Common Market: Time to Make a Real Choice
Socialist Organiser1981 1981-02-07Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
The recent debate in these pages on the Common Market has been necessary and enlightening. However, all the contributions tend to treat the question in the abstract as a fixed problem rather than examining it in the context of specific situations. The position socialists take on the EEC may differ according to the concrete circumstances facing the working class at a particular point in time. It is not simply a once and for all question of capitalism versus socialism, as Graham Norwood suggests, nor always a question of working class independence versus class collaboration, as John Bloxam implies.
SCALE
In this discussion where we start from is important. The EEC does not represent, as most of the nationalist left appear to think, a political conspiracy to weaken the workers. The 25-year postwar boom led to major developments in new technology, a shift to new advanced industries and the development of multinational enterprise. The growth in the scale of capitalist enterprise and the increasing centralisation of capital made the nation state appear increasingly inadequate in its developing role as the manager of capital in a situation where smaller national capital was squeezed. This was particularly the case for the small European capitals in a world market dominated by the USA.
The EEC was an attempt to provide an economic and political framework within which European capital could compete with the USA, the first continental capitalism. The blueprint saw first the customs union, the merging of companies in member states into European companies, complemented finally by moves at state level to provide an integrated Curopean state for an integrated European capital. This ideal agenda was crippled by competing national interests and ideology and particularly the disintegration of the post-war boom. A distinctive European capital, still less a distinctive European state, has failed to emerge. What we are faced with is a minimal framework of rules, a weak bureaucracy, a formal means for member states to negotiate directly in an attempt to reconcile cuipeting interests.
A limited arrangement rather than a business utopia, the EEC is a capitalist organisation. Barratt Brown is right when he says " ... all the economic institutions, rules and regulations of the EEC are designed to achieve just one economic end: that the allocation of resources is determined in the market by the return in profit to private capital." The same is true of the United Kingdom. In January 1973 and June 1975, therefore, the working class was not facing a choice between a socialist Britain or even a Britain in which major steps were being taken in a socialist direction, and the EEC.
What was at stakt was whether British capitalism should join or remain outside a wider capitalist organisation. Which choice could provide the most efficient conditions for exploiting the workers? For the workers the problem would be' essentially the same in or out.
Socialists should not have opposed the EEC any more than they would opts ine entry of one capitalist firm into an amalgamation with another. In both cases the correct approach is to fight the impact by linking up with workers elsewhere. To do otherwise would be to indulge in Luddism or unpaid management consultancy to intensify sectionalism in one case, nationalism in the other. In 1971 and 1973 the majority of the left participated in a dangerous diversion: the EEC question had nothing to do with the real problems facing the working class. The anti-EEC campaign. - inevitably class collaborationist and nationalist - did nothing to help the struggle against the Industrial Relations Act and the Heath government. By reinforcing the ideas of the national interest and uniting the Tory right with the Labour left, it helped in 1974-5 to defuse for Callaghan-Healey the movement which removed Heath from power.
In 1981, however, the situation is different: the Brighton decisions and other developments hold out the possibility of a future Labour government which would act in the interests of the working class. A future Labour government which, for example, took even i minimal step of nationalising 25 profitable monopolies would face an immediate capitalist backlash. uaaue alt The mainspring of this backlash would not •be the EEC. But such a gover-