Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[absence of any spontaneous mass movement fon a…]

Socialist Organiser no. 35, 21 February 1981 · scan p. 8 · about 1,045 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

absence of any spontaneous mass movement fon a scale experienced in 1917-20) in set up workers' councils, and instead a successful restoration of parliamentary institutions took place.

This not only undermined the theory that bourgeois democracy is dead, but also threw serious doubt on the theory that working class rule (in any meaningful sense) must take the form of soviet democracy as it appeared in Central and Eastern Europe in the years 1917-20. It now seems more likely that this form of direct democracy" owed more to the political vacuum created by the collapse of autocratic regimes in countries in which the traditions of representative government were weak, rather than to any historical trend to set up organs of workers' power in this form. Soviets that were set up during that period lacked stability and may have been no more than a transitional political phenomenon. national. The other he associates with what he considers to be a programme of transitional demands.

On the first conception he comments: "Essentially it was an apparatus-building, bureaucratic and propagandist view. It led to a situation where in fact the goal of socialism was forgotten.. the day to day struggle came to be everything; the goal came to be nothing" • Unfortunately for comrade O' Mahony's argument, things are not so simple.

In the case of Russian Social Democrats there was a clear link between 'organisational' opportunism and opportunism in politics. No such link existed in the pre1914 German Social Democracy. If anything, on organisational questions the German opponents of revisionism occupied common ground with the Russian revisionists. This, incidentally, also accounts for their political failure. Rosa Luxemburg put her faith in the spontaneity of the masses as a counter to opportunist 'organisation.

Lenin's view of German Social Democracy was very different. To a very considerable extent his conception of the party was in fact derived from the German model.

Was this simply "an apparatus-building, bureaucratic view.. comrade O' Mahony indirectly implies?

This is what Lenin actually said: 'Take the Germans. It will not be denied that theirs is a mass organisation, that in Germany everything proceeds from the masses, that the working class movement has learned to walk...

Members of the hostile parties have often taunted socialists. 'Fine democrats you are indeed. Yours is a working class movement only in name; in actual fact the same clique of leaders is always in evidence... But the Germans only smile.. at these demagogic attempts to set the 'masses' against the 'leaders' the Germans. have accumulated sufficient experience to understand that without a 'dozen' tried and talented leaders. no class in modern society can wage a determined struggle" (What is to be done?).

Propagandist view? Let us once again look at Lenin's experience of German Social Democracy: 'Everywhere the Social-Democrats are found in the forefront, rousing political discontent among all classes, rousing the sluggards, stimulating the laggards, and providing a wealth of material for the development of political consciousness" (Ibid). He approvingly quotes Engels, 'It must be said to the credit of the German workers they have exploited the advantages of their situation with rare understanding. For the first time since a workers' movement has existed, the struggle is being conducted pursuant to its three sides -the theoretical, the political, and the practical-economic - in harmony and in its interconnections, and in a systematic way" (Ibid). movement is everything" , in the dictum, "Who says organisation, says oligarchy" • It is a pity that comrade O'Mahony should echo these sentiments when he claims that in the Second International "day to day activity came to be everything; the goal came to be nothing"

More recently, attacks on effective forms of organisation have masqueraded as the rejection of "democratic centralism". . The organisational principles of the pre1914 German Social Democratic Party (as adopted by Lenin for Russian Social Democracy) are being held responsible for the totalitarian regimes in the East European states and the USSR.

Here the Left's emotional distaste for work within the existing political framework is being passed off as the need to concentrate on the 'self-activity of the masses' - a general term which for some reason is being extended to a variety of extra-parliamentary activities organised by sectarian or semisectarian political groups and to their expectation of what will emerge from 'community politics'.

Whatever view we take, whether we blame 'organisation' , the 'system', or just the concentration of power in the hands of the central government, the gist of it all is that the responsibility for reactionary policies is being transferred from people to impersonal mechanisms. Not only does this give party leaders virtually absolution, but above all it diverts our attention and energies from the struggle in areas which matter most.

* Vladimir Derer is secretary of the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy. He writes in a personal capacity.

This article will be continued in the next issue of SO. sidential address, where he said, 'The purpose of my political remarks is not to apportion blame for blame's sake, but to stress the need for unity of purpose in the movement in the future. That and that alone will secure the election of a Labour Government'.

"As Brother Crawford was elected to office as a member of the Labour Party, we should ask: is he going to stand again as a member of the CSD?

Relieved

•Another is Clive Wilkinson, leader of Birmingham City Council, who also comes from the right wing of UCATI. The Building Workers' Charter (Vol.3 no.9) describes the sort of person who can be relied on to put country and self above the working class. • 'He is a member of the Northfield WE118 branch of UCATT but he has never been part of the movement as such. He is a self-employed carpenter by trade ... and has called (as his contribution for International Women's Year) for legalised brothels to cater for tourists using the new National Exhibition Centre.

A career-minded man who has willingly carried out the Government's cuts'".

BUILDING WORKER:

FOR RANK AND FILE MILITANTS IN THE BUILDING INDUSTRY New issue out now:

• A fightback against subcontractors?

• Court acquits UCAT"

militant • Costains sackings • Shirley's backers in UCATT.

10p plus postage from 223b Queens Road, London SE15.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 35

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →