Poland: new face, same bureaucracy
Socialist Organiser1981 1981-02-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
The Polish bureaucracy faces a new challenge - occupations and demonstrations by millions of small farmers. The state has half-heartedly replied that although a Rural Solidarity union structure is 'out of the question' • an 'association' of farmers is not. Once again the bureaucracy has to hide behind legal obscurities and terminological tricks.
However the partial retreat can only strengthen the resolve of the farmers to continue with their fight. If they are not granted recognition, the farmers say, food supplies to the major cities will cease this coming spring.
It is these events which explain the latest government reshuffle in Warsaw.
The new Prime Minister is Jaruzelski, an army general. He will continue to be Minister of Defence too.
For the first time in the history of Polish Stalinism, a major military figure is head of the government. Yet the general comes dressed in the robes of a 'moderate' - a Polish nationalist widely believed to have refused to.. use the army against the striking workers in Gdansk last summer.
We can be sure that this reluctance had more to do with the deep sympathy of IAN PAISLEY's attempt to pose as a second Carson, saving 'ulster' from the "sellout' of the Thatcher-Haugh. ery talks, reminds us of Marx's remark that 'history repeats itself, the first time as tragedy, the second as farce"
Instead of thousands of men with rifles openly drilling, 500 men on a dark hill brandishing firearms certificates. While Carson's Uster Covenant was signed by thousands, Paisley's badly. spelled petition has met with a lukewarm response.
But there is a serious side, and more is at stake than electioneering for Paisley's Democratic Unionist Party. Firstly, the firearm certificates are a reminder of how well-armed the Paisleyite bigots are.
Paisley refused to say rank and file conscripts towards their striking fellow workers, than with any liberal humanitarianism on Jaruzelski's part.
Mieczyslaw Rakowski has been appointed vice-premier.
A member of the Communist Party's Central Committee and editor of the influential weekly 'Polytika' • he is known for his 'liberal' views within the party apparatus.
He has been a critic of the government's unwillingness to stick by the Gdansk agreement to loosen up censorship and allow oppositionists access to the mass media.
The Education Minister Gorki has appealed to students occupying several faculties at the University of Lodz to end their action and call off their threat of a national student strike. As concessions, he has agreed that compulsory courses in Russian and the Stalinists' own petrified version of 'Marxism-Leninism' will no longer be compulsory as in the past.
Clearly the Stalinists hope that with these liberal credentials the new government will be able to fool the workers, peasants and intellectuals, that real progress is being made in reforming the regime.
Jaruzelski, trying to cash in as quickly as possible on his supposed popularity, has, whether Royal Ulster Constabulary or Ulster Defence Regiment men had been involved in his manoeuvres in Co. Antrim — a fairly clear indication that some were. In any case, Paisley's supporters clearly have legal access to quantities of weapons. This contrasts with the case of Bernadette McAliskey, who despite police warnings of a likely attempt on her life was unsuccessful in three attempts to get a gun to use in self-defence.
Paisley wants to demonstrate to Thatcher that ANY agreement between Thatcher and the southern prime minister, Haughey, will be opposed by Loyalists who wish to ensure their supremacy in the North. Of course the Thatcher-Haughey talks are unlikely to lead to a united Ireland - but PaisSTRIKE PL for the time being, refrained from attacking the Workers' Defence Committee (KOR), who act as advisers to the Solidarnosc leadership. Denunciations of KOR had been a constant theme in government propaganda over the last month.
He has appealed to the free unions for a 90 day moratorium on strikes and disturbances, for the sake of 'social peace' The leaders of the workers' union Solidarity, acutely conscious of the danger of all-out repression or Russian intervention, has been eager to seize on any seeming chances of peaceful progress. They have said the union will not engage in any strikes 'if the authorities refrain from attacking it" • In a move to tighten the reins on local rank and file activity, the central leadership of Solidarnose has threatened to disown any industrial or political action not in accord with the new concordat.
Similarly, KOR has agreed not to push for the publication of unofficial papers and journals which might find disfavour with the Communist Party leadership. They are placing hopes, it seems, on government promises about the relaxation of official censorship.
In the negotiations over the recognition of the farmley wants to make sure they lead to nothing at all.
Paisley also wants to raise the level of tension among the Protestants at a time when a hunger strike is due to begin, and stir up a new pogrom atmosphere. 'Hitting the Carson trail' , as he himself cynically puts it, is his means to these ends.
ANNED Burtis it even possible?
ers' union - Rural Solidarnose - Walesa has tried to pacify the small peasantry by stating that, although their claim for recognition at present 'has no basis in law" it will not be forgotten when the new Labour Code is drafted later in the year.
The urgent desire of Solidarnosc 's leadership, or sections of that leadership, to arrive at some agreement with the Polish stalinists is visible in this feeble argument over the 'law'. Had industrial Solidarity given in to such arguments about legal niceties last summer the present mass political movement in Poland would simply be a wild dream.
Walesa has also had secret talks with Rakowski, at the end of which Walesa stated that the new government and the attempt at some con cordat, is "our last hope.
But the present rise of the 'liberal' and 'nationalist' elements of the bureaucracy has a parallel in all the crises of the bureaucracy since the 50s.
In 1956 Gomulka -'liberal' in stalinist terms then, a 'national communist' a man who (like Jaruzelski) had been disgraced and imprisoned by the Russmass movement which was sweeping the country in the wake of Khruschev's de-stalinisation and the Hungarian revolution.
There is no doubt that Gomulka would have been prepared to fight the Russian army if the latter had tried an invasion. In fact the streets of Warsaw and other cities were being barricaded and army defences set up.
But at the same time Gomulka used the threat of a Russian invasion as the stick to beat down the workers' and farmers' impatience. Then Gomulka's regime drifted more and more to the 'right', gutting all the initiatives and organisations of workers' control which had sprung up. Within years the working class was once again firmly in the grip of the Stalinist political machinery - with none of its demands satisfied.The faith and confidence which the Russian bureaucrats placed in Gomulka to patch up the crisis was well justified.
And it is highly dangerous for people like KOR and the Solidarnose leadership to place any faith in the re-run Gomulkas of today.
Political and social victories for the working class and Poland's national independence will not be guaranteed or furthered by capitulation to such bureaucrats, but only by a political revolution led by the workers themselves with all the attendant risks and uncertainties. If the demands of the Polish workers, blocked since the establishment of the Stalinist regime, are to be realised and a farcical re-run of 1956 avoided, resolute and increasingly militant opposition rather than concessions is necessary.