Justice Tory style: The Royal Commission
Socialist Organiser1981 1981-03-07Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
THE ROYAL Commission on Criminal Procedure was supposed to offer a 'balanced' package of recommendations on police powers. They saw themselves as restoring a 'fundamental balance' between, on the one side, the 'interests of the community' and, on the other, 'individual liberties' They equated police power with community interest. They counterposed defendants' rights to the interest of the community, as if these defendants were not members of the community.
And the Commission declared that the 'existing balance' had been disrupted not by the hardening of state power (they raise this issue only to drop it), but by the growth of crime and the danger to the ine better of the lay, Betting It was as if the deaths of Blair Peach and Jimmy Kelly, the SPG, the Special Branch, the Prevention of Terrorism Act, the arming the police etc. had never existed. The Commission seemed to exist in a different world from the citizens of Lambeth, for example.
A recent report on police-community relations there blamed the police for creating 'extremely grave' relations with the community. They cited such practices as 'provoking blacks by shouting obscenities at them from cars', taking it upon themselves (with no law to back them up) to set up road blocks, to stop and search people at will 'to prevent crimes' , and so forth.
As one black bus driver put don't DURING THE second week in February, Zimbabwe experienced the most intense political violence since independence, leaving more than 300 dead and over 1,000 homeless.
Fighting broke out within the 12th Battalion of the new national army at the Ndabazindana Barracks, comprising half ZANLA and half ZIPRA forces. Ironically, this Battalion was commended for the role it played in subduing the fighting between the guerilla forces in November.
By Wednesday the clashes had spread to include the 13th Battalion and the 41st Battalion, and, by Friday,
approach you like they are
police officers; they're more like war officers'.
Yet the Commission's claptrap about 'balance' has still been enough to win the faint hearts and muddled minds of liberal commentators from the Guardian and New Society. They were just thankful that the report was not worse than it turned out, and had not gone whole. hog for Metropolitan Police the guerilla forces in Entumbane near Bulawayo were drawn in.
When ZIPRA guerilla forces moved out of their heavily fortified headquarters at Gwaai River, Mugabe ordered out the white airforce. The jets returned to base without opening fire when the column halted.
The fighting was finally quelled by the 3.000 strong ist Battalion - the new name for the former Rhodesian African Rifles, which is still under white officer command.
Throughout, the violence has been contained to the guerilla forces, despite their proximity to the urban centres of Salisbury and Bulawayo. Indeed, Commissioner David McNee' S police-state They even succeeded in persuading themselves that the Commission had not recommended a loss of rights for defendants, despite the fact that it was quite explicit about it (it restricts rights of defendants to see a lawyers, eliminates the right of silence, extends police powers of arrest, stop and 'DEFENDANTS' rights' are one of the few ways we have of policing the For example, the police are restrained from dragging false confessions out of people by the rule that unsupported confessions are inadmissible as evidence lexcept in Northern Ireland!] These legal controls over the police are often very ineffective. But we should not forget that they are not meaningless, and do provide some - albeit very insufficient - form of independent control.
We should be campaigning for the strengthening of defendants' rights. For example, by giving the Judges' people living in the area are reported to have condemned the fighting.
The frustrations and uncertainty of the transition from war to peace appear to be the main cause of the conflict, linked with long' standing rivalries between ZANU (PF) and the Patriotic Front (ZAPU), which have been exacerbated by the leadership. Some 11.000 guerillas have been integrated into the new army, but 24,000 remain with an uncertain future. With two million unemployed out of a population of 7.5 million, few guerillas are persuaded by the 4month demobilisation pay.
Mugabe has come out of the conflict with a much stronger position. He will
search, and generally
brings the legal situation into line with existing police practice).
In fact, as Harriet Harman from the NCCL, Tony Gifford from the Legal Action Group, and Michael Meacher from the Labour Campaign for Criminal Justice have seen and brought to light, the package offered by the Commission is a rotten deal.
In return for a anc JE Rules, on police treatment of suspects in custody, the force of law.
But this is not enough. It is also vital that direct forms of democratic accountability be imposed on the police.
The more serious civil rights campaigners are calling for measures like giving teeth to police authorities and increasing their representativeness; disbanding the SPG; repealing the Prevention of Terrorism Act; granting local authorities powers to restrict police activity in their areas; opening up the inner sanctuaries of police stations to public representatives [or to the public themselves].
These are elementary democratic demands that we use this to move strongly against the ZIPRA forces. Already an agreement has been signed which cuts off all military aid to ZIPRA.
rights, it offers us 'increased safeguards' over the police. And these safeguards prove in fact to be no more than reliance on the internal disciplinary proceedings of the police themselves!
No external accountability. No control by independent democratic bodies. Just 'trust' that the police will police themselves.
So much for balance.
nocral should totally support.
It is vital that the left does not restrict itself merely to exposing the police for lack of democracy and for acting as an increasingly vicious arm of the ruling class. Exposure is necessary but not enough.
We also join the fight _ alongside the serious democrats — to enforce democratic accountability on the police and to resist the attacks on those small pockets of accountability that currently survive.
At the same time we attempt to convince democrats of the need to completely replace the existing police system.
Mugabe & Nkomo His programme of integrating the new national army has suffered a setback, but his response has been to accelerate it.
----- pull-quotes -----
4000 AH GOM RUN JUSTICE NAH COME!