How Labour Can Control the Counciliors
Socialist Organiser1981 1981-04-04Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
ir's Manifesto was decided by a special conference above not by the usual cabal. And i commits a Labour ! against the Government like Poplar's fight in the 1920's [top].
ar against the state?
• atanding in tham AND POSSIBLY TO RATES AUL 4pc swing The Greater Londe Council has 92 member: one for each parliamen ary constituency in i1 area. The Tories won cor trol in 1977. To win bac the GLC, Labour needs 4.1% swing in its favor compared with the Ma VIGEL WILLIAMSON, a member of the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy's Local Government Action Committee, reports on the discussion about Labour councillors and Labour democracy at the March 22nd Socialist Organiser day'THE FIGHT for democracy and accountability in local government must not be forgotten!, wrote Jon Lansman in SO 37. At the Socialist Organiser dayschool, it became increasingly apparent that in fact it is rapidly moving to the top of the political More and more ruling Labour Groups are making largescale cuts, against the wishes of their lacal parties, and against the manifesto on which EKIL they were elected. So the campaign for democratic reform in local government forges a very close, visible, and relevant link between Labour's constitutional debates and the immediate political issues.
At the dayschool, speaker after speaker referred to the issue in general debate, and the workshop on Labour Party democracy concentrated almost exclusively on it. The need for the accountability of councillors was realised by all, and there was fairly clear agreement about how that accountability should be achieved.
Signed pledges and loyalty oaths were dismissed as not worth the paper upon which they are written. As some of those who have freely signed such a pledge in the ĞLC elections prove, little bits of paper are not going to stand in the way of the determined careerist.
on which they were elected.
If any new information makes them wish to vote in a manner contrary to the manifesto, then they must seek a joint meeting with the local Party - and 'no contrary policy shall be followed by any Group member without the express permission of the General Committee of Stirling District Labour Party'.
Stirling now also elects its Labour Group leader at a joint meeting of the Labour Group and the District Party.
It is, of course, only logical that the party body that controls the manifesto and selection process should be given the power to elect the Labour Group leader.
London Labour has proposed some similar reforms.
Of course, there are large areas of local government PHOTO: TESSA HOWLAND (IFL)
democracy which remal unchartered. In Stirling, for instance, although the Group leader is chosen by a wide: franchise, the selection ol nominations to civic offices (including chairpersons and vice-chairpersons of committees) still lies firmly in the hands of the Labour Group. And the local party does not have full control over Group discipline and the withdrawal of the whip.
Councillors in Manchester, Bristol, Coventry, Southwark and other areas have had the whip withdrawn for voting against cuts implemented by the Labour Group, despite Party policy locally being against the cuts, and national policy being for 'a united fight... on a firm nocuts position' (ironically, an emergency resolution moved by Ted Knight at the 1980 Annual Conference).
It also emerged very clearly from our discussions on the 22nd that we need reform of the party bodies to which councillors are to be accountable.
In many instances, district parties, county parties, and local government committees are totally unrepresentative. In Lambeth, for example, the majority of the delegates from at least one GMC to the Local Government Committee are also councillors. There is clearly little point in making councillors accountable to another body which they also control!
That apart, these bodies have other unsatisfactory aspects, and one possible solution would be to abolish the two-tier system of representation from GMCs and replace it with direct representation from the wards, union branches, women's sections, etc.
Again, Stirling has done this. According to Labour Group leader Mike Connarty, it has brought greatly increased attendance and improved the representative nature of the District Party.
It must be stressed that democracy and accountability cuts both ways. If we champion accountability, and the local Party agrees that a package of cuts is the only option open to the Labour Group, then progressive councillors will find themselves having to vote for unpalatable decisions.
This would not, of course, stop them from taking the argument out to the local party and the local community, and campaigning against the decision: indeed. it would be essential for them to do so. On particular points of principle where the councillor could never bring him/ herself to support Party policy in the council chamber, s/he would have to consider the option of resigning.
To champion democracy and accountability only when it works in our favour is to play into the hands of the right wing opponents of reform.
The current position on local government reform is that the NEC has established a sub-committee to enquire into amending the model rules and standing orders of Labour Groups, inviting submissions from all party organisation. It then plans to bring forward 'detailed proposals' to the 1981 Annual Conference.
This would appear to be unwise, particularly following the defeat of a motion calling for reform at the recent Scottish Annual Meeting. This defeat was due to the abstention of the TGWU, and in fact not one union has policy on local government democracy yet.
Therefore, any such measures brought before Annual Conference this year are Ikely to be defeated heavily, and the issue will then be buried for three years with the re-introduction of the three year rule for constitutional issues.
If proposals are brought to the 1982 conference instead, it will allow 18 months to mount a rank and file campaign, greatly increasing the chances of success.
The Campaign for Labour Party Democracy is circulating a model constitutional amendment this year which, in many ways, is far more conservative than the rule changes already agreed by either Stirling or London Labour Parties. CLPD is in great danger, in fact, of being left completely behind in the demands for democratic reform of local government structures.
The rearguard action against local government democracy is going to be even more bitter than the arguments over accountability of MPs, if only because instead of one elitist group, the PLP, we have 454 Labour Groups all attempting to preserve their privileged and elitist position. Nevertheless, we must remain confident that we can win this crucial reform.