Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Labour after Wembley: a 4-page feature Gang of 3 moves Out but big guns of the Right are still in place

Socialist Organiser no. 34, 7 February 1981 · scan p. 5 · about 1,995 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

To make Socialist Organiser a real campaigning paper that can

WE WON at Wembley. But it is now clear that the decisive battle on leadership election is yet to come.

That will take place at the Brighton conference in the first week of October. It is only there that the decisions of Wembley can be clinched and consolidated by defeating the new counter-offensive now being mounted by the parliamentary elitists and their backers in the trade unions.

A victory like that at Wembley, in which good 'tactics' and the mistakes of our opponents played such a big part, is an unstable victory if a replay can be staged. It looks like it can be, and that it will be at Brighton.

The newspaper headlines have focused attention on the ditherings and meanderings of the Gang of 3, on 'Roy Jenkins and his claretdrinking eunuchs' (T.E.

Utley), and on the Tory

Fifth Column in the PLP.

These are important. But

more important is the fightback launched within days

of the Wembley decision by

Hattersley, Healey and

Shore in the PLP, and by

important trade union leaders like Terry Duffy.

Duffy says, "The battle

has been lost, but the war

can still be won. We hope

to put matters right next

time round."

Michael Foot has moved

to put himself at the head of the counter-offensive.

Foot responded to the Wembley decision with this statement: ''The conference has made its decision, and according , to our constitution that is now part of our constitution. I certainly accept the vote, and I hope that the whole Party - left, right and centre - will accept the vote as well"

Later But four days later Foot told the weekly meeting of the MPs that the -right-wing dominated -Shadow Cabinet will shortly put forward an agreed solution proposing that the Wembley decision should be overturned and reversed at Brighton. A statement signed by 150 MPs - including some Tribunites -calling for reversal was simultaneously issued.

It seems that technically it will be possible for them to put the matter on the agenda. Their goal will probably be to give the MPs. 50% of the electoral college, which Foot promised the PLP but proved unable to deliver at Wembley.

As the Observer commented editorially, "Belated.

ly the fightback within Labour's ranks has now begun.

There appears to have been serious talk of a declaration of independence by the PLP. (This may have been a major reason why Foot felt obliged to put himself at the head of the fightback despite his first reaction after Wembley).

But there are lesser manifestations of independence than a clear-cut repudiation of the conference by the PLP. One possiblity was aired by Philip Whitehead, discussing the situation of Roy Mason.

•What happens if Mr.

Scargill gets the union and the constituency to disown him? Will Mr. Foot keep him in the Shadow Cabinet or not? If reelected to that body, as he would be, would Mr. Mason test his popularity in his home town before the general election, offering his endorsement by the PLP against his rejection by the Barnsley management committee?"

But the central danger of a victorious counter-attack lies not in what the PLP does, but in what the unions do. The principle of the electoral college was passed overwhelmingly (by 6,283,000 to 411,000).

ROM NUADES To 1910 tok ¿LEVEN, I'm puzzled how the Coun cil of Social Democracy will select a leader, although I suppose they could always have a wine-tasting comp etition'.

(BRYAN McALLISTER, THE GUARDIAN)

The 40-30-30 formula however only passed by half a million votes in a situation where the union moving it, USDAW, didn't believe in it, and where the AUEW, bitterly hostile to it, sat on 900,000 votes.

As Duffy says there is good reason for them to hope to sort that out if they can get a replay.

There is also the fact that the trade union leaders, collectively, are now committed to laying rough hands on Parliament itself, on its traditions, prerogatives and immunity from direct outside control, pressure or interference. The displeasure of the ruling class at that prospect has been loud and angry and the trade union leaders are being made to feel that maybe they have bitten off more than they can chew. For the trade unions to have put themselves in this position half by accident and blundering and partly as a result of being outmanoeuvred, must mean that at least some of them will recoil in real alarm, and try to get out of the line of fire.

Their alarm, if the rank and file of the unions allow them to give expression to it, could lead to a serious retreat. And of course the victory at Wembley wasn't only a victory for the radical socialists of Labour's rank and file. The decisive weight in the scale was that of the trade unions led by the bureaucracy. Add to this the fact that something like a bloc of the non-kamikaze right and the soft left is taking shape on the NEC. At the last meeting Kinnock, Hart, Lestor and Short voted with Shirley Williams, etc. to reject a proposal from the Organisational Sub-Committee because it would have ruled out an interpretation of reselection allowing one person shortlists. (Williams seems to have delayed planned resignation from the NEC to deliver her -decisive - vote on this).

Despite the ballyhoo, the Gang of Three, or Eleven or whatever, are only a small segment of the right.

In fact, it is increasingly clear that they are the least serious part of Labour's right. Their choice of sabotage tactics seems to be, by getting out of the Labour Party, to try to make it impossible for it to hope to form a government.

This tactic is probably based on a massive overestimation of their own potency - probably induced. Narcissus-like, by their own reflection in the mass media. The Hattersleys and Healeys want to stay in and pursue the tactic of gutting and undermining the decisions on democracy. They plus their allies on the soft left are the people who matter in what looks like a formidable counter-attack.

For this reason the cliffhanging soap-opera of the "claret-drinking eunuchs" is, at least for now, a sideshow. Nothing short of a reversal of the principle would satisfy them and they won't get it now. Some of them sound as if nothing less than break between Labour and the unions would satisfy them. But they won't get that either. To nullify reselection via the absurdity of a one person shortlist, and to cut down the direct labour movement share in the vote for the Labour leader (and Prime Minister) and maybe to enfeeble the reform by, for example, making it less than annual or inoperative if Labour is in government - that would satisfy the rightists who still have a will to remain alive in the labour movement. And they can hope to gain these things.

That would be a major defeat for the hopes of a political renewal of the labour movement and therefore for the hope of providing a real, working class, socialist alternative to Thatcher and to Toryism, whether of the pink or blue variety.

Antics

In a real sense the media nurtured antics of the Gang, inspiring as it does hatred and disgust in most Labour movement activists, can help the Hattersleys by making them seem by contrast an acceptable right wing and not the formidable enemies of socialism and of a socialist renewal of the labour movement, which in fact they In 1931 the dramatic and open betrayal MacDonald, Snowden and Thomas drew a sharp organisational. hut politi cally

misleading, line between them and their co-thinkers like Herbert Morrison, who (on MacDonald's advice) had stayed in the farty. Ine traitors assumed the role of scapegoats for their political co-thinkers and counterparts who remained behind, making them seem a different breed politically, which they were not They, like Denis Healey and Roy Hattersley today chose to stick to the labour movement as their field of operations. They stayed and shaped the subsequent history of the party (tor example, it was primarily Morrison who gave Labour's post-1945 nationalisations the character of bureaucratic state-capitalist corporations without a vestige of workers' control).

Today the Gang issue the threats but it is the "loyal' right wing which, together with Foot and the soft left, is putting together the forces for a counter-offensive that can derail the process of self-renewal. The main right wing enemy is the one that continues to make its home in the

In fact, it is not at all clear that the Williamsites

have much prospects as an independent political force.

The latest opinion polls

show that all 11 of the proclaimed CSD MPs would

lose their seats if they had

to stand against the Labour

Party (which should be a

knockout blow to the stupid

myth, central to the right wing' s agitation against reselection - that the voters support not the party but the individual).

The political living-space for their projected party is, essentially, already occupied by the Liberal Party. The polls show that, exactly like the Liberals, the social democrats would take most of their votes from the Tories. In fact, if the projected party didn't move quickly to fusion with the Liberals it would have to compete bitterly with them on the same ground.

The comparatively fayourable response to the idea of a centre party in some of the polls no doubt expresses disillusion with the parties, unhappiness with the sharp polarisation between the Labour Party and the Tory Party now, and a wish that things were different.

But what reason is there to think that the process of polarisaztion, which is a response to the crisis of society, can be reversed, that an organic centre party can be newly cobbled? The

mischief the 'Social Democrat' party could do, including perhaps lost elections for Labour, should not be underestimated or treated lightly. But if they are not to become a cosmetic element in a Tory government presenting itself as a national government like 1931), which is what Tony Benn thinks they might become, then they are more likely to contribute to a revamped Liberal Party than to do anything else.

If the two-party mould of British politics is to be broken, it is not clear why people who will be indistinguishable from the Liberal Party, in competition with a left-faced (at least) Labour Party operating in conditions of mass working-class deprivation, should be the ones to break it.

There was something symbolically synthetic, fake and unreal about the scene when the three, together with the merchant banker Jenkins, issued their Limehouse Declaration to the TV cameras - rich and good-living people who had

made careers in the labour

movement emerged from the private upper-middle

class lifestyle cocoon that

Owen has built for himself

amidst the decayed dockside terraces of the East

End, in total isolation from

the lives and. most of the

present concerns of the

working people in that

area. Media

They were being sustained by the media as by a political life-support system. But the fawning, manipulative media bosses didn't save Dick Taverne.

What must we do now? We must generate the maximum pressure on the NEC to ensure that reselection is not gutted by allowing one-person shortlists.

We must continue the work of the Mobilising Committee. Its work between now and Brighton will probably be more important than its work up to the Wembley Conference. And that was vitally important.

We must turn to the trade union rank and file and rouse a massive barrier of active opposition to any moves by the trade union bureaucracy to retreat from the Wembley decisions: Duffy and his friends think that they will be able to throw the weight of their unions behind Foot and Healey. The rank and file must be mobilised to make sure that they can't.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 34

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →