SO appeals for funds in WRP libel case
Socialist Organiser1981 1981-03-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
ITATEMENT FROM THE equated the Socialist Work- the anglicised version of his our viewpoint or be silenced to deserve at least a nominaA STATEMENT FROM EDITORIAL BOARD WHEN JULIAN Lewis and Paul McCormack tried to use the law courts as a weapon in their fight to control Newham North East Labour Party, they were condemned throughout the labour movement. The act branded them as aliens within our movement. Ultimately it did them more harm than good.
The WRP's attempt to use the courts against SO is an attack on free speech, on free comment and on free debate in the labour movement. It shows how little confidence the WRP has in its ability to make a political response to our comments on them (SO 33). It shows the WRP to have as much contempt for the principle of keeping the bourgeois state out of the affairs of the labour movement as the mysteriouslyfunded Lewis and McCormack.
Why does the WRP choose this course of action?
Because SO's outspoken comments on them threaten their central project of the moment.
They are making a concentrated effort to rebuild support for the WRP in Lambeth. In an effort to regain some credibility they have entered the service of the right wing and of Ted Knight, who leads a big section of the Left in Lambeth.
equated the Socialist Workers Party with the NF because both oppose rate rises in Lambeth. And with the impudence characteristic of them, the Newsline carried an immediate public attack on Cllr Bryn Davies for daring to vote against Knight's policy! In this coin they pay for their alliance with Knight and his right-wing allies.
Ted Knight and his comrades have views on how to fight the Tories which we emphatically disagree with. We have discussed the issues many times in SO. But Knight and his politics is one thing. People who brand the left as the equivalent of the NF for opposing Knight are clearly something altogether different.
The WRP has set up one of their so-called Youth Training Centres in Lambeth (the other is in Liverpool).
These offer night-school style training and facilities to youth on a very broad and supposedly non-political basis, ask for money from businessmen, etc, appeal for volunteer instructors and so on, without any reference to Politic other than 'oryisun the anglicised version of his name, John O'Mahony).
Why not make a formal tongue-in-cheek apology? For a number of important reasons. In the first place, SO values its own reputation as a responsible and serious non-sectarian socialist paper. We do not lightmindedly attack or condemn socialists, or those who call themselves socialists (or anyone else!). SO can and will defend Sean Matgamna's article on the nature and character of the
our viewpoint or be silenced
because the WRP is richer than we are.
And while & tongue-incheek apology would provoke a cynical wink from those in the know, it would add considerably to the problems of the • uninitiated- young people in the Youth Training Centres, for example - in getting to know what's what. They are the people who most need the benefits of free comment in the affair.
Fourthly, given that our real opinion is that SO should in honesty defend the article in court, to make an insincere apology would be to allow ourselves to be torced to tell lies under the compulsion of Ms Redgrave's wealth.
We are not prepared to tell lies to the labour movement or to the youth. That is in general a rock-basic rule. It is urgent to preach it and to live by it because for fifty vears deliberate ana systematic lving and other falsifications of truth have been a major part of the labour movement.
Spreading outward from the totalitarian Stalinist state via the Stalinist parties, the politics of lies and doubletalk, of the double standard or none, of 'anything goes' for my organisation or for my faction, the politics of the numbed or dead conscience and of the supple spine, have wreaked havoc with the politconsciousness political moranty of the abour movement. These are not the sort of politics SO exists to promote.
Not for nothing did Leon Irotsky preach and insist agam and again that one oi the truth to the labour movement and to the masses' We subscribe to Trotsky's Principle. And we will fishi tor It Fifthly, while the WRP uses the courts and the threat of bankruptcy to present SO with the option of paying out a lot of money or denying its opinions by issuing a forma.
apology that would be a lie, the WRP's own press spews out libels against its social.
ist opponents of such 8 volume and ai such speed as to deserve at least a nomination for the Stalin prize for mendacity.
With utter lack of scruple it uses the libel laws to inhibit its critics and relies on the scruples of those it libels to keep it out of court. It has used the threat of the courts against working-class newspapers before. Yet it is not uncommon for Newsline to accuse its socialist opponents of murder or complicity in murder!
To give one of many cases:
A youth who supported the US WRP (the Workers' League) was shot dead in October 1977. For three years there were no arrests - a common occurrence in New York. Newsline commented:
''While the police investigation has never begun... the International Committee of the Fourth International [the WRP's international selfproJection nave exposed then mean relegation ad out the FBI agents who control the leading positions in the revisionist SWP (not connected to the British SWP] as the ringleaders of this political murder... "Lemphasis added]. '[The vicious killing did not stop a struggle to unmask and drive out the agents of counterrevolution in the workers' movement" (Newsline, October 16th, 1980).
Reading the WRP's press
reminds SO how important Trotsky's principle about revolutionary politics and the fight for the truth is. It does not suggest to us that we should apologise to the WRP.
For all these reasons we have decided to fight the case. SO would not choose to spend time and effort on this. There are many far more important things. But we do not consider the only alternative to be an option for us.
Merely by taking out the writs, the WRP has already drawn us into a costly process that now strains our usually stretched resources. So we are starting a fund to pay for our defence.
We ask our supporters to send us a supporting donation. And we ask the SO groups to discuss what they can do to raise money to cover the costs of the case.
* The printers' apology: While SO's concerns are political, the printers' are commercial. Morning Litho Ltd have chosen to apologise to Ms Redgrave. Not wanting to embroil them against their will, SO prints their apology in this issue. Ubviously it does not in any sense detract from our own position.
LABOUR MOVEMENT PRESS DEFENCE FUND Send donations to jonathan Hammond [Hon.
Treasurer], c/o 214
ment Press Defence Fund'.
Name:
Address:...
Organisation:
Donation:
----- pull-quotes -----
the first principles of revolu- tionary politics was to tell
Sickert Court, London N1 2SY. Cheques pay- able to 'Labour Move-