Mobilising the masses for reforms
Socialist Organiser1981 1981-03-07Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
criticised John O'Mahony's perspective in "Half a revolution?' (SO27, and 'We need a workers' government'[SO28].
John O'Mahony replied in SO 32 ['Now or Never'). In SO 33 Martin Thomas interviewed Tony Benn. In SO 34 Colin Foster and Graham Norwood contributed comrade O'Mahony, havins lismissed the method oi th ballot box, backed by force if the ruling class state was used to stop the party committed to a socialist transformation of society as leading to a "situation where in fact the goal of socialism was forgotten and reform became everything..." , puts his faith in another method.
Let us therefore examine some of the assumptions behind comrade O'Mahony's conception of how the struggle for socialism should be pursued.
He states: 'The struggle for reform should be linked to a struggle for socialism. Reform demands should not be formulated as a minimum programme drafted to be compatible with capitalism..
As pointed out in the first part of this article, I have never suggested that reforms must be kept within what is possible under capitalism. There is no disagreement about the need to link the struggle for reform with the struggle for socialism.
In fact, any consistent struggle for reform is impossible without an eventual break with the capitalist environment. It is precisely this which gives reform demands their 'transitional' character. tions der ge piesly teloming government attempting to implement its programme is bound to come into fundamental conflict with the forces of the status quo. While it is just feasible that any one single demand for a partiSO 35 contained the first part of a second article by Vladimir Derer ['Optimism or wishful thinking?"!
Here we publish the second part of that article.
A letter from Arthur Bough on page 2 this week also contributes to the debate. And we have in hand another contribution by John Watts, which we have had to hold over for lack of space.
Lenin: lead the broad masses to t. cular reform may be accommodated within the capitalist framework, it is quite impossible to accommodate in this way a whole range of measures based on a broad programme of reforms.
The distinction Comrade O'Mahony draws between demands 'formulated ясcording to the needs of the working class and 'demands drafted to be compatible with capitalism and therefore not attached to the goal of socialism' is therefore wholly artificial.
The problem is not the intrinsic character of the demands - in the present context they are all 'transitional' - but the fact that the working class believe that these demands can be satisfied without major changes in he real struggle the present institutional structure.
It may well be that even such a modest demand as a 35 hour week is 'inconceivable' 'without mass industrial/political mobilisation of the working class' • The question is how are we going to convince Labour voters of chis.
Comrade O'Mahony tells as that the Left's programme should not correspond to the existing level of consciousness. What should it correspand to?
Is it possible to influence people without actually comnunicating with them? And 'an we communicate if we speak on a different waveength?
Clearly a different approach is needed for the prospective readers of Socialist Organiser as distinet from the averase Tahour Partu nember or 'the average VasU MANUMA ›abour voter. But there is 1 contradiction here in Comade 'Mahony's augunent.
On the one hand, he adrises the Left 'to explain (and levelop) a socialist overview, goal and criticism of society', to educate the people with hom (the Left) is active on pecitic issues to see those ssues in that framework'. On he other hand Comrade O' Mahony also says: "The Left irganises first as a minority.
'It does not relate to the nasses. It relates to individlals, groups, and only by irst organising them can it icquire levers to reach, let lone organise, the masses'.
To whom then is the Left to xplain a socialist overview? o the average Labour Party oter, to the masses?
But they do not want to be educated' in this way. Socalist propaganda groups, nder different names and anners, have been trying to o this for donkey's years -rithout much success.
The only thing that will convince Labour voters, the masses, and indeed many Labour Party members, that their mobilisation is necessary, is when they have the concrete experience of a reforming government, which they have elected, being prevented by extra-parliamentary forces from carrying out its programme, even though (unlike recent Labour governments) it is determined to do so.
Or is 'a socialist overview' to be addressed solely to the prospective readers of Socialist Organiser? Is it they who need convincing on this score?
Unlike in the distant past when the Left was entering virgin lands, Comrade O' Mahony's prescription no longer applies today. for the present political impotence of the Left in Britain is not rooted in an isolation imposed by external conditions. The Left's today's isolation is entirely of the Left's own making.
In fact numerically the Left in Britain amounts to a sizeable force. What prevents this force from becoming politically effective is its fragmentation.
Each group or grouplet pursues purely propaganda activity. Each tries to convince members of the other groups of the correctness of its own particular position and at the same time each tries to by-pass the mass political organisations of the working class in a vain effort to reach the masses.
The only thing that unites them is their common failure to recognise that, at this stage, genuine political struggles can be waged, and masses can be reached, only within the framework of existing political institutions. Without this recognition the Leit remains condemned to political impotence.
Exaggeration of the importance of the relatively small differences between the various groups is the inevitable by-product of the abstention from genuine political struggles. The unifying forces arising out of the ștruggle against a common enemy is missing.
How can these difficulties be overcome? Not by Comrade O'Mahony's prescription.
According to him the Left, at present, cannot relate to the masses. But, of course, the Left does relate to the masses.
What else is the Labour Left doing when it strives to commit the next Labour government to a programme of a radical social reform; or when it seeks to ensure Labour's electoral victory; or after that victory when it seeks mass support for the implementation of these reforms?
The fact that it can only relate to the masses through the existing mass organisations does not mean that it is not doing so.
What has been demonstrated already in relation to mandatory re-selection and the method of electing the Labour Party leader is that if a systematic, sustained and concerted effort in support of demands that are central to Labour Party policy and to Labour Party politics is ially acceptable, demands, with others which go beyond this limit. (The demand of the Militant tendency for the nationalisation of 200 monopolies being a prize example of this kind of tactical error).
If the Left plays a leading part in such struggles, it will attract support from among the non-committed by virtue of playing that role, and not as the result of its socialist propaganda (which of course it would continue to disseminate).
Capitalism would not rest on mental slavery if it were possible to convince the masses by rational argument and political education. Mass support for socialist policies will not be gained by socialist propaganda, but by socialists winning the trust of the working people through being the most consistent fighters for their demands.
Thus Comrade U'Manony fails to clearly differentiate between these two ways of gaining political influence: one resulting from propaganda, the other from winning the trust of the people whose political class interests socialist represent. He seems to be afraid that unless 'day-today' demands are explicitly tied to socialist demands, the socialist goal will somehow be lost.
The point was made in the first part of this article that the reason for the abandoning of socialist aims should not be sought in the bureaucratic features of the working class organisations, but in their leadership. Equally no amount of combining 'day to day demands' with socialist ones will prevent a sellout by a leadership lacking the determination to carry out a socialist programme.
Nor will the omission of continuous references to socialist demands, for that matter, prevent a really determined leadership from carrying out a socialist programme.
Perhaps because Comrade O'Mahony does not fully acknowledge that there are two distinct ways in which socialists must win support, he is suspicious of the idea of winning support through winning trust. He seems to hint that what I am proposing is some kind of manipulation.
The idea is emphatically not that socialists manipul ate. We say who we are and what our goal is...
What childishness. What exactly do we say and to whom? Are we not to differentiate between the various levels of consciousness depending on whom we are addressing ourselves to? propaganda but actual participation in movements whose semi-legal existence the regime only just tolerates. 'To declare oneself' in such circumstances would be the quickest route to prison, or worse, for among the 'supporters' there would inevitably be informers.
But not just because of that. Among those genuinely involved in such movements there would be many who would be deterred by the presence of people whose declared aim is the overthrow of the existing political or social regime. They would conclude in line with the official propaganda) that such people are merely using their legitimate demands for their own subversive ends.
Should socialists in these circumstances forgo their participation and possibly a leading role in the struggle for religious freedom just because such a participation would require them not to 'declare themselves'? Would they be 'manipulating' if they meet this requirement?
Comrade O'Mahony describes his approach as a Marxist one. Yet Lenin was presumably also a Marxist. This is what he had to say on this subject:
'The immediate objective" of the class-conscious vanguard... is to lead the broad masses (who are still, for the most part, apathetic, dormant and convention-ridden) to their new position... To be able to seek, find and correctly determine the specific path or the particular turn of events that will lead the masses to the real, decisive struggle... such is 'the main objective... in Western Europe and in America today' (Let Wing Communism - An Infantile Disorder)
Comrade O'Mahony concludes that the Left must organise itself on a real socialist programme. This is to beg the question. The dispute is not about whether but about how.
On a number of points one can only agree with him. We must indeed 'add radical political content to the Labour Party as it renews its structures and procedures' Certainly, 'if we start a serious campaign for reforms in the present situation, it will escalate way beyond what we start with' But whether socialists will succeed in preparing the movement politically will depend on the Left's willingness to shed its old sectarian habits and adopt a strategy appropriate to the present situation.
The SCLV has gone some way in that direction. Many defects, which basically stem from the association of its leading members with a particular political tendency, still remain. Notably the overestimation of what workers can learn from the experience of struggle in which there is no intervention by a politically effective Left ('bowing to spontaneity').
To quote Comrade O'Mahony: "The movement grows in consciousness by way of its escalating mobilisations and struggles and through inter-