Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[dead letter within a short The capitalists would…]

Socialist Organiser no. 32, 10 January 1981 · scan pp. 9–10 · about 954 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

dead letter within a short The capitalists would resist, defy the law, evade it, use the courts to obstruct it, or organise lockouts if necessary. They could probably be defeated only through sweeping nationalisations and replacement of the present managers by people elected by We will only win any serious reforms now on the basis of struggles which shake the capitalist system, perhaps to its foundation. That does not mean, as one might conclude from what Vladimir Derer says, that it is all hopeless.

For "Vladimir Derer's picture of the situation is too pessimistic and his conception of how the presently reformist workers will be won to fight for socialism is inadequate.

Suppose it is true that only reforms are likely to be accepted as goals by the mass of workers now. How do we get from this to a struggle for a different society?

There have been differ. ent answers to this problem, a recurrent one in the history of the labour movement. According to one, the struggle for reforms would be organised by the socialists, who would build up be formulated according to the needs of the working class, without regard to whether or not they were compatible with capitalism (that is, with the maintenance of the principles and boundaries within which the capitalists owned industry and controlled the political system).

The name such 'reform' demands are known by in the history of the socialist movement is 'transitional The working class would mobilise and be mobilised on its felt needs to gain such demands. Engaged in the struggle for them, it would learn with great strides about the system and about itself. It would choose between achieving its own needs at the expense of capitalism - or abandoning its own needs and confining itself to a 'minimum' reform programme none of which challenged the capitalist system. In fact, in a situation of capitalist crisis, the minimal approach yields practically no reforms at all. lo return to the example above, the 35-hour week is a rather modest demand - in Britain now only an onslaught on capitalism could achieve it throughout industry.

The new approach argued that the working class needed stable organisations, but as a fighting the fight for satisfaction of even limited, immediate needs brings the workers into clear conflict with capitalism. hain A linked 1 chain of demands can be constructed - beginning, say, from the 35 hour week or the sliding scale of hours and wages, and going on to the struggle for workplace and other workers' committees, to the struggle for workers' control to challenge the employers' untrammelled rule in a factory, to the creation of a workers' militia from (for example) flying pickets — all the way to the overthrow of the political power of the bourgeoisie.

There is no a-priori schematic sequence in the way a struggle will untold, ana no a-priori order in which a sequence of demands will be raised. The logic and intensity of the struggle will determine that.

The role of Marxists in the great working class struggles on which such a view is based is first to learn from the working class. But Marxist theory acts as the codified memory of the class, and Marxists try to bring that 'memory' to the living struggle around them. They try to raise transitional deMass action... the 1 ideas "already' con Can we not help the ideas people st The conclusion follow that the Le gramme must o the existing lev iciousness. If it di you would have thing as a stable fined by some d from the existin or you would hav vately-defined tive 'Left'. (And y THEIR ideas com How would new arrive at them?] • There is not level of conscioust are we appealin known home group.

• A given ness is not homo, it has many cont elements which rapid changes in cr ness possible und ure of events. to shape all-round way. upport?). loes not le from? society.

just one less, nor ig to a geneous onsciousgeneous: radictory make two systems? onsciouser pressThe great significance of the decision on re-selection of MPs, and what may be decided on the Party leader, is that it would bring Parliament itself under the direct influence and partly even under the control (if Labour had a majority) of the labour movement.

But what would happen then? Certainly the direct grip and real control of such a Parliament over the 'armed bodies of men' and over the bureaucrats would diminish. If such a parliamentary majority reflected the working-class, and fought the ruling-class interest, then it would be shown that Parliament does not control the state.

If the conflict between Parliament and the state became intense, then parliamentary control would cease to be real; and to the degree that the Labour MPs really fought for the working-class interest, then have to be a transitional the conflict would become period between capitalism intense. Either the working and socialist society — but class would disarm the ruling-class state, or it would is there a point at which there is a qualitative break- face disaster.

At issue nere is not a through out of capitalism choice for "bloody revoluand towards socialism (with tion', but the protection of the transitional period the labour movement from beyond it)? Is there a bloodier counterrevolution. dividing line between the Of cour se, parliamentThere is a dividing-line ary legality would be of and a break - at the point where the working class

Scan page 10

very great advantage to th working class movement. But the ruling class would probably erode and begin Organiser his other pet subject is

----- pull-quotes -----

freeing of the dockers, july 1972. ne from? lence — and organise

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 32

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →