Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[The basic error made by the SWP is…]

Socialist Organiser no. 37, 21 March 1981 · scan p. 9 · about 473 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

The basic error made by the SWP is to believe that you cannot fight within the trade unions AND the Labour Party.

They see it as an 'either/ or' '. It is, in fact, an inextricably interlinked process. You cannot just pick one.

In Lambeth, for example, many Labour Party members are active in the trade unions arguing like the SWP against the Tory government and what they regard as the mistaken pollcies of Ted Knight. They work together.

When the Labour Party members then point out that another crucial area for changing the policies of the council is in the wards, branches and GMCs, the SWP stop. "Sorry, we can't help you there"

Now the joint work approach suggested by Duncan • Hallas is all very well, but what kind of joint work is it when the Labour Party council worker who has been on the picket line with the SWP says, "Right, let's now take this up on the GMC. Let's move discipline of Councillor X, instruct the MP to attend the picket, make Labour Party premises available to strikers, call a Labour Party demonstration. All of this will help the strike" - and s/he is met with a stark, incoherent and irrational negative?

It is ineffective joint work, completely on the SWP's sectarian terms. The SWP and others who think like them thus leave thé Labour Party to the trade union and Labour Party work, he or she sees no contradiction between furthering the direct struggle against the Tories here and now and looking to the possibilities that the pressure of that struggle can exercise on a future Lahour government. They argue for the return of such a government, debate its possibilities, and attempt to ensure that it will carry out a programme of demands stemming from today's struggle, such as the 35 hour week, nationalisation of bankrupt enterprises under workers' control, the repeal of anti-union legislation, and so forth. They agitate, educate and organise in the course of the struggle to help the working class develop beyond such a government.

Once again, the abstain. alist ideas, and the reaction of the capitalists and the state. We argue that the workers therefore must rely only on themselves. And we organise the serious left - within the labour movement.

We hope that SWP members will think about these very basic points. At the moment their organisation is on a one-way ticket to nowhere.

In a recent article in International Socialism, the SWP's theoretical journal, Alex Callinicos argues that, 'Circumstances where the influence of revolutionary socialists is confined to a formation of Marxist organisations into dogmatic sects. This is especially so because there is a tendency inherent in capitalism for the class struggle to become separate into distinct

----- pull-quotes -----

small minority of the work- ing class promote the trans-

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 37

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →