Caricaturing Dr Kirk
Socialist Organiser1981 1981-02-07Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Anthony Sher as Kirk He sets up a visit to his university by a racist professor of genetics and a student protest against the visit - all the while keeping himself in the background. "I abstained, actually", , he says atter the sociology department meeting that votes to invite the professor.
REVIEW Organiser Socialist But: "Now there'll be trouble, and it will radicalise everyone, and we shall have a good term"
He ruthlessly seduces women. And he gets a rightwing student from his sociology class expelled from the university.
Moral of the story? seekers. At least, that's the moral of the story in the BBC version. For the film angles the story rather differently from Malcolm Bradbury's book.
Bradbury's viewpoint (unless 1 have misunderstood him completely) is expressed in the selfreproach of the hero of an earlier novel, "Stepping Westward.
'I wanted to work in with the wheels of history. (But) I should have left history alone, passed by on the other side. That's the truth. I'm a people man. The myths of history, these new faiths, they're all myths of dispossession. Take something away from someone and give it to someone else. But I'm for people, people keeping what they've struggled to have. I don't think we can yield up what exists for the possibility of what might. That's my idea of liberalism: kindness to what is, to those who now exist.
So the books - both •The History Man" and "Stepping Westward" (which has an earlier version of Kirk in Bernard Froelich, not a Marxist but a go-getting American academic) - are ittee. Sam Lomas from the emic. We are invited to idertify, in a self-mocking spirit, with Beamish in 'The Hiatory Man" or Walker in 'Stepping Westward" - the victims of the "wheels of history". • Kirk is not pilloried but gently dissected.
In the book, Kirk, until his mid-20s, is timid, hardworking, and conformist. Then he discovers he can use sex and politics as means of self-assertion. In the film we only get the end result.
When the book describes a clash between Kirk and a right-wing student Carmody, in a sociology class, it tells us how "dul, dogged, weak" Carmody's essay 1s, now tolerant the left-wing students. are, how diligent and competent Kirk is as a teacher. In the film all that is blanked out: it is just Kirk vindictively crushing Carmody.
So... the constituency delegate with the leather jacket and jeans was not Howard Kirk. But the BBC's producer was probably there at Wembley somewhere, caucusing in a corner with Shirley Williams and some of those other defenders of decent liberalism against left-wing ruthlessness.
structure of the campaign we