Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

A Tory on reform and revolution

Socialist Organiser no. 34, 7 February 1981 · scan p. 8 · about 741 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

Certainly the army and the ies this really was a revolupolice force have seldom tion, fundamentally, for The debate between Vlad- been more deeply consery. The debate between Vladimir Derer and John O'. Mahony, and the interview with Tony Benn, raised the question of whether power can be taken from the ruling class gradually and peacefully.

One thing that has some weight in this matter is what the ruling class itself thinks about it. And in this context an article by Peregrine Worsthorne in the Sunday Telegraph just before Christmas is interesting.

Worsthorne, a maverick Tory, starts by recalling the anxiety of many in his officers' mess when Labour was elected in 1945. But their wealth and power survived 1945. And, he reassures his friends, they will survive "Bennery' too.

"The system in another 35 years' time may well be more Socialist in name...

But you and your offspring will still be running it. For, short of a violent revolution which physically liquidates those at the top, i is extremely difficult to dislodge a ruling class which has not entirely lost its will to survive.

'Yours, it seems to rather stronger now than was a few years ago. vote in the branches or (better) in the workplaces.

Other changes have included removing much of the influence of working lay union members and the latest decision by the union rules revision committee on December 3rd on TUC and Labour Party delegations. police force have seldom been more deeply consery. ative, thanks to their valuably educative experience in Northern Ireland, which has weaned them off any lurking sympathy for radical rhetoric".

Worsthorne equates socialist revolution with Stalinism, and Stalin's murderous brutality (in fact mostly directed against workers and socialists) with 'killing off' the old ruling class. "Lenin and Stalin were serious revolutionaries who knew that... there is no way to kill off a ruling class except to kill it off". But what he does understand is that the power of the bourgeoisie rests ultimately on violence, and will ultimately tion, transforming their lives fundamentally, for lives .._l.. mad anill good or ill.

"But only a foreign army, or an armed insurr. ection, can bring about that degree of dramatic change... "In British constitutional theory any Parliamentary Government with a majority can do what it wants. But this theory would not survive long if it was used in war's profoundly unacceptable to a majority of the middle class...

•This is not to deny that many Socialist innovations were introduced by Mr Atlee's Government, which certainly helped to transform the material lives of working people. But the degree of change at the top was not very great. Public ownership did not alter the existing industrial or commercial hierarchy. Those who gave the orders before continued to do so. Bosses and workers did not change place...

"(And) just as R.A.Butler soon found ways of taking over Atleeism on behalf of the old order, turning the Welfare State into a bonanza for the middle class, so will some future Tory magician do the same to Bennery. delegation to go his way on Labour democracy?

Duffy declared: "It won't happen next year, because I'll make sure our delegates are elected by the divisional committees.

Continuing the debate on socialist strategy started by Vladimir Derer, John O'Mahony and Tony Benn "Of course the hard men of the Labour Left think they know better, as did their counterparts in Allende's Chile, who also thought that their middle class would submit voluntarily to dispossession.

That will not happen in Britain, any more than it happened in Chile.

•Either Bennery will be taken over, as was Atleeism, by the middle class, for its own purposes, or, if the hard men behind his Government try to push Leftwards regardless, poor Tony will suffer the British equivalent of Allende's fate...

Unless, of course, the counter-revolutionary violence of the British Pinochets is answered by revolutionary violence. What Worsthorne can't see is that this revolutionary violence is not some secretlyorganised sudden bloodbath, but just the normal generalisation of workers' self-defence on the picket line — on condition that the labour movement has understood and absorbed the lessons on the nature of capitalist • power which Worsthorne offers want to defend their living standards and jobs, these changes are important.

But they are not enough without a similar clean-out in the unions — particularly the AUEW.

Just as the Labour leader is to be elected annually,

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 34

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →