Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Where to begin

Socialist Organiser no. 38, 4 April 1981 · scan p. 8 · about 1,257 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

Watts the working class arguments of John O'Mah- class's low level of cons- self-determination

VLADIMIR Derer s article in Socialist Organiser 32 raised issues of strategy and tactics that have been the subject of debate in the socialist movement from its early days. He said, "The programme of the left. at any given stage. must correspond to the existing letel of consciousness of the people to whom we are appealing" and that ... people can be organised only around such demand as they are prepared to support"

In his excellent reply, John O'Mahony correctly answered this line of argument by saying that the left must base itself upon "an overall analysis of society and a basic historical programme for the working class to create a socialist society": He went on to explain. in very clear terms, how this involved the use of transitional demands, rooted in the needs of the working class.

I would like to develop these ideas in the form of a critique of Vladimir's method.

In any given struggle the lett has to represent the ANDREW WIARD (REPORT)

Democratic reform is widely ar interests and need of the whole working class as opposed to those of a section of the class. This seemingly abstract statement has profound practical implications. Let us take a very topical issue: import controis. Unfortunately, large sections of the British working class are "prepared to support" and are prepared to "be organised around such demands." And this does, indeed, correspond to the "existing level of consciousness."

But the left has to wage a struggle against the demand for import controls

, the working class

which, in this period of the dominance of the multinationals, is an urg ent and practical necessity in day-to-day struggles.

There are worse examples. The French Communist Party, in calling for an end to immigration, is undoubtedly putting' forward something which "corresponds to the existing consciousness" of big sections of the French working class. But where does this take the French CP and the French working class? Along the racist road of blaming their problems on the immigrant workers!

arguments of John O'Mahony. On the contrary, the concept of transitional demands (and of course the transitional programme) is based upon the recognition of the need to get workers into *real movement' • And is it true that we can complacently say, as Vladimir does (perhaps unwittingly) that anti-Tory battles "are already going on"? There is a crisis of strategy and tactics for the struggle against the Tory government. This crisis is impeding the real movement of workers. There is a growing awareness that traditional methods of struggle (e.g. those which sufficed in the period of capitalist upswing) are inadequate in this present period. Some sections of the class are reluctant to go into action because of this.

The left, through trying to learn from the historic and international experience of the working class, is seeking to resolve that crisis. This means suggesting demands and methods of struggle which are, in many cases, in conflict with the existing level of consciousness. - but it started with a minority This is not living in a fantasy world — it is trying to find a way forward for the real movement of workers. When the left puts forward the idea of factory occupations as a method of struggle against unemployment it is in response to situation where the 'normal' methods have proven to be inadequate. It the oh-so-practical reformists who are holding back the real movement of workers by trying to prevent the adoption of such demands of the grounds

class's low

ciousness.

Moreover, Vladimir's prescriptions cannot really be put into effect. How do we know what are the demands around which workers are "already prepared to struggle"? As O'Mahony demonstrates, this can only be determined in the process of struggle: If we say in advance of the struggle that the workers are unwilling to support certain demands or methods of struggle, even if these correspond to their interests and needs, we are running the risk of holding back the struggle. Thus, far from being • a method which leads to the stimulation of the real movement, Vladimir's "lifeless formulae" are likely to lead to the inhibition of struggle.

self-determination. This involves the suppression of the most elementary civil liberties and the use of torture and other forms of repression. This is not confined to the six counties.

The Prevention of Terrorism Act and other similar measures are in operation in Britain itself.

Yesterday, the British ruling class used these methods over half the world. Every conceivable form of repression has been used to keep the jolly old British empire safe for imperialist exploitation. All this was done to meet a challenge to part of British imperialism's interests. With a record like this, isn't it obvious that when the loss of the whole of its power is posed the British capitalist class will use every method at its disposal.

Unfortunately, the mass of the British working class do not see things in these terms. Bourgeois ideology has mystified the nature of the struggles of the Irish people and other liberation movements. This is why it is doubly important to have solidarity with such struggles as part of the programme of the left.

This not only helps these siruggies, Il also lays the basıs for educating the working class on these questions.

The main problem with the way Vadimir poses the problem is that by the time the British ruling class is actually engaged in extraparliamentary struggle it will probably be too late to convince the working class to respond in kind.

Organiser JOHN WATTS continues the debate on socialis Vladimir Derer's article in Socialist Organiser no.

32.

means coming into conflict with existing consciousness.

But this is not all utopian or living in a fantasy world. Every factory occupation, every militant picket line, every refusal to be intimidated by the police and every militant demonstration, because they are based on the real movement of the working class, can take the workers along this road of understanding.

Finally, I do not think that our differences with Vladimir are anything like as big as he appears to believe. His own practice is in contradiction with his arguments. Vladimir and other comrades of CLPD have played a very important role inside the Labour Party: In the early days of this struggle, it was by no means the case that it "corresponued" to the existing level of 'consciousness of the people" to whom Vladimir and co. were appealing. On the contrary, Vladimir and the other comrades of the CLPD had to wage a long educational struggle to convince people of the relevance, importance and possibility of this struggle. Sometimes, it might have appeared that the comrades of the CLPD were putting forward 'lifeless formulae" and that they lived in a 'fantasy world" when they argued for such things as the mandatory reselection pf MPs.

We are all very glad that Vladimir and his comrades did not lose heart and confine their efforts to those political struggles which corresponded to the existing level of consciousness. Instead they helped to change that consciousness, and the left is in a much better position because they did.

Today, Vladimir is very active in the East European Solidarity Campaign. 1 am not at all convinced that this campaign corresponds to the existing level of consciousness of people in Britain. •I believe that the majority of people in Britain -

----- pull-quotes -----

strategy, with another reply to

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 38

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →