Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

How to avoid another Chile

Socialist Organiser no. 36, 7 March 1981 · scan pp. 2–3 · about 1,163 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 2

Wornen and the labou-onor "mentoo itten ant Agm desserts from ge Goman di polandawap how dom glassperuęzle o Rank, ende movemerts iny building os A ney EA Workersiand theiStalinististare unionsido • hesslurnp and the 62p including postage from Box 135, I WOULD like to make a number of points about Vladimir Derer' s reply to John O' Mahony in SO 35.

1. Vladimir Derer appears to ascribe to John O'Mahony - unjustifiably — a spontaneist conception. He states, ''there is no direct causal relationship between the undoubtedly hierarchical features of the workers' organisations and the fact that their leaders eventually jettison socialist goals" • True, but I cannot see where John O'Mahony says there is.

The point made by John O'Mahony - that for the Second International "day to day activity came to be everything, the goal nothing" - is not that we should therefore abandon the idea of building a working-class party (as for example some of the supporters of the 'Fragments' appear to believe), leaving everything to the masses to spontaneously discover socialism.

It is that if socialism is seen as being brought about by gradually building a well-oiled machine, which goes out to win votes on the basis of taking workers' consciousness as it is, then compromises and ultimately betrayals of socialist principle will follow. Socialism will only be built on the basis of the direct action of the working class, and this direct action needs a socialist party committed not just to building a bigger better machine or winning more votes than the Tories in the election, but to defending socialist principles, outlining the line of march, and resisting pressure even from the working class to compromise its principles.

If we were to accept comrade Derer's argument that we can only organise people around those demand that they are already prepared to support, we would end up with a party which reflected the racism, sexism, and all the other reactionary tendencies which exist within the working class and which it is our duty to combat.

2. Comrade Derer argues that the experience of postwar Germany has thrown doubt on the belief that soviets are the natural form of organisation of the revolutionary working class. He does not say anything about the creation of similar bodies in Hungary in 1956, in France in 1968, or Poland within the last 12 months.

3. Comrade Derer speaks with some disdain about the 'extra-parliamentary activities organised by sectarian or semi-sectarian political groups...' But however much one might disagree with the political positions adopted by the ANL, for example, one has to admit that this body, organised by one of these sectarian groups, succeed in building a mass movement to oppose the fascists. What was wrong with the ANL was not that it was extra-parliamentary, but that its politics were inadequate.

4. Comrade Derer does not anywhere in his reply answer John O'Mahony's question about how he would ensure that another Chile did not occur. All we are told is that the presence of 'hard men behind Tony Benn would make it more likely that any British Pinochets would end up as Kornilovs.

But comrade Derer forgets that Kornilov was defeated London N1 ODD. not by the hard men of the Bolshevik Party but the tens of thousands of workers and peasants standing behind the Bolsheviks. He forgets to tell us that it was the self-activity of those same workers and peasants in the months between February and October which allowed the Bolsheviks to take over the power.

ARTHUR BOUGH, Stoke.

Advertisement PO

Scan page 3

Rachel Lever 'THIRTEEN dead, nothing said'. The slogan on the New Cross Massacre march summed up the anger of a community.

The Queen and Mrs. Thatcher had sent messages of sympathy about the Dublin disco fire. The thirteen black teenagers who burned to death in Deptford didn't merit such attention.

When a small bomb went off outside a Minister's house in 1972, injuring no-one, police swooped on hundreds of leftwingers for questioning. In Deptford, no such sweep of organised racists has been carried out. And the police are still 'open minded' about there being a racist motive, although there have been several murderous attacks on black people in the same neighbourhood in the past few months.

The National Front, echoed by some Tories such as Jill Knight, has explicitly attacked West Indian parties, such as the fatal one in New Cross to celebrate Yvonne Ruddock' sixteenth birthday. Yvonne and her brother Paul, and eleven other teenagers, died as the house turned into a firebomb in a matter of minutes.

Anger was heightened by police statements that the fire might have been started by a black person. John La Rose, Chairperson of the Massacre Action Committee, commented: 'If a synagogue was burned down, no-one would have the nerve to suggest it had been done by a Jew.' Up to ten thousand people joined the march, with a core of about 7,000 who went from New Cross to Hyde Park, to bring the message of anger from the MAINLALAN crave mili black community into the bastions of white bourgeois power in Fleet Street, the Law Courts, and the opulence of the West End.

The march was unlike the JANSI OVENTHIMPSON PALL RUDDOOK YYONNE RUDOILK PATRICIA IDANSUN LLOYD HALL JIC FLAPHREYERK BIN PIMBL THAN HENRY PETER CUPBEL MARY FRINCE average white lett demonstrations that snake along the side of the road surrounded by the traffic. For much of the long route from New Cross into central London it went in columns of twelve or more, taking over most of the road. As it roared up Fleet Street, shouting 'Murder in Deptford, Silence in Fleet Street', everyone there must have felt that, if only for a brief few minutes, power had shifted to the people on the streets.

Stewards barred the way into shops and chippies along the way. "Thirteen people died: we're going to march with dignity.' • Three young lads with beer bottles were told to leave them on the ground and rejoin the march. They obeyed.

But as the march came up to the river, it met with a barrier of police. Riot shields, ambulances, SPG, horses and the drone of a helicopter overhead all created an atmosphere of confrontation.

The sequence of events after that isn't clear, but undoubtedly it was the show of aggression from the police which stoked up the anger of some to boiling point. And the press, which would have given the march a few column inches on page four if there had been no 'incidents' was able to go to town the next day with its stereotype of a black riot complete with looting and injured policemen.

The fascist National Front has called a march for Saturday 7th March - to go past the house where 13 black youths were killed.

The Anti-Nazi League has called a counter-demonstration assembling 10.30am at Clifton Rise, near New Cross Station.

Be there!

----- pull-quotes -----

WORKERS' ACTION

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 36

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →