Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

BRIEFING on January 24

Socialist Organiser no. 33, 24 January 1981 · scan pp. 7–8 · about 1,358 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

IOMA recause it make the : now cond they are then lave actual support ave got to 'e going to sted me on to that Is speech fact that it 17 times at conference ated they ) was the here was g that this ip another ion, you ther interommittee, immes on what shall ids — you nmitted to House of ! are going election to to abolish is that the as enormheory that power is lain power our Cab. h attemptfact you ich, Lord a senior emovable lans, says hal. Mayvill. Mayill. What ¡titutional inning Dn...

I think I'd answer it this way.

The task of a socialist is to analyse where power really lies. The Press tells us the power lies with the 'Left-dominated National Executive Committee' and 'the trade union bosses' That's the way the Mail, the Express or the Sun put the landowners and the bankers and the multinationals anı But anyone who has thought it out knows that true power in our economy does not reside there. It still resides with the landowners and the bankers and the multinationals and the IMF and the EEC and so on.

The next question is the one you're putting: if you try to change things, how can you beat those centres of power? To answer that, you've got to convert yourself into a different sort of analyst, and say: they've got power now, but they've got the power now because we accept that they have power. If we decide that they won't have power, then they would not be as strong as they appear to he.

ernment retreated and ment • • What about the experience on Irish Home Rule before the First World War? It was put to the electorate again and again. It was very well known that that was the Liberals' programme. And yet the Tory Party and the Army were able to veto it.

I don't believe that parallels of that kind are necessarily valid. If a Labour Government was elected committed to the unity and independence of Ireland, as I hope it would be, I don't think now it would present such a problem.

It's a mistake to attribute too much real power and capacity to undermine an elected Labour Government to those who now, because no-one questions their power, do have power.

Let me give you an example. During the 'winter of discontent' I was responsible for the oil supplies. I had an opportunity of studying at first hand just how effective the Army would be if it were asked to take on responsibility for the supply of oil. It simply couldn't do the job. The Transport and General Workers' Union could. In fact the TGWU could offer a better emergency service during a dispute against a Labour Government than the Army.

This is a perfectly manageable problem; but only provided that before we start we know where the power now resides and how to mobilise popular opposition to that power and poplong time, what are the necessary steps for the democratic transformation of society. I don't think you would win without having a broad socialist perspective.

If you did, then inevitably you would be drawn in to be a management team of a system whose criteria you didn't accept and end up with another confrontation with the people who put you there, which is what's happened time and again:

1970, 1979, and so on.

We have got to the point where capitalism cannot function with strong trade unions and the democratic process. We are stuck in this impasse. Unless Labour is prepared to take the initiative and move towards transformational strategy, it will be destined to get elected on the disappointment of people with the injustices of capitalism, on the rhetoric of change - and then get driven back again when in office.

normal that the electorati can hire and fire a Prime Minister but that workers can't hire and fire their management' Labour and the ballot box are sufficiently strong now to dislocate the market economy. And because they are so strong that they can dislocate it, unless you're prepared to change the framework of the market economy and the frame. Name.

Address.

Send to: ford Hill Cheques lutionist solution to these problems would mean that you would end up in power but without public support, up against exactly the same forces.

That is, in ettect, an attempt at an industrial short-cut to socialism, or a short-cut by industrial action. It would work much less effectively and leave you with a situation where you could not get rid of the Government you had got by that route, anyway. That is the high road to Stalinism.

And of course the other difficulty about doing it by the revolutionist route is that then the institutions you were fighting would have the constitution on their side. With what I'm saying, they would not have that moral cover. They would be facing a very big majority in the House of Commons.

Subscribe E3 for 12 issues, E6 24. Overseas, air m £5 for 12 issues, E9 24.

SO, 5 Stam , London N' payable to Organiser by JON LANSMAN [secretary of the Rank and File Mobilising Committeel THERE ARE two ways in which the Left could be defeated at the Special Conference.

There could be no decision at all, or an electoral college could be agreed which gave 50% of the votes to MPs.

The former would be more of a victory for the 'hard Right' ', since only then could David Owen and others reconsider their intention to leave the Party. However, in that case the issue would remain very open, since the NEC itself would bring the whole matter back to Conference in October.

The latter would reinforce the hand of the Parliamentary Labour Party and the mainstream Right, given the widespread determination among even sympathetic trade union leaders to close the matter. However, the Left would have won some ground and could make further progress in future.

Neither of these is desirable, but, as I explained in the last issue (SO 32), a Left victory will almost certainly depend on retaining support from the right-wing union USDAW. It will be essential, both at the group meetings on Friday and at the conference itself, to maximise the chances of retaining USDAW support.

There • is still procedural uncertainty. There may be a group meeting on Friday for delegates from all organisations which have proposed electoral colleges at conference. If this materialises, delegates should demand to be sub-divided on the basis of proportion options rather than the wording of their proposals. If that succeeds then the following should emerge from the sub-groups:

• The NEC submission (Agenda pp. 5-6), to cover all proposals for 3-way parity.

• The USDAW submission (Agenda no.76), or failing that the almost identical no.69, for 30-30-40 (also covering CLPD's 30-3038-2).

• The CoHSE submission for 40-30-30.

If the groups meet on the basis of wording, then the following should emerge:

• The NEC submission, from those with the NEC wording and with a separate section for Socialist Societies.

• The USDAW submission or no.69 from those with the NEC wording but no separate section for Socialist Societies.

• The CLPD/RFMC resolution no.112 from our own group.

Campaign for Democracy Special Conferenc Briefing Meeting 1pm-2pm, Saturday 24 January, in the Severn Suite, Wembley Conference Centre.

Speakers: Tony Benn, Andy Harr is. Chair: Joan Maynard.

Admission 50p In the Conference itself, maximum support from the very first ballot must be given to USDAW's resolution, or failing that to some formula giving 40% of the votes to the trade unions. If USDAW reneges on its submission, we may ultimately be forced to swing behind the NEC proposal, but with much less chance of success.

Scan page 8

humanity, teamwork and tears, keeping your word

----- pull-quotes -----

Power in economy still resides with

the IMF and the EEC

almost ended up in an alliance with the Establish.

'It's strange that we shoul accept as

'The revolut- ionist solution ... an industr- ial short-cut tc socialism... the high road to Stalinism'

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 33

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →