[necessary? No. The disagreement is not about whether…]
Socialist Organiser1981 1981-02-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
necessary?
No. The disagreement is not about whether radical changes are needed, but about how to bring these changes about: how can the working class and the masses be convinced that their problems are not soluble within the capitalist framework?
Comrade O'Mahony claims that 'Vladimir Derer's picture of the situation is too pessimistic" • Why? Apparently because I believe that "only reforms are likely to be accepted as goals by the mass of the workers now" • What evidence is there that this is not so?
Is there any other explanation for the fact that year after year, decade after decade, the British working class votes Labour? Surely comrade O'Mahony does not share the view of Militant that Labour candidates would do better if they tried to get To base socialist strategy on the expectation of their reappearance in one form or another - as all those who exalt the importance of extraparliamentary action do - is not optimism but an attempt to replace politics by wishful thinking. But even were the unlikely situation to recur, and soviets on a mass scale make a spontaneous appear- ance, political influence in such bodies could only be gained by parties which have already struck deep roots within the working class as the result of their participation in the political struggles during the previous period.
Comrade O'Mahony outlines two contrasting conceptions of pursuing the struggle for a socialist society. One conception he attributes to the pre-1914 Socialist Inter### BLAME There is no direct causal connection between the undoubtedly hierarchical features of the workers' organisations and the fact that their leaders eventually jettison socialist goals. When in 1914 the Social Democrat group in the Reichstag finally betrayed the working class, it did not occur to Lenin to blame Social Democratic organisational methods. He put the political responsibility for this squarely on the shoulders of the Social Democratic leaders.
It is, of course, possible to blame 'organisation'. Robert Michels, writing in 1911, paraphrased Bernstein's