the national capitalists. The day to day activities came to be everything; the goal came to be nothing.
Against this view there came to be counterposed another one: the struggle for reforms should be linked to a struggle for socialism. Reform demands should not be formulated as a minimum programme drafted to be compatible with capitalism and therefore not attached to the goal of socialism, nor even necessarily pointing to it.
Reform demands should class it could rouse itself in tremendous industrial mass strike mobilisations, and for political ends too.
In the struggle it could learn in days or weeks more than in decades of slow organisation and propaganda.
Is this idea of a mass transformation of consciousness an irrational appeal to belief in ana reliance on miracles? Not at all.
The spontaneous strike of ten million in France in 1968 came a few weeks after the failure of an attempt by the trade union bureaucrats to call a token strike. The defeat of the riot police by the students on their barricades galvanised the workers and gave them a model of victory to which they responded eagerly and with an explosive energy.
The idea is emphatically not that socialists manipulate. We say who and what we are and what our goal is — and we say more than transitional demands. The key idea is that the workers can and do mobilise with limited immediatę objectives, but that the struggle unfolds and has a sharp anti-capitalist logic when mands appropriate given level of worki struggle, according logic each stag struggle.
Transitional demi a bridge between t sciousness of labou ments dominated reformist allies of th class, ano the co ness of the need for cal break with caf the energy and dy s provided by the s The movement g consciousness by wi escalating mobil and struggles, and interaction with th or-less stable gre revolutionary social BUT VLADIMIR asserts that "peopl organised only arou deny prepared to demands as The programme of t at any given stag therefore corresp the existing level sciousness of the p whom we are appea Obviously people organised only arou demands as they : pared to support. ( READY prepared port? Where hav create a socialist society. logical). A central task of a into mutually exclusive Eating them into a strategy.
to the ng class : to the = in the ands are the con- without dislocating them it moveby the itself a chaos and a force le ruling nsciousr a radi- repulsion of 'Lefts' with vitalism: 'namism focuses. truggle. rows in ay of its lisations through e morerups of ists.
framework.
Derer • The Left organises first support. the Left, of con- masses.
• The Left must be deprives the capitalist class defined by an overall an- of the possibility of exploitalysis of society and a ation, by making industry basic historical programme own democratically. for the working class to owned and controlled social property, and by breaking • The tasks of the Left the power of the army and are many, not one task, police to make a bloody because the class struggle counter-revolution against takes place on a number of fronts (at least on the eco- The state is not a mononomic, political and ideo- lith, comrade Derer adds.
But does it not have a core serious Left is to prevent of 'armed bodies of men', these fronts falling apart packed up by the state bur aucracy? Are not both activities and therefore linked directly by a thousorganisations) by integr- and strings of education, wealth, family, and thereOver-adaptation, chame- Coas loyalty to mited to leonism in one area means class, committed to repelling the others. The the defence of the existing Left is either a force for system? integrating the different If that is agreed, then it fronts, issues, struggles, can usefully be added that campaigns, etc., via a of it, hd that the Parliament is part of the comprehensive programme and organisation which creates specialised groups can be, contradictions (potfor specific areas and tasks entially contradictions which will lead the ruling from the whole, or it is class to, turn on Parliament). for creating chaos via onein fact though Parliament sidedness and mutual itself is directly under the bourgeois influence. For different assessments and example, Tony Benn has • It is necessary for the shown from his experience in government how the perLeft to explain (and deve- manent bureaucracy has lop) a socialist overview, goal, and criticism of soc- something like a parallel steering wheel and drives iety, and win people to the vehicle of state often that; and to educate the against the will of some or people with whom it is all of those elected to that active on specific issues to function. see those issues in that In reality, not a great deal even in the way of reforms has been pushed through against the serious opposition of the ruling class, and nothing fundamentally against their interests. 'Under certain circumstances" says Vladimir Derer, its representative institutions can be used against the interests of the ruling class, and the reassertion of bourgeois supremacy within the state 1s by no means automatic"
Yes, the labour movement has used Parliament, and must use it now. But Parliament has also dominated and even tamed large sections of the labour movement. Surely that is what much of the fight to make the MPs accountable is about: to reverse the historical experience and subordinate Parliament to the priorities and concerns of the working class.
----- pull-quotes -----
le fight for socialisn NOW OR JENN