Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[The origin of the present EETPU regime in…]

Socialist Organiser no. 36, 7 March 1981 · scan p. 11 · about 1,394 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

The origin of the present EETPU regime in the notorious ETU ballot-rigging scandal was the subject of ion Perrin's play The Unday, 24th February, exactly 20 years after the High Court ruled that the 1959 election in the ETU had been rigged by the incumbent leaders, secretary Frank Haxall and president Frank Foulkes.

Both Haxall and Foulkes were leaders of the Communist Party's electricians' group* Catholic Action-ist John Byrne was declared to have been the victor in the 1959 election. The grip of the CP was shattered, and a new leadership around Byrne took control.

In fact, Byrne had been the candidate of a coalition which included a group of recent ex-Pers, especially Chapple and Les Cannon. Members of the CP were banned from holding office (they still are). Betore long the 'regime' fight the CP. Later, confronting a suspicious John Byrne to propose an alliance against the CP machine, he grimly contrasts his own situation, wages, and conditions, as an electrician "taking home peanuts' with Byrne's as a district official. To be a mere member of 'the union' is made to seem a lowly and wretched fall from caste.

There are such people, of course, who mistakenly drift into the socialist movement. The 1940s CP, especially, maybe, in the ETU, would attract such people. (Between 1941 and '47 the CP opposed strikes, and CP secretary Harry Pollitt raised the slogan: 'It is the class-conscious worker who crosses the picket line').

Perhaps Cannon was like that then. But the general crudity of the play gives us no reason to think that the picture of Cannon is deliberately drawn for either truth or artistic purpose, or meant to shed light on what his fate was to be. trotted out in the usual false selse - as if Lenin were talking about tactics to undermine democracy, rather than tactics to fight bureaucratic repression.)

Dramatically, of course, it had to make its hero as sympathetic as possible. That may be why the sympathy is for the religionlike consolation the CP offers and the loss of which Cannon has to face. This is true to part of life, certainly. But to see Pollitt and the younger Cannon thus, through the haze, and to put impossible words describing it in Pollitt's mouth, is not to see them in their reality at all, and not to see their tragedy.

After his break with the Stalinists, Cannon is shown at war with the CP's 'machine' • (He was). He is sacked REM For example, we, together with Olga in nightdress, letter. Coming off the nightshift, he just had to get off his chest a 'letter to the TUC' about the iniquities of the Stalinists.

Olga draws the curtain and lets the light in on unshaven Les, stretching in his tiredness, and lectures him on his health!

The most radically false section of the play is this one, where Cannon is shown in cliché terms fighting the machine, David against Goliath. But this David has the help of a gang of giants who dwarf the CP ETL machine - the press and TV, the Catholic Action machine gime reflects the 960-1 and rent/rate rises.

But UCATT, the union attected by the 600 job cuts in direct works, decided at first not even to contempl ate any strike action. The NUPE mass meeting voted for a one-day strike on the rate-making day, March 4th.

But the NALGO mass meeting passed (by 700 to 400) a resolution from full-time officer Mike Blick, rejecting strike action and calling on the branch executive to neA THOUSAND workers from Ansells, brewery at Aston Cross in Birmingham are standing firm as they enter the second month of their strike for jobs.

They started the action in a struggle against 96 forced redundancies and changed working practices. Then last month 1 Ansells announced that they were going to close down the whole brewery.

The strikers have remained 100% solid, despite attempts to divide them with the offer of 400 alternative jobs at depots and, most recently, a proposed redundancy payout worth several thousand pounds to most machine frightens off prospective employers!

In fact the sustained press and TV campaign against the ETU, aimed at prising the CP grip loose, pre-dated the 1959 ballot-rigging by some years. (In 1957 the Trotskyists published a pamphlet appropriately entitled 'Defend the ETU against Fleet St and King St'). There was nothing heroic about Cannon.

The weapons he chose to fight the corrupt Stalinist bureaucracy with — the millionaire press, the Catholic Action machine and the law courts - amounted to a declaration of his political programme. The tightly-policed ETU of the last 20 years, much much worse than it ever was under the corrupt Stalinists, is the realisation gotiate redeployment, voluntary redundancies, and early retirement.

The majority of the NALGO branch executive has resigned, and is seeking reelection on a mandate for a no cuts policy. But NALGO's and UCATT's failure to move has obviously had a bad effect on the NUPE members' morale.

Last week, however, UCATT stewards did an about-face, and are now calling for all-out strike action at a mass meeting on Tuesday 3rd.

As one of the strikers told Socialist Organiser, 'we are fighting for our jobs and our organisation, not for redundancy pay. The T&G officials want us to accept some kind of deal, but we're all quite clear. We won't accept anything short of the reopening of the Brewery and a satisfactory settlement of our other grievances.' The strikers are now org anising flying pickets to pubs and hotels that are bringing in alternative beer supplies.

Money is urgently required and contributions can be sent to: J.H. Bond, Secretary TGWU 5/377, 23 Barnet Rd, Erdington, Birmingham 23. der cutting through the Gordian knot, abolished most of them.

The tragedy of the ETU was that the degeneration and corruption of a group of would-be Marxist militants led to the politically criminal behaviour of using trickery and ballot-rigging to keep a bureaucratic control of the union. And this allowed the bourgeois state to step in and help Catholic Action and a turncoat like Cannon to take control and make this key union safe for the right wing and for capitalism.

The members of the ETU (now EETPU) were the victims then. They are still the 'The Union' turned the story of how and why this happened into a coarsegrained soap-opera-level drama about the scab Les Cannon.

It was, among other faults, full of trade-union and pidgin-'Marxist' jargon - the play was waterlogged with it, as distinct from using it to establish and define character. And then close to the end film was shown of an interview between Frank Foulkes and John Freeman - and Foulkes was at least a dimension above the level of mindless jargon which was the language of the play itself!

This tragedy deserved better and more serious treatment.

* The CP denies that it knew about or was responsible for the ballot-rigging. It expelled Haxall and Foulkes, and Peter Kerrigan resigned as industrial organiser, though he remained a party member.

Gareth Caley On Tuesday 24th February about 40 students occupied the Registrar's Department at Manchester's Institute of Science and Technology [UMIST] in a campaign to stop further rises in overseas students' fees.

Last year the fees were massively increased, from £1,200 a year to £3,500. The government said this was the 'full cost level' This year the government put the minimum cost at £3,600, and UMIST, gave assurances that it would not charge more. But only 24 hours later they decided to put this year's fees up to £3,900.

During those 24 hours a petition was organised, and signed by 450 students. A picket was organised outside the meeting that was to decide the fees.

When it became obvious that the college would go ahead and charge £3,900, students occupied the Registrar's department.

The next day at an occupation meeting it was decided to go out and widen the campaign by lobbying staff. This will be combined with further lightning occupations.

Several other colleges are taking up the issue of these racist fees, and it looks likely that wide scale actions and occupations will take place in the near future.

----- pull-quotes -----

find him at a table, early in the morning, writing a short

yIng pickets st the beer

£300 in 24 nours

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 36

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →